Who was greater, Alexander or Caesar, Napoleon or Genghis Khan? Each of the 38 comparisons below sets two commanders, two states or two kinds of soldier side by side, with their lives, campaigns and battles, what historians have said of each, and the sources behind every figure. None of them hands down a verdict, because the evidence rarely settles it and the final call is yours.
The grid shows which of the great conquerors already meet on this site. Below it the comparisons come in two parts, commanders and then states, armies and weapons, each grouped by era with a link to the guide to that era. Readers vote on many of these questions, and the running results are on the Readers’ Verdict page.
Which great conquerors meet here
| Cyrus | Alexander | Hannibal | Scipio | Pompey | Caesar | Genghis Khan | Napoleon | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cyrus | vs | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | |
| Alexander | vs | vs | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | vs | vs | vs | |
| Hannibal | no comparison yet | vs | vs | no comparison yet | vs | vs | vs | |
| Scipio | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | vs | no comparison yet | vs | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | |
| Pompey | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | vs | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | |
| Caesar | no comparison yet | vs | vs | vs | vs | vs | vs | |
| Genghis Khan | no comparison yet | vs | vs | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | vs | vs | |
| Napoleon | no comparison yet | vs | vs | no comparison yet | no comparison yet | vs | vs |
Each “vs” opens the comparison of the two commanders in its row and column. An empty square means that pair has no page yet.
Commanders
Generals and admirals, era by era, then the pairs who never met.
Antiquity Guide to the era ›
Generals and states of the ancient world, from Cyrus and Alexander to Caesar and his rivals.
6th and 4th centuries BCCyrus vs Alexander
356 to 44 BCAlexander vs Caesar
356 to 183 BCHannibal vs Alexander
247 to 44 BCCaesar vs Hannibal
Zama, 202 BCHannibal vs Scipio
235 to 44 BCScipio vs Caesar
Pharsalus, 48 BCPompey vs CaesarThe Middle Ages Guide to the era ›
Crusaders, sultans and conquerors who met on the battlefield.
Montgisard, 1177Saladin vs Baldwin IV
Third Crusade, 1189 to 1192Saladin vs Richard the Lionheart
Ankara, 1402Bayezid vs Timur
Wallachia, 1462Mehmed II vs Vlad the ImpalerThe early modern era Guide to the era ›
The American War of Independence and its decisive campaign.
The Napoleonic era Guide to the era ›
Napoleon against the two men who beat him, on land and at sea.
The industrial age Guide to the era ›
The generals of the American Civil War.
World War II Guide to the era ›
Soviet, Allied and German commanders on the Eastern Front, in North Africa and in Western Europe.
1942 to 1943Zhukov vs Manstein
1942 to 1945Eisenhower vs Montgomery
El Alamein, 1942Montgomery vs Rommel
1943 to 1945Patton vs Montgomery
1943 to 1944Patton vs RommelAcross the ages
Commanders who never met, compared across centuries by their campaigns and records.
Genghis Khan vs Alexander
Genghis Khan vs Caesar
Genghis Khan vs Hannibal
Genghis Khan vs Napoleon
Napoleon vs Alexander
Napoleon vs Caesar
Hannibal vs Napoleon
Sun Tzu vs ClausewitzStates, armies and weapons
Rival states, troop types and weapons, era by era.
Antiquity Guide to the era ›
Rival city states and empires, and the infantry formations that fought for them.
The Middle Ages Guide to the era ›
Bows, mounted archers and armoured knights.
The early modern era Guide to the era ›
Heavy cavalry of the seventeenth century.
Across the ages
Warriors and troop types compared across centuries.














