What happened at the Battle of Karnal?
On 24 February 1739 Nader Shah, ruler of Iran, defeated the army of the Mughal emperor Muhammad Shah on the plain east of Karnal, north of Delhi. The Mughals had dug in behind a mud wall. When Persian raiders fell on the baggage of Saadat Khan, governor of Oudh, he rode out with a small force, and the commander in chief Khan Dauran followed him. Both were lured into an ambush and cut down by Persian musket fire. Saadat Khan was captured and Khan Dauran mortally wounded, while the rest of the army stood by. Within weeks Nader held the emperor and Delhi.5
Encyclopaedia Iranica names the Mughals among the opponents whose defeat made Nader’s reputation as a commander, and Indian historians, as Ernest Tucker notes, see the invasion it opened as a blow from which the Mughal dynasty never truly recovered. The rest of that day is told in 24 February in military history, and the wider story of war in the subcontinent in our guide to the battles of India.6
From Khorasan to the throne of Iran
Nader was born in 1688 into a poor Turkmen family of the Afshar tribe in Khorasan, in north-eastern Iran. He rose as a frontier warlord in the chaos that followed the Afghan conquest of Isfahan in 1722, and the Safavid claimant Tahmasp II took him into his service and made him his principal commander. As Tahmasp-qoli, the servant of Tahmasp, he drove the Afghans out of Iran in 1729.7

He then pushed back the Ottomans in the west. When Tahmasp lost part of those gains in a campaign of his own, Nader deposed him in August 1732 and ruled as regent for his infant son. In early 1736 he called the leading men of the realm to the Mughan steppe, where they proclaimed him shah. Encyclopaedia Iranica dates his coronation to 8 March 1736, and Sarkar, in the Old Style calendar, to 26 February.8

The Victoria and Albert Museum holds a portrait of him painted in northern India, possibly in Delhi, about 1740, signed by Muhammad Panah. Its inscription calls him the King of Kings, and the museum notes another version, dated 1742, in the Bodleian Library in Oxford.9
Why Nader turned on India
In 1737 Nader marched on Kandahar, the last stronghold of the Ghilzai Afghans who had ruined the Safavid state. Sarkar gives him 80,000 men for the campaign. The siege lasted about a year, and the city fell in March 1738. Many Afghans then joined his army.10
Afghans fleeing Kandahar crossed into Mughal territory towards Ghazni and Kabul. Nader had asked the court of Delhi to close the frontier to them, and by Sarkar’s account the emperor Muhammad Shah twice promised to do so. A third envoy was sent in 1737 and was then kept in Delhi for about a year with no answer. Iranica sees the pursuit of the Afghans growing into an invasion when Nader accused the Mughals of sheltering them.11
The Mughal Empire was ill prepared. Sarkar describes a court split between factions, a Kabul garrison whose pay was five years in arrears, and Maratha raids that had reached the suburbs of Delhi in 1737. The chronicler Rustam Ali, writing soon after the invasion, blamed the emperor’s distrust of his own ministers: whatever Khan Dauran proposed, the Nizam ul-Mulk opposed, and the other way round.12
Kabul, the Khyber and Lahore
Nader crossed the Mughal frontier in May 1738. Sarkar records that Ghazni opened its gates without a fight and that the citadel of Kabul surrendered in June, after the Persian guns had brought down part of its wall. In November, near the Khyber Pass, 20,000 Afghans raised by the Mughal governor Nasir Khan waited for him. Nader left his baggage, led his cavalry by a little-used mountain route and fell on them from an unexpected side. Sarkar puts the march at fifty miles, Lockhart at some 48, and both record Nasir Khan taken prisoner.13
The Persians crossed the Indus on a bridge of boats at Attock and forded the rivers of the Punjab, which were low at that season. Zakariya Khan, governor of Lahore, resisted for a short time in January 1739 and then submitted. He handed over 20 lakhs of rupees, which spared the city, and Nader left him in office. Encyclopaedia Iranica notes that Nader often confirmed Mughal governors who submitted in this way.14
The walled camp at Karnal
The Mughal army left the outskirts of Delhi slowly. Lockhart writes that it took a month to cover the four stages from the Shalimar gardens to Karnal. The emperor himself reached Panipat on 7 February and Karnal a few days later. The commanders chose the plain just north of the town because the Ali Mardan canal gave water and a belt of jungle covered its front, and they wanted to wait for Saadat Khan, governor of Oudh, and his contingent.15

The camp was walled with earth and the guns were mounted along it. Mirza Zaman, quoted by Lockhart, put its circuit at fourteen miles, and Hanway at twelve. The chronicler Muhammad Muhsin Sadiqi wrote that the head of the artillery chained the heavy guns together into an iron fortress five parasangs round. Anand Ram Mukhlis, who marched with the army as far as Panipat, thought the plan hardly worthy of an emperor.16
Karnal sits on the old road from Delhi to Lahore. Sarkar places it about 75 miles north of the capital, 20 miles north of Panipat and nine miles south of Taraori, the field of the Second Battle of Tarain in 1192. The Imperial Gazetteer of India of 1908 records that in 1739 the town saw the defeat of Muhammad Shah by Nader Shah, while its entry on the district gives the year as 1738.17
Two armies, two ways of war
No figure for either army is secure. Nader’s court historian Mirza Mahdi gave the Mughals 300,000 men, 2,000 elephants and 3,000 guns, and Rustam Ali 200,000 horse with foot soldiers without number and 1,500 elephants. Sarkar argued that the Mughal fighting force could not have exceeded 75,000, and Lockhart thought the lowest figure in the sources, 80,000, close to the truth. With servants, families and traders, both accept that the camp may have held nearly a million people.18
For Nader’s side Sarkar prefers Rustam Ali’s 55,000 horse, while A. L. Srivastava, the historian of the nawabs of Oudh, puts the Persian fighting force at about 65,000 horse. Hanway, writing from accounts that reached Persia, says about 50,000 of Nader’s troops took part in the action.19
The real difference was firepower. Nader’s army was all mounted, and much of it carried the jazayir, a heavy long musket fired from a forked rest, which Sarkar describes as seven or eight feet long. He also describes swivel guns carried on camels that knelt at command, and volleys held until the word was given. Mughal armies relied on the charge of heavy cavalry, war elephants and big, slow guns. Encyclopaedia Iranica credits the rapid fire of the jazayirchis and the camel guns with the victory.20
Nader’s march round the camp
From Lahore Nader marched by Sirhind and Ambala, left his baggage and harem at Ambala and pressed on with a light force. Kurdish scouts under Hajji Khan reached the Mughal lines first, killed some men and brought back prisoners. On 22 February Nader reached Sarai Azimabad, twelve miles north of Karnal, where the governor of Ambala resisted for a time.21
There he learned of the camp’s strength and of the jungle in front of it, crossed by a single narrow road. He chose to go round to the east. If Muhammad Shah came out, he would fight him on the open plain between Karnal and the Jumna, some seven miles wide. If the emperor stayed behind his walls, the Persians would march on to Panipat and Delhi.22
On 23 February the army crossed the Ali Mardan canal and camped near Kunjpura, north-east of Karnal. Nader rode up close to the Mughal lines with part of his guard to look at them. That evening scouts reported that Saadat Khan had reached Panipat, and a strong force was sent to intercept him.23
Saadat Khan’s baggage
Saadat Khan slipped past them and reached the imperial camp about midnight, but his baggage train straggled behind. On the morning of 24 February, while he was paying his respects to the emperor, word came that the Persians were plundering it. Saadat Khan, who could not ride because of a leg wound, took hurried leave and rushed out despite all efforts to hold him back. Srivastava, who counts the days differently, dates this to 23 February.24
His troops, worn out by a month of forced marches, were slow to follow. Srivastava counts 1,000 horse and a few hundred foot with him at first, and nearly 4,000 cavalry and 1,000 infantry who joined him in the end. Anand Ram condemned his “headlong impetuosity misplaced in a commander”. He went without his artillery and without forming his men in any order.25
The Persian patrols he met fled before him, and he followed, sending back for reinforcements. Sarkar and Lockhart both write that the Nizam ul-Mulk advised the emperor to send Khan Dauran, whose wing was nearest. Anand Ram says Khan Dauran first objected that the army had not expected to fight that day, and that the emperor called him a conceited idler before he mounted his elephant and went. He took between 8,000 and 9,000 horse by Lockhart’s count, while Rustam Ali heard of 7,000 or of 20,000.26
The ambush on the plain
Nader had hoped for exactly this. He put on a coat of mail and a helmet and took 1,000 picked Afshar horsemen to direct the fight. He placed 3,000 men in ambush and sent out two bodies of musketeers, 500 each, to draw the enemy on. Hanway adds that he had platforms of naphtha fixed across pairs of camels and set alight to frighten the Mughal elephants.27
The battle began about one o’clock in the afternoon. Saadat Khan’s men, now the Mughal right, ran by Lockhart’s account into the musketeers of Fath Ali Khan Kayani, posted behind the walls and buildings of Kunjpura. Srivastava describes the Persian horsemen drawing aside and many hundreds of swivel guns firing in volleys. Khan Dauran’s division came into action a little later against Nasrullah Mirza in the Persian centre.28

The Mughal divisions were far apart. Sarkar and Lockhart both describe gaps of more than a mile between them, so that each heard the firing of the others but could not help. The generals, high on their elephants, made easy targets. The chronicler Abdul Karim summed it up, in Lockhart’s rendering: “An arrow cannot answer a jazayir.”29
Saadat Khan’s men were the first to give way. He fought on with a few followers until the elephant of his nephew Sher Jang, maddened by a wound, charged his own and carried it into the Persian ranks. Sarkar tells, after the Siyar, how a young soldier from Saadat Khan’s home town of Nishapur called him by his name, climbed up into the howdah and took his surrender.30
Khan Dauran’s stand and the idle wing
Khan Dauran’s division held out longer. By Sarkar’s account, when most officers had fallen, about 1,000 of his men dismounted, tied the skirts of their coats together in the Indian fashion and fought on foot until they died. Anand Ram saw the field differently, with swords and daggers in play and the red caps of the Qizilbash looking like poppies in the smoke.31
Khan Dauran was wounded, then shot in the face, and fell unconscious in his howda. His brother Muzaffar Khan and a son were killed. His steward Majlis Rai and a few retainers fought their way back to the camp with his elephant near sunset. Lockhart puts the end of the battle at five o’clock, and Srivastava just after five.32
The rest of the army did nothing. The emperor and the wazir drew up beside the canal with field guns and never engaged. The Nizam ul-Mulk, the most experienced general on the Mughal side, stayed idle all day. Lockhart repeats the story that he sat on his elephant drinking coffee when the emperor urged him forward, and Sarkar suggests he hoped to take his rivals’ places at court. Rustam Ali and Muhammad Muhsin Sadiqi both blamed the Nizam for leaving Khan Dauran without help.33
Nader did not storm the fortified camp and its heavy guns. Lockhart thought him too prudent to try, and at sunset, Srivastava writes, the emperor went back inside his lines.34
Counting the dead
Mirza Mahdi claimed 30,000 Mughal dead, and Nader wrote of more than 20,000 in a letter meant to be copied across his empire. Hanway heard of 17,000. Lockhart thinks the Mughals may have lost some 10,000 men, and Encyclopaedia Iranica gives the same figure. Sarkar, adding Rustam Ali’s 5,000 for Khan Dauran’s division to at least 3,000 for Saadat Khan’s, arrives at about 8,000.35
For the Persians, Hanway gives 2,500 killed and nearly twice as many wounded, and Lockhart, who found the same figures in a contemporary letter, thought them on the high side. At the other extreme Shaikh Ali Hazin, then in Delhi, claimed only three Persians killed and twenty wounded, a figure both historians reject.36
From the battlefield to the emperor’s tent
That night Saadat Khan was brought before Nader and advised him to summon the Nizam ul-Mulk to discuss terms. Lockhart quotes Khan Dauran, dying, telling the nobles who came to his tent not to let the emperor meet Nader or take him to Delhi. Lockhart and Srivastava date his death to 25 February, while other sources give the 27th or the 28th.37
The Nizam agreed with Nader that the Persians would go home for an indemnity of 50 lakhs of rupees, paid in instalments. On 26 February by Lockhart’s dates, the 25th by Srivastava’s, Muhammad Shah visited Nader’s camp. Lockhart writes that the two rulers talked in Turki, and that Nader exchanged dishes with his guest at the start of the meal to show the food was not poisoned. Encyclopaedia Iranica describes the visit as an act of submission.38
Meanwhile the camp was blockaded and food ran out. Anand Ram writes that four rupees could hardly buy a seer of flour. When the Nizam took the office of paymaster that Saadat Khan had wanted, Saadat Khan urged Nader to march on Delhi and its treasure. Rustam Ali blames him for the disasters that followed. In early March the emperor went to the Persian camp again and was held there under guard, while his soldiers were told they could go home.39
Delhi, the massacre and the Peacock Throne
The two rulers left Karnal on 12 March, and Nader entered Delhi on 20 March. On 21 March the sermon at prayers was read and coins were struck in his name. That evening a rumour spread that he had been killed, and crowds attacked his soldiers in the streets. Lockhart thinks some 3,000 Persians died, while Rustam Ali speaks of 5,000.40
By Lockhart’s account, at sunrise on 22 March Nader rode to the Roshan ud-Daula mosque and ordered that no one be left alive wherever a Persian had been killed. The killing lasted from nine in the morning until three in the afternoon, when the Nizam and the wazir begged him to stop. Estimates of the dead range from 8,000 to 400,000. Sarkar’s figure of about 20,000 is accepted by Lockhart and by Encyclopaedia Iranica.41
Nader then took the treasure of the Mughals. Lockhart puts the whole at no less than 70 crores of rupees, 700 million, with the Peacock Throne and the Koh-i-Noor diamond the most famous pieces. Encyclopaedia Iranica adds the Darya-ye Nur, the other great diamond of the booty, which its entry on the stone places in the jewel museum of Iran’s central bank. On 12 May Nader placed the crown of Hindustan back on Muhammad Shah’s head with his own hands, and the emperor ceded the lands west of the Indus.42
The wealth paid for Nader’s next campaigns. He exempted Iran from taxes for three years, as both Lockhart and Iranica record. Lockhart traces the Koh-i-Noor after his murder in 1747 through Ahmad Shah Durrani and Ranjit Singh to the East India Company, which presented it to Queen Victoria in 1850.43
What Karnal changed
Muhammad Shah kept his throne until 1748, and the Cleveland Museum of Art, which holds a portrait of him made in 1764, notes that he was known as Rangila, the Colorful. But the empire he kept was smaller and poorer. Encyclopaedia Iranica lists the plunder, the loss of the north-western provinces and the blow to Mughal military power among the causes of its long decline, with Maratha raids and the sacks of Delhi by Ahmad Shah Abdali, once one of Nader’s commanders, to follow.44
In Iran the campaign was remembered as Nader’s crowning achievement. Ernest Tucker writes that some Iranian historians see it that way, while in Indian memory, Iranica notes, the word Naderšāhi became a byword for massacre. The struggles for northern India that followed, from Plassey to the Third Battle of Panipat, were fought in the world Karnal had made.45






