PLFree pilot

Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: teacher answer key

Answers come from the article and its sources. Open answers list what to look for.

Secondary (ages 11 to 16) Ancient world

Back to the worksheets Read the full article ›

  1. 1. Battle fact card
  2. 2. Map task
  3. 3. Timeline
  4. 4. Primary source analysis
  5. 5. Three perspectives
  6. 6. Key terms
  7. 7. Entry and exit tickets
  8. 8. Quiz sheet
Level

Suggested age: 11 to 14

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 1 of 8 · Battle fact card

Battle fact cardThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

When
2 August 216 BC (the traditional date)
Where
The plain by the Aufidus river (today the Ofanto), near the hill town of Cannae in Apulia, southeastern Italy
War
Second Punic War, Rome against Carthage

Context

By the summer of 216 BC the Carthaginian general Hannibal Barca had been fighting in Italy for two years and had wrecked Roman armies at the Trebia and Lake Trasimene. Rome answered with the largest force it had ever fielded, eight legions at once, under the consuls Lucius Aemilius Paullus and Gaius Terentius Varro. The two consuls held the supreme command on alternate days, and they did not agree. On the day of the battle it was Varro's turn, and he led the army across the Aufidus.

500 km
Battle of Cannae: where it happened

The sides

Carthage

Commanders: Hannibal Barca, with his brother Mago and the cavalry commander Hasdrubal

Strength: about 50,000: some 40,000 infantry (Gauls, Spaniards and Africans) and 10,000 cavalry, by Polybius's count

Roman Republic

Commanders: The consuls Gaius Terentius Varro and Lucius Aemilius Paullus

Strength: about 86,000: about 80,000 infantry and just over 6,000 cavalry, by Polybius's count

Result

A crushing Carthaginian victory: Polybius puts the Roman dead at about 70,000, Livy at 48,200. The consul Paullus was killed and Varro escaped. Hannibal lost roughly 5,700 to 8,000 men.

Why it mattered

  • It is the classic example of a double envelopment: a smaller army surrounds and destroys a larger one.
  • It did not win the war: Rome refused to negotiate, raised new armies and avoided pitched battles.
  • Many of Rome's allies in southern Italy went over to Hannibal, among them the rich city of Capua.
  • It is still studied: the German chief of staff Alfred von Schlieffen built his idea of encirclement around it.

Check your understanding

  1. How did the two Roman consuls share the command?

    They held the supreme command on alternate days. On the day of the battle it was Varro's turn.

  2. Which side had more infantry, and which had more cavalry?

    Rome had far more infantry, Hannibal far more cavalry.

  3. Why did Cannae not end the war, even after such a victory?

    Rome refused to negotiate. It raised new armies, wore Hannibal down over the years and finally beat him at Zama in 202 BC.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

Map: © Echoes of Battle (data: Natural Earth, public domain). Positions are approximate.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 2 of 8 · Map task

Map taskThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

12°E13°E14°E15°E16°E17°E18°E40°N41°N42°N1Venusia (Venosa)2Capua3Rome100 km

The star marks the battlefield. Numbers are named.

Battle of Cannae: 41.3°N, 16.1°E

Tasks

  1. The battlefield lies at about 41.3°N, 16.1°E. Use the grid to mark it with a star.

    The star sits a little above the 41°N line, just east of the 16°E line, near the east coast of Italy (see the key map).

  2. After the battle the consul Varro escaped to place 1 with about 70 horsemen, by Polybius's count. Name it.

    Venusia, today Venosa.

  3. Place 2 is the rich city of Campania whose leaders made a treaty with Hannibal after the battle. Name it.

    Capua.

  4. Hannibal's cavalry commander Maharbal begged him to march at once on place 3. Name it, then draw an arrow for the march that never happened.

    Rome. The arrow runs northwest from the battlefield to Rome.

  5. Maharbal said Hannibal could be feasting on the Capitol in Rome within five days. Use the scale bar: about how far is Rome from the battlefield in a straight line?

    About 310 km (accept 280 to 340 km).

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

Map: © Echoes of Battle (data: Natural Earth, public domain). Positions are approximate.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 3 of 8 · Timeline

TimelineThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

Cut out the cards and lay them in the order the events happened, or write the letters in order below.

Correct order: E C G H B D A F

  1. E The two years before 216 BC Hannibal wrecks Roman armies at the Trebia and Lake Trasimene.
  2. C 216 BC The senate puts eight legions into the field at once, which had never been done before.
  3. G 2 August 216 BC, morning On his day of command, Varro leads the army across the Aufidus and forms it facing south.
  4. H 2 August 216 BC The Gauls and Spaniards in the crescent give way, and the legions push into the pocket.
  5. B 2 August 216 BC The African infantry turn inward, and Hasdrubal's cavalry strikes the Roman rear.
  6. D After the battle The senate refuses to ransom the prisoners and sends the Carthaginian envoy Carthalo away.
  7. A Years later The survivors of Cannae, kept in Sicily, become Scipio's fifth and sixth legions.
  8. F 202 BC Scipio's army beats Hannibal at Zama.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 4 of 8 · Primary source analysis

Primary source analysisThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

About the source

The Greek historian Polybius is the closest ancient source for Cannae. Most of the numbers of the armies and of the dead come from him. In this passage (Book 3, chapter 115) he describes the moment the trap closed on the Roman infantry. The English translation is by W. R. Paton, published in 1922.

The Romans, however, following up the Celts and pressing on to the centre and that part of the enemy's line which was giving way, progressed so far that they now had the heavy-armed Africans on both of their flanks. Hereupon the Africans on the right wing facing to the left and then beginning from the right charged upon the enemy's flank, while those on the left faced to the right and dressing by the left, did the same, the situation itself indicating to them how to act. The consequence was that, as Hannibal had designed, the Romans, straying too far in pursuit of the Celts, were caught between the two divisions of the enemy, and they now no longer kept their compact formation but turned singly or in companies to deal with the enemy who was falling on their flanks.

Polybius, The Histories, Book 3, 115. Translated by W. R. Paton (died 1921): Polybius, The Histories, vol. II, Loeb Classical Library, Harvard University Press, 1922, p. 285. penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Polybius/3*.html

Words to know: Celts the Gauls in the center of Hannibal's line. heavy-armed carrying heavy armor and weapons. flanks the sides of an army. dressing by the left lining up their ranks on the men to their left. compact formation close, tight ranks.

Find What does the source say?

  1. Which troops were the Romans following up and pushing back?

    The Celts (Gauls) in the center of Hannibal's line.

  2. Which troops did the Romans end up with on both of their flanks?

    The heavy-armed Africans.

Explain Why? Use what you know.

  1. Polybius writes "as Hannibal had designed". Use the fact card and the article to explain what Hannibal's design was.

    He pushed the Gauls and Spaniards forward in a crescent that gave way, so the Romans pushed into a pocket. Then the Africans on both wings turned inward against the Roman flanks, and the cavalry closed the ring from behind.

  2. Why did the Romans lose their compact formation, and why did that matter?

    Attacked from both sides, they had to turn singly or in small groups to face the enemy on their flanks. The legions had pushed forward packed tight, trusting their weight. Once broken up, they no longer fought as one mass and could be cut down rank by rank.

Evaluate How far can we trust it?

  1. Polybius gives about 70,000 Roman dead and Livy 48,200. Why might ancient historians disagree, and what should we do with such figures?

    They used different authorities, and Livy himself admits that his sources disagreed. Historians compare the sources and give a range, as Britannica does with 55,000 to 70,000. Good answers say that no one knows the exact number.

  2. Polybius is called the closest ancient source for Cannae. Why does that make him useful, and what problem can a source like this still have?

    A writer closer to the events could use earlier accounts and the memories of people alive at the time. But he can still make mistakes: the article shows Polybius running ahead of events on Tarentum. Good answers give one strength and one limit.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

The source: Polybius, The Histories, Book 3, 115. Translated by W. R. Paton (died 1921): Polybius, The Histories, vol. II, Loeb Classical Library, Harvard University Press, 1922, p. 285. The Greek text is ancient, and Paton's translation, published in 1922 after his death in 1921, is in the public domain.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 5 of 8 · Three perspectives

Three perspectivesThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

Read the three short accounts. Then fill in the table for each side.

The neutral narrator

On 2 August 216 BC about 86,000 Romans faced about 50,000 men of Hannibal on the plain by the Aufidus. Hannibal pushed his weaker center forward in a crescent. When the Romans attacked, it fell back slowly, and the legions pressed deeper, packing ever tighter. Then the African infantry turned in on both flanks and the cavalry struck from behind. The ring tightened rank by rank until almost the whole mass was cut down.

Carthage

Hannibal came to Cannae outnumbered and turned that into a trap. He bowed his center of Gauls and Spaniards forward, inviting the Roman infantry to push into it, while his African veterans waited on the wings and his cavalry cleared the Roman horse from the field. Then the Africans wheeled inward and the cavalry sealed the rear. Yet without siege power or reinforcement, Hannibal could not take Rome, and the triumph never became final victory.

Roman Republic

Rome came to Cannae to crush Hannibal by sheer mass, with about 86,000 men under the consuls Varro and Paullus. Trusting their heavy legions, they drove straight at the Carthaginian center, exactly as Hannibal intended. The legions packed so tightly they could barely lift their weapons, and they were surrounded. Paullus was killed, Varro fled and tens of thousands died in one day. Yet the Republic refused to surrender, raised fresh armies and avoided open battle.

QuestionCarthageRoman Republic
What was their plan?Let the center give way, then close in from the wings and the rear.Use their weight to push straight through the center.
What was their strength?Far more cavalry, and African veterans on the wings.Far more infantry: eight legions and as many allies.
What went wrong for them?Without siege power or reinforcement, Hannibal could not take Rome.Packed tight, the legions had no room to fight and were surrounded.
What did the day cost them?Roughly 5,700 to 8,000 men.About 70,000 dead (Polybius) or 48,200 (Livy), and a consul.
What did they do next?Won over Rome's allies in southern Italy, such as Capua.Refused to negotiate, raised new armies and wore Hannibal down.

Think about it

Cannae was one of Rome's worst defeats, yet Rome won the war. Which mattered more in the end, one great victory or the will to keep fighting? Explain with evidence.

Good answers use the fact card: Hannibal won the battle but could not take Rome, while Rome refused to negotiate, raised new armies and won at Zama in 202 BC. Credit a reasoned answer either way.

Accounts based on the article and the battle narration in the Echoes of Battle app.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 6 of 8 · Key terms

Key termsThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

Match each term to its definition. Write the letter next to the number.

Terms

  1. consul H
  2. legion G
  3. cavalry F
  4. crescent C
  5. flank A
  6. double envelopment B
  7. ally E
  8. battle of annihilation D

Definitions

  • A The side of an army or a battle line.
  • B Attacking an enemy from both sides at once, so that it is surrounded.
  • C A curved shape like a new moon.
  • D A battle in which one army is not just driven off but destroyed.
  • E A people or city that fights on the same side.
  • F Soldiers who fight on horseback.
  • G A large unit of the Roman army, at Cannae about 5,000 citizens.
  • H One of the two highest Roman officials, who led the army.

Use two of the terms in one sentence about the battle.

Open answer. Accept any thoughtful reply.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 7 of 8 · Entry and exit tickets

Entry and exit ticketsThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

Entry ticket Before the lesson · Battle of Cannae

  1. Which two powers fought each other at Cannae?

    Rome and Carthage.

  2. What is cavalry?

    Soldiers who fight on horseback.

  3. In which country is Cannae?

    Italy (Apulia, in the southeast).

Reflection

How could a smaller army beat a bigger one?

Open answer. Accept any thoughtful reply.

Exit ticket After the lesson · Battle of Cannae

  1. What shape did Hannibal give the center of his line?

    A crescent bulging toward the enemy, made of Gauls and Spaniards.

  2. What closed the ring behind the Romans?

    Hannibal's cavalry, after it had driven the Roman horse from the field.

  3. Where did Rome finally beat Hannibal?

    At Zama in 202 BC.

Reflection

Why is a battle from 216 BC still studied by soldiers today?

Open answer. Accept any thoughtful reply.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.

Echoes of BattleWorksheet 8 of 8 · Quiz sheet

Quiz sheetThe Battle of Cannae, 2 August 216 BC

Answer key for the teacher

Circle the letter of the one correct answer.

  1. Why did the Carthaginian commander deliberately push his weaker center forward, knowing the Romans would attack head-on?

    • A The center was to distract from the main attack by hidden troops from behind
    • B It was a tactical mistake that happened to turn out well
    • C The center was to fall back slowly, drawing the packed Romans into a trap
    • D He wanted to give up the center quickly and withdraw across the Aufidus

    C. Why: Hannibal deliberately pushed his weaker center forward, knowing Rome would attack head-on. The center fell back slowly as planned, drawing the legions ever deeper. The crowded masses lost their ability to maneuver, exactly what Hannibal was waiting for.

  2. What role did the Carthaginian cavalry play in closing the trap at Cannae?

    • A After routing the Roman horse it struck the legions' rear, closing the ring
    • B It cut the Roman supply lines, forcing the army to surrender from hunger
    • C It overran the Roman camp, seizing supplies and the legions' standards
    • D It charged the Roman center head-on, smashing the legions

    A. Why: Hasdrubal's Spanish and Celtic horse on the left wing cut down most of the Roman cavalry by the river, then crossed to the far wing, where the allied horse broke and fled. Hasdrubal then struck the rear of the legions, already pinned on both flanks by the African infantry. The ring tightened rank by rank until almost the whole mass was cut down.

  3. Why did Rome's larger army become a weakness at Cannae?

    • A Their superiority led them to fight in loose order, without any formation
    • B The bigger army needed more food, and the Romans fought hungry
    • C Packed in the center, the legionaries lost mobility and could not wield their weapons
    • D The Romans left all their cavalry in camp and relied on infantry alone

    C. Why: The deeper the legions pushed into the retreating center, the more tightly they were packed. The Roman host could barely lift its weapons as the African wings and the enemy cavalry closed around it. Their numerical superiority turned into a deadly trap.

  4. Why did Cannae not win the war for the Carthaginian commander?

    • A The Italian cities rebelled against him right after the battle
    • B Rome immediately offered him peace on favorable terms
    • C He lost too many of his own men and lacked strength for further campaigning
    • D He had no siege engines, and Carthage sent him few reinforcements

    D. Why: Polybius gives about 70,000 Roman dead, Livy about 48,000. Hannibal was a master of the battlefield, but without siege engines he did not march on Rome, and only small reinforcements reached him from Carthage. Rome refused to negotiate, rebuilt its army, and Scipio Africanus carried the war to Africa.

  5. What irony links the Roman victory at Zama in 202 BC to the defeat at Cannae?

    • A Survivors of Cannae, exiled to Sicily, served in the army that won at Zama
    • B Zama was fought on the same plain as Cannae
    • C The consul who fled from Cannae commanded the Roman army at Zama
    • D Carthage fought at Zama with Roman prisoners taken at Cannae

    A. Why: The senate shipped the soldiers who had fled from Cannae to Sicily and kept them there in disgrace. Scipio Africanus, knowing the defeat had not been their fault, made them his fifth and sixth legions and took them to Africa. That army beat Hannibal at Zama in 202 BC.

  6. How did the Roman system of two consuls commanding on alternate days help cause the disaster?

    • A Both consuls issued conflicting orders at once, throwing the legions into chaos
    • B One consul fled before the battle, leaving the other with half an army
    • C The system had no effect, since both consuls wanted battle
    • D The consuls alternated command, and the more aggressive consul gave battle on his day

    D. Why: According to Polybius and Livy the consuls commanded on alternate days, and on the morning of the battle it was Varro's turn. Varro, whom Polybius dismisses as inexperienced, wanted to close with the enemy and led the army across the Aufidus. The more cautious Paullus was killed in the fighting.

  7. Why did the Carthaginian commander not attack Rome after Cannae, and what long-term consequences did this decision have?

    • A He did not realize how badly Rome had been weakened by the defeat at Cannae
    • B His mercenaries mutinied over back pay and refused to march north
    • C The Romans paid him a ransom in silver, and in return he withdrew from Italy
    • D He lacked siege power and reinforcement, and turned to winning over Rome's allies

    D. Why: Without siege power or reinforcement, Hannibal could not take Rome itself. Livy says Maharbal begged him to march on the city at once, but Hannibal asked for time to think and set out instead to break Rome's alliances in southern Italy. Rome refused to negotiate, raised new armies and finally beat him at Zama in 202 BC.

Sources: Based on the Echoes of Battle article “The Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap”, echoesofbattle.com/blog/battle-of-cannae, which cites: Polybius, Histories, Book 3. Livy, History of Rome, Book 22. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Battle of Cannae”. Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae. Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War.

Questions from the battle quiz in the Echoes of Battle app.

© Echoes of Battle, echoesofbattle.com. Free to print for your lessons.