Saladin or Richard: what does the evidence say?
Saladin (about 1138 to 1193), sultan of Egypt and Syria, and Richard I of England, the Lionheart (1157 to 1199), fought each other through their armies for fifteen months in the Third Crusade, from Acre in June 1191 to the truce of September 1192. They never met in person: Saladin refused, and his brother al-Adil negotiated in his place. Historians are split. Asbridge describes Hosler's book as a sustained criticism of Saladin's supposed failings as a commander, and answers it. Lane-Poole in 1898 put magnanimity and real chivalry on the Saracen side, and called Richard's rescue of Jaffa a glow of setting glory over his crusade. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The legend of a duel between the two kings is old. An English psalter of the fourteenth century shows Richard unhorsing Saladin with his lance. It never happened. Saladin, wrote his biographer Stanley Lane-Poole in 1898, certainly never encountered Richard on the field of battle, and a modern reference work agrees that in fact they never actually met.1
This is not a ranking. Below are the two careers side by side, the campaign in which they faced each other, and six questions on which a commander can be judged, each with the strongest evidence for Saladin and for Richard, the words of the chroniclers on both sides and those of the historians who still argue about them. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
- Lived
- About 1138 to 1193
- 8 September 1157 to 6 April 1199
- Origin
- Tikrit, a Kurdish family, son of Ayyub
- Oxford, third son of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine
- Rule
- Vizier of Egypt from 1169, then ruler of Egypt and Syria, founder of the Ayyubid dynasty
- King of England from 1189
- Against each other
- June 1191 to September 1192
- June 1191 to September 1192
- Victories named here
- Hattin and Jerusalem, 1187, Jaffa town, 1192
- Acre and Arsuf, 1191, the relief of Jaffa, 1192
- Did they meet?
- No. He refused a meeting before a treaty
- No. He met Saladin's brother al-Adil instead
- Death
- Damascus, aged about 55
- Of a wound taken at the siege of Châlus
Dates and titles from the Treccani encyclopedia, the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography and Gale’s reference works. No source we read gives a win and loss total for either man, so we give none. No authentic portrait of Saladin survives, so we show neither man.2
Where they met: the Third Crusade, 1191 and 1192
From Hattin to Acre, 1187 to 1191
Saladin had won the kingdom of Jerusalem in 1187. The Latin chronicle known as the Capture of the Holy Land by Saladin tells how the Frankish army marched out on Friday 3 July against the warning of the Count of Tripoli that in that heat they could not survive half a day without plenty of water. At Hattin, desperate for water and harassed by fires set in the brush, the army broke up. Its infantry climbed to the top of a hill and, when ordered back, answered that they were dying of thirst. In the chronicler's words, more blood than water flowed that night.3
Jerusalem followed. Hadia Dajani-Shakeel, comparing the Arabic and Latin accounts, writes that Ibn al-Athir has Saladin at first threatening to treat the city as the crusaders had treated it in 1099, by death and captivity. The French chronicle of Ernoul, she notes, has Saladin earlier letting Balian of Ibelin into the city under safe conduct to fetch his family, and later telling him, when Balian came to ask for terms: why are you proposing to surrender the city, we have already captured it. Balian offered 30,000 dinars for the poor, and the city surrendered on 2 October 1187, according to the chronicler Imad ad-Din. Ibn al-Athir called the recovery of Jerusalem a deed achieved by no one since the caliph Umar except Saladin.4
The crusaders had been besieging Acre since 1189 when the king of England arrived on 8 June 1191 with twenty-five galleys, fresh from conquering Cyprus, writes Baha ad-Din, Saladin's adviser and biographer. On Friday 12 July the Muslims saw the banners of the Franks floating from the walls. Whether Saladin handled the defence of Acre well is disputed: John Hosler, in his study of the siege, criticises his generalship, while Thomas Asbridge, reviewing the book, calls that criticism a strategic assessment informed by hindsight, and warns that Hosler's view that Saladin had no part in the surrender of Acre rests on the partisan testimony of Baha ad-Din himself.5
During the siege Richard asked to meet Saladin. The answer Baha ad-Din records was that it is not customary for kings to meet, unless they have previously laid the foundations of a treaty.6
The Acre prisoners, August 1191
In August 1191 Richard had the Muslim prisoners of Acre killed. Baha ad-Din counts more than three thousand, all tied together with ropes, gives the motives reported at the time, revenge or unwillingness to leave prisoners behind, and adds: God knows what his reason really was. The crusader poet Ambroise gives two thousand seven hundred, led out in chains. His modern editor John La Monte notes that the consensus of evidence shows that Richard was the first to execute his prisoners.7
Arsuf, 7 September 1191
Richard then marched his army south along the coast towards Jaffa, and at Arsuf Saladin attacked the column. The crusader chronicle known as the Itinerary of Richard I puts the Turks at about twenty thousand. It tells how the Hospitallers begged to charge and Richard held them back: good master, it is you who must sustain their attack, no one can be everywhere at once. The charge went off early, it admits, because two knights, impatient of delay, broke ranks.8
The numbers grew in the telling. Ambroise, who marched with the army, put Saladin's host at three hundred thousand. Baha ad-Din, on the other side, calls the day a blow to all Muslim hearts. He describes Saladin rallying his men while his drum kept beating, and says that afterwards the sultan was so overwhelmed by the events of the day that he would not listen.9

Talks and two marches on Jerusalem, 1191 and 1192
Richard opened talks with Saladin's brother al-Adil. On 8 November 1191, Kate Norgate writes, the two feasted in a tent, Richard asked again for an interview with the sultan, and Saladin refused for the same reason as before.10
Twice the crusaders marched inland towards Jerusalem and twice they turned back. In January 1192 a march of ten miles brought the army to Beit Nuba, on a level space of high ground, where cold and rain wore it down, and a council of the leaders advised rebuilding Ascalon first, Norgate writes, and the host fell back to Ramla.11
The Itinerary says the army was much dejected, but that even if they had taken the city in January they could not long have kept it, because the pilgrims would go home. In the summer Richard refused to lead a siege at all: Jerusalem's walls were too long to blockade with troops few as they now are, and he would be the army's comrade, not its commander.12
Jaffa and the truce, summer 1192
In July Saladin took the town of Jaffa within days, but his troops, worn out by fatigue, by their wounds, by the heat and the smoke, would not storm the citadel, Baha ad-Din writes. Richard told Saladin's envoys afterwards that he was still wearing only the shoes he wore on board, and that he could not have believed Saladin would take Jaffa in two days.13
Richard came by sea to relieve the citadel, and the Itinerary has him fighting the next attack mounted, with only ten other knights.14
On 2 September 1192 the two sides agreed a peace for three years, Lane-Poole writes, which left the coast from Acre to Jaffa in Christian hands while Saladin kept the rest of the land. After this Peace of Ramla, he adds, the crusaders held only a narrow strip of coast from Tyre to Jaffa. Under the terms recorded in the Itinerary, Ascalon was to be destroyed and not rebuilt, and pilgrims were to have free access to the Holy Sepulchre without the exaction of any tribute.15
Strategy: the Jerusalem question
The case for Saladin
Saladin had united Egypt and Syria before he took on the crusaders. The Treccani encyclopedia records that he succeeded his uncle Shirkuh as vizier of Egypt in 1169 and in 1171 ended the Fatimid caliphate there. His aim in 1191 was to keep what he had won in 1187, above all Jerusalem, and he did. The Treccani encyclopedia notes that the peace of 1192 left the Christian states as a coastal strip with pilgrim access to the city. It also names his mistake: failing to take Tyre in 1187 left the crusaders a port through which their armies could be supplied by sea. Bruna Soravia adds that the long war after Hattin brought his regime a serious crisis of resources.16
The case for Richard
Richard came within reach of Jerusalem twice and both times turned back, first on his council's advice that the city could not be held, then on his own judgment that it could not be besieged. The Oxford Companion to British History says he came within an ace of recapturing it, though it also notes that he spent a mere six months of his reign in England. The Treccani entry on Richard calls his crusade a military success that fell short of its main goal: he won the great battles but not the city.17
Battle
The case for Saladin
Hattin was Saladin's masterpiece. The Treccani encyclopedia dates it to 4 July 1187 and calls it a crushing defeat for the Franks, after which Reynald of Châtillon was captured and executed. The Latin chronicle of the fall of the Holy Land records how the relic of the True Cross was seized in the rout.18
His record also has defeats. At Montgisard in 1177, Lane-Poole writes, he was himself all but taken prisoner, but the great captain, who had for once thrown away an army, hastened to collect another.19
The case for Richard
Gale's Encyclopedia of World Biography says that Richard twice defeated Saladin, at Arsuf and at Jaffa, and its Middle Ages Reference Library calls Arsuf a brilliant victory against Saladin's much larger force.20
Holding an army together
The case for Saladin
At Arsuf Saladin rallied his fleeing men while his drum kept beating, Baha ad-Din writes. But the same witness admits that at Jaffa his troops would not obey, and that he made peace because his troops had suffered a great deal and all their funds were exhausted. Baha ad-Din adds two further reasons: the sultan wanted time to set the country in order and to fortify Jerusalem.21
The case for Richard
Richard commanded a crusade of rival kings and lords. The Itinerary tells how the army was much dejected when the council turned back from Jerusalem in January 1192, and how Richard refused to lead a siege in the summer. Norgate shows the leaders deciding in council at Natroun, not Richard alone.22
Courage and cruelty
The case for Saladin
Saladin's reputation for generosity began in his lifetime, and the record is mixed. Dajani-Shakeel reports Imad ad-Din's story that, when advised to seize the churches' treasure in Jerusalem, Saladin refused so that no one could accuse the believers of breaking the covenant. The same chronicler counts 15,000 people who could not pay their ransom and were enslaved. Lane-Poole, his admiring biographer, wrote that it would be hard to imagine a nature more unselfish, devoted to higher aims, or more wholly lovable, and argued that the same generosity cost him a more lasting empire.23
The case for Richard
Richard's courage was never in doubt. Lane-Poole reports that when Hubert Walter praised his master's skill and valour to Saladin, the sultan answered that Richard often incurs unnecessary danger. Against him stands the killing of the Acre prisoners, an act that La Monte, in his notes to Ambroise, says the evidence shows Richard was the first to commit.24
Diplomacy
The case for Saladin
Saladin used diplomacy as a weapon. He kept Richard at arm's length, refusing to meet him until the foundations of a treaty were laid, and let al-Adil carry the talks, as Norgate shows. In 1192 he obtained a peace that left Jerusalem in his hands.25
The case for Richard
Richard negotiated from the start, through al-Adil, and ended the war with a treaty that kept the coast and gained the pilgrims free access to the Holy Sepulchre without tribute, in the words of the treaty text in the Itinerary.26
What came after
The case for Saladin
Saladin died in 1193, months after the truce. Bruna Soravia writes that his death put his family regime to the test. His brother al-Adil eventually took control, and the Ayyubid dynasty ruled Egypt until 1260. Soravia describes his state as a semi-feudal federation held together by kinship. The Treccani encyclopedia adds that a legend formed around Saladin in his own lifetime, and that modern movements in the Arab and Islamic world have claimed him as a symbol of resistance.27
The case for Richard
Richard had become king in 1189 after rising against his own father, Henry II, the Treccani entry recalls. On his way home from the crusade he was recognised and arrested while crossing the Empire in disguise, and had to be ransomed, the Treccani entry records. He spent the rest of his reign fighting Philip II of France, recovering almost all the lands he had lost by 1199, and died of a wound at the siege of Châlus in 1199. The Gale reference work counts him among England's worst kings and notes that he spent all but six months of his reign abroad, while the Oxford Companion calls him an utterly irresponsible king of England but also one of the ablest men to have sat on its throne.28
How historians have judged them
The two main eyewitness accounts each served one side. Baha ad-Din wrote as Saladin's adviser, the Itinerary and Ambroise as crusaders. Asbridge describes Hosler's book as a sustained criticism of Saladin's supposed failings as a military commander and answers it. He warns that Baha ad-Din's testimony is partisan, with reasons to distance Saladin from the surrender of Acre.29
Lane-Poole, writing in 1898, put the virtues of civilisation, magnanimity, toleration and real chivalry on the side of the Saracens, and called Richard's rescue of Jaffa a glow of setting glory over his crusade.30
Norgate's life of Richard, published in 1924, follows the chronicles closely and records Richard's repeated requests for a meeting. Among modern reference works, the Gale and Oxford Companion entries differ sharply on Richard as a king.31
Battles on the site
Every battle page on the site that involves either man, with the guides that set them in context.
Both in command · 1191Siege of Acre
Both in command · 1192Battle of Jaffa
Both in command · 1191Battle of Arsuf
Saladin in command · 1187Battle of Hattin
Saladin in command · 1187Siege of Jerusalem
GuideThe Crusades
CommanderSaladin
CommanderRichard the Lionheart
RankingThe Greatest Military Commanders
QuizMedieval Battles Quiz
The battles of Hattin, Arsuf and Jaffa and the sieges of Jerusalem and Acre have their own articles, and the guide to the Crusades and the lives of both men give the wider background.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide between them.
For Saladin
- Hattin and the taking of Jerusalem in 1187
- He held Jerusalem through the whole crusade
- He rebuilt an army after Montgisard
- A diplomacy that kept Richard at arm's length
- A reputation for generosity that his enemies shared
- Jerusalem won by a negotiated surrender, not by storm
For Richard
- Acre taken five weeks after he arrived
- Arsuf and Jaffa, two victories over Saladin's army
- He judged soberly that Jerusalem could not be held
- A treaty that kept the coast and opened the pilgrim routes
- Personal courage that Saladin himself remarked on
- Cyprus conquered on the way to Acre
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Is a commander judged by the battles he wins or by what he still holds at the end?
- Saladin defended a land he had to keep, Richard fought far from his kingdom. Which task was harder?
- Does the killing of the Acre prisoners outweigh Richard's battlefield record?
- How much should personal courage count, given Saladin's own remark that Richard ran unnecessary risks?
- Who gained more from the 1192 treaty, the side that kept Jerusalem or the side that kept the coast?
- Can either man be judged fairly when each main eyewitness served one side?
Cast your vote below and see how other readers have judged them.






