What happened at the Battle of Montgisard?
The Kingdom of Jerusalem won the Battle of Montgisard on 25 November 1177, defeating Saladin, who had invaded from Egypt while much of its army was away in the north. The sixteen-year-old King Baldwin IV, a leper, left Ascalon with a small force, joined the Templars of Gaza and surprised Saladin near Ramla, while many of his men were scattered plundering. Saladin’s guard was cut down and he barely escaped. His army fled through the desert to Egypt in winter rain, losing men all the way.5
R. C. Smail called Montgisard the heaviest defeat of Saladin’s career, and Saladin himself, as Ibn Shaddad remembered, said that only Hattin made good the disaster. The rest of that day is told in 25 November in military history, and the wider story in our guide to the Crusades.6
A leper king and a sultan
Baldwin IV was thirteen when he was crowned king of Jerusalem in July 1174, after his father Amalric died. He had leprosy, and Bernard Hamilton describes it as the lepromatous form, the most deadly. The Old French chronicle attributed to Ernoul introduces him simply as the king who was a leper.7

In the same year Nur ad-Din, ruler of Syria, died, and Saladin, who already ruled Egypt, set about taking over his lands. Hamilton compares the result to a giant nutcracker closing round the Latin kingdom. By 1177 Saladin ruled Damascus through his brother Turan Shah as well as Cairo, and Lane-Poole reproduces a silver coin he struck at Damascus that year.8
The army that went north
In 1177 Count Philip of Flanders arrived with a crusading army. A joint attack on Egypt was planned and came to nothing, and the count was persuaded to campaign in the north instead. Around the beginning of October he left for Tripoli with Count Raymond of Tripoli, the master of the Hospital and many Templars. William of Tyre adds that the king gave him 100 knights and 2,000 foot soldiers.9
In November the northern army attacked Hama for four days and then laid siege to Harim, a fortress near Antioch. Ibn al-Athir and Abu Shama both record the attack on Hama, and Hamilton notes that Raymond had been taken prisoner at Harim in 1164 and held for ten years.10
Saladin comes out of Egypt
Saladin saw his chance. William of Tyre writes that he expected either to draw the Franks away from Harim or to do as he liked in a kingdom stripped of its knights. He crossed the desert to al-Arish, which William calls Laris, left his heavy baggage there, and went on with his best-mounted men past the Frankish forts of Darum and Gaza towards Ascalon.11
The sources disagree on the day he reached Ascalon. Ibn al-Athir gives 18 November, and Abu Shama the Wednesday before the battle. Hamilton prefers 22 November, which fits William of Tyre’s account better.12
Shut in at Ascalon
Warned a few days ahead, Baldwin gathered what knights remained and entered Ascalon before Saladin arrived. His constable, Humphrey of Toron, was gravely ill. The Templars who had stayed in the kingdom had shut themselves up in Gaza, expecting Saladin to besiege it first. Hamilton writes that the campaign was in practice directed by Raynald of Châtillon, the former prince of Antioch, recently ransomed from captivity in Aleppo. Röhricht, writing a century earlier, also gives Raynald the supreme command.13
Baldwin also called the arrière-ban, the summons of every man able to bear arms. Ernoul says that before it could gather, Saladin appeared before Ascalon and caught the burgesses of Jerusalem and others as they came in, tying them onto camels to be sold. Hamilton reads the use of the summons, very seldom invoked, as a sign of how desperate things looked.14
The king led his men out once, but the more experienced among them judged it safer to stay near the walls than to attack such a host. William of Tyre describes skirmishing until evening and a return to the city. Smail sees in this a king who would not fight against heavy odds, but who would soon prefer battle to the unchecked ruin of his subjects.15
Raiders across the plain
Saladin left the Franks in Ascalon and let his army spread over the country. William of Tyre writes that his men rode in bands without order, as men who feared nothing. A renegade named Ivelin, an Armenian by the French version, burned Ramla, whose people had fled to Jaffa, Ascalon or the hill castle of Mirabel. He then attacked Lydda, where the townspeople took refuge in the church of St George. Imad ad-Din, quoted by Abu Shama, adds that before Ascalon the sultan’s men plundered and took prisoners, and that Saladin had the captives gathered and beheaded.16
Panic reached Jerusalem. William records that the citizens thought of abandoning the city and crowding into the Tower of David, and that raiders came as far as a place called Calcalia. The letter from the Hospital says that the people of Jerusalem took communion together as men about to die and entrusted the tower and the city to the women, so few men were left.17
The march along the coast
Baldwin decided to fight. He left Ascalon and followed the coast so as to come on the enemy suddenly and unseen. The Templars from Gaza joined him on the way. Hamilton notes that Saladin, sure that the Franks would not leave Ascalon, had not even posted men to watch it.18
Ernoul tells it differently. In his version Saladin stayed three days before Ascalon and then moved on to the town of St George, seven leagues away, while the king followed and camped two leagues from him at the castle of Ibelin. The next morning, he writes, the Saracens set out for Jerusalem.19

Abu Shama, quoting Saladin’s secretary Imad ad-Din, says that the sultan meant to attack a Frankish fortress and found a river in his way below Tell Safiya. His baggage was crossing and blocked the passage when the Frankish squadrons suddenly appeared. Ibn al-Athir tells the same story of a river crossing interrupted.20
Who stood with the king
William of Tyre names the men around the king. Odo of St Amand, master of the Temple, with eighty brothers, Prince Raynald, Baldwin of Ramla and his brother Balian, Raynald of Sidon, and Count Joscelin, the king’s uncle and seneschal. Ernoul adds the young brothers Hugh and William of Tiberias, stepsons of the count of Tripoli. Albert, bishop of Bethlehem, carried the relic of the True Cross before them.21
The famous figure of the battle comes from the same chapter. All of them, of every rank, William writes, were scarcely 375. Ernoul gives 500 knights, and Röhricht lists other medieval estimates of 3,000, 7,000 and 20,000 men, or even 30,000. Hamilton thinks William’s figure a deliberate underestimate, but adds that Saladin’s decision to ignore the royal army shows it really was small.22
On the other side, William says that he learned from careful inquiry of many witnesses that Saladin had brought 26,000 light horse into the kingdom, besides those riding pack animals and camels. Of these 8,000 were picked troops he calls Toassin, and 18,000 ordinary horsemen he calls Caragolam. Ernoul gives Saladin 60,000 horsemen, and some of his manuscripts 40,000.23
The clash below Mont Gisard
It was about the eighth hour of the day, which Hamilton reads as about two in the afternoon, when the Christians saw the enemy close ahead. Saladin had trumpets and drums sounded to call in the scattered bands, and William writes that the closer the Franks came, the more the Muslim ranks grew as the raiders hurried back.24
Ibn Shaddad, quoted by Abu Shama, records Saladin’s own explanation. As the enemy approached, someone near him had the right wing wheel towards the left and the left towards the centre, so that the army would have a hill at its back. The Franks charged while the troops were still moving, and routed them. Hamilton credits Raynald with aiming the main charge at Saladin’s centre during that manoeuvre.25
Ernoul gives the first blow to the Ibelins. Baldwin of Ramla asked the king for the first joust because the battle was on his own land, and with his brother Balian he broke the strongest Saracen division. He writes that Roland and Oliver never did as many feats of arms at Roncesvalles as the two brothers did that day, with the help of St George, whose church at Lydda the Saracens had wrecked the night before.26

Imad ad-Din says that Saladin’s nephew Taqi al-Din stood firm and fought hard. His son Ahmad, barely out of boyhood, was killed after bringing down a knight. Ibn al-Athir adds that his father sent him back into the fight a second time.27
Saladin’s escape
The sultan was nearly taken. Ibn al-Athir writes that a Frank came so close to him that he almost reached him before he was killed under Saladin’s eyes. Abu Shama preserves Saladin’s own account of a knight charging at him with his lance aimed at his chest, followed by two companions, until three of his officers rode at them and struck them down.28
William of Tyre describes a guard of 1,000 men in saffron surcoats over their mail, the sultan’s own colour, whom the Turks call Mamluks. They stood round their lord until he fled, and nearly all of them died. Lane-Poole adds that Saladin escaped on a swift camel, a detail the other sources read here do not give.29
Ibn al-Athir says Saladin retreated slowly at first, stopping to let his men catch up, until night fell. Hamilton notes that the Frankish prisoners of the arrière-ban, tied in the baggage train, took advantage of the confusion, broke free and killed their guards.30
Into the marsh and the desert
The Franks pursued until night, from the place called Mons Gisardi to a marsh known as the Canebrake of Starlings. The Latin text of William of Tyre gives the distance as twelve miles or more, and the Old French translation as two miles or more. The fugitives threw their mail and helmets into the marsh, but the Franks came back the next day and probed it with poles and hooks. Trustworthy men told William that a hundred mail coats were pulled out in a single day.31
The next day it began to rain and went on for ten days, with unusual cold. William writes that the fugitives had lost their horses and thrown away their clothes, and that many, not knowing the country, walked into villages and gave themselves up. Bedouin plundered Saladin’s base at al-Arish, Hamilton notes, so the survivors had little to eat on the way home.32
Saladin went back through the sands without water or guides, Imad ad-Din recalled, and many men vanished. The jurist Isa al-Hakkari and his brother lost their way, were betrayed by a false guide and spent years in captivity. Ibn al-Athir puts Isa’s ransom at 60,000 dinars, and Abu Shama at 60,000 or 70,000.33
Saladin reached Cairo on 8 December 1177. Imad ad-Din, who was there, remembered how the couriers announced that the sultan was safe, and how he told his companion that if safety was the good news, then it was a complete defeat. Ibn al-Athir saw a letter Saladin wrote to his brother in Damascus, opening with a verse about thinking of him while the spears were drinking their blood.34
Counting the armies and the dead
William of Tyre writes that four or five Christian knights fell in the first clash, and an unknown number of foot soldiers. The Old French text says six. The letter of Raymond of the Hospital gives a very different picture: 1,100 Christians killed and 750 badly wounded, taken into the Hospital in Jerusalem. Röhricht notes that it survives as a kind of pass for a wounded soldier.35
The same letter claims that from 3,000 Christians the Franks killed 19,000 of the enemy and captured 15,000, figures no other source read here supports. It also tells how the cross appeared to the Saracens to grow from the earth to the sky. Hamilton uses the 1,100 dead to argue that the Frankish army was far bigger than 375. Röhricht, who set the medieval estimates side by side in 1898, had already called William’s figure obviously too low.36
Where was Mont Gisard?
Charles Clermont-Ganneau, who explored Palestine in 1873 and 1874, identified the hill of Tell el-Jezer, the biblical Gezer, with the crusaders’ Mont Gisard, a castle and fief of the county of Jaffa. He argued that the battle was fought there and that a priory of St Catherine of Mont Gisard was founded on the spot. He thought the skeletons found at the south-western end of the tell, apparently buried after a battle, very likely came from 1177.37
Conder and Lane-Poole followed him, and Hamilton places Saladin’s army at the hill of Mont Gisard, or Tell Jazar, near Ibelin, rejecting another site proposed by Lyons and Jackson. Imad ad-Din’s river below Tell Safiya, which the editor of Abu Shama places in the district of Ramla near Beit Jibrin, points to a different spot, so the Muslim and Christian accounts are not easy to fit together.38
After the victory
The king returned to Ascalon, waited four days for his men to come back loaded with plunder, and went up to Jerusalem to give thanks. Hamilton writes that the Franks built a Benedictine priory on the battlefield, dedicated to St Catherine of Alexandria, on whose feast the battle had been fought.39
Saladin recovered fast. Lane-Poole writes that he was ready to meet the Franks again within three months. Imad ad-Din insisted that Ramla had been a defeat for the Muslims in appearance and for the infidels in reality. Two years later, Smail notes, a master of the Temple was blamed for the disaster at Marj Ayyun, and in 1187 Saladin destroyed the Frankish army at Hattin, ten years after Montgisard, as Abu Shama observed.40
Hamilton notes that Baldwin IV remained king until his death in 1185. In the 1840s Louis-Philippe filled the new Crusades Rooms at Versailles with 125 paintings, and Larivière’s large canvas of the battle, shown above, hangs there under the title of the Battle of Ascalon, 18 November 1177. The story of the sultan who lost here and won ten years later is told in our biography of Saladin.41






