Cyrus or Alexander: what does the evidence say?
Cyrus the Great (died 530 BC) founded the Persian Empire. Alexander the Great (356 to 323 BC) destroyed the army of its last king two centuries later and made the same empire his own. They never met, but they are tied by one state, one city, Babylon, which welcomed both, and one tomb, which Alexander restored. Historians have not settled which was the greater. Herodotus records the Persians calling Cyrus their father. Dodge gave Cyrus the first place in time and Alexander the highest art, while van der Spek reads Cyrus's famous tolerance as pragmatic clemency, not principle. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
Alexander himself took the comparison seriously. On his way back from India he came to Pasargadae, Cyrus's old capital, and found that the tomb of Cyrus had been broken into and robbed. Arrian writes that he was grieved by the outrage.1
Plutarch says he put the robber to death, although he was a prominent Macedonian from Pella, and that the words of the inscription on the tomb deeply affected him.2
This is not a ranking. Below you will find the two careers side by side, the places where their stories meet, and six questions on which a ruler and general can be judged, from strategy to what each left behind. Under each we give the strongest evidence for Cyrus and the strongest for Alexander, with the weak points of each, and the ancient writers and modern historians who argue each case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
- Lived
- Born about 600 BC, died 530 BC
- 356 to 323 BC
- Origin
- Son of Cambyses, king of Anshan, of the Achaemenid line
- Pella, son of King Philip II of Macedon
- Reign
- King of Persia from 559 BC, about thirty years
- King of Macedon from 336 BC, twelve years and eight months
- Conquests
- Media, Lydia, Central Asia, Babylonia
- The whole Persian Empire, from Asia Minor and Egypt to the Indus
- Notable opponents
- Astyages of Media, Croesus of Lydia, Nabonidus of Babylon, the Massagetae
- Darius III, the Persian satraps, Spitamenes, Porus
- Capital and tomb
- Pasargadae, where he is buried
- Founded Alexandria, died at Babylon
- Death
- In battle in Central Asia, by most accounts
- At Babylon, aged 32
Dates and reigns from the Encyclopaedia Iranica, Herodotus and Arrian. No reliable army sizes survive for any of Cyrus's battles, and no source counts the victories of both men the same way, so we give no numbers of our own.3
Where their stories meet
Some 170 years separate the death of Cyrus from the birth of Alexander. What joins them is that Alexander conquered the empire Cyrus had built, entered the same city of Babylon that had opened its gates to Cyrus, and stood at Cyrus's grave.
The tomb at Pasargadae
Arrian gives the inscription Alexander's companion Aristobulus read there: O man, I am Cyrus, son of Cambyses, who founded the empire of the Persians and was king of Asia. Do not therefore grudge me this monument.4
Strabo, also following Aristobulus, gives nearly the same words and says Aristobulus had seen the tomb intact on the first visit and found it robbed on the second. Alexander ordered it restored.5
Plutarch gives a longer inscription, which Alexander had repeated in Greek letters below the original: O man, whoever you are and wherever you come from, for I know that you will come, I am Cyrus, and I won for the Persians their empire. Do not, therefore, begrudge me this little earth which covers my body. These words, Plutarch says, deeply affected Alexander, who was reminded of the uncertainty and mutability of life.6
Strabo also explains why Pasargadae mattered to Cyrus. He held the place in honour, Strabo writes, because there he beat Astyages the Mede in his last battle and took over the empire of Asia, and there he founded a city and built a palace as a memorial of his victory. UNESCO lists the site, with the palaces, the gardens and the mausoleum of Cyrus, as the first dynastic capital of the Achaemenid Empire.7

Alexander follows Cyrus
Arrian shows Alexander measuring himself against Cyrus more than once. He honoured the Ariaspians because their ancestors had helped Cyrus in his invasion of Scythia. In Sogdiana he stormed Cyropolis, a city with walls higher than the others because Cyrus had founded it. And on the way back from India, the admiral Nearchus claimed, he chose the desert route through Gedrosia partly from a desire to outdo Cyrus and Semiramis, who were said to have barely escaped it.8
One city, two entries
In October 539 BC, the Babylonian chronicle records, Cyrus beat the army of Akkad at Opis on the Tigris, Sippar fell without a battle, and Babylon was entered without a battle.9
Cyrus's own clay cylinder says the god Marduk made him enter his city Babylon without fighting or battle. Two centuries later, Pierre Briant writes in the Encyclopaedia Iranica, Babylon welcomed Alexander with much the same enthusiasm its people had shown towards Cyrus.10
The chronicle stresses how quietly the city changed hands. The rites in the great temple of Esagil were not interrupted and no festival date was missed. When Cyrus entered Babylon there was peace in the city, his greeting was spoken to all of it, and his officer Gubaru appointed the district governors.11
Strategy: building an empire, taking an empire
The case for Cyrus
Cyrus built from a small base. He began as king of Anshan, the title his cylinder gives his father and grandfather. According to the Babylonian chronicle, when Astyages of Media marched against him in about 550 BC, Astyages's own army rebelled and handed him over. M. A. Dandamayev, in the Encyclopaedia Iranica, follows the conquests that came next: Lydia, the Greek cities of Ionia through his general Harpagus, Central Asia to the north-western edge of India, and finally Babylonia.12
A. T. Olmstead, in his History of the Persian Empire of 1948, describes the speed of the war against Croesus of Lydia. Croesus expected his allies to join him in the spring, but Cyrus had no intention of allowing the enemy time for reinforcements, and although the hard Anatolian winter was coming, he pushed rapidly west.13
Olmstead also follows Cyrus east, across the Oxus, which could not be bridged and which Cyrus probably crossed on inflated skins, to the Chorasmians of the lower Oxus, who were subdued, and to the half-nomad Massagetae beyond the Jaxartes, the people against whom he would die.14
The case for Alexander
Alexander took over a working empire and aimed at all of it. Briant writes that from 334 BC he had in view the whole extent of the empire as it had been under Darius I. After Issus he turned to Phoenicia and Egypt first, to take the empire's Aegean front and its soft underbelly, and only then marched inland to beat Darius again at Gaugamela on 1 October 331.15
The weak point is that his plan had no natural end. At the river Hyphasis in 326 BC his army refused to go further, and Arrian records the soldiers' joy when the king gave way: by them alone, they said, he had let himself be beaten.16
He also started with far more than Cyrus. Diodorus itemises the army that crossed into Asia in 334 BC at 32,000 foot and 4,500 horse, veterans of his father's wars, and Arrian gives a little over 30,000 foot and more than 5,000 horse.17
Battle and stratagem
The case for Cyrus
Cyrus's most famous stratagem came before Sardis. Herodotus writes that on the advice of Harpagus he set the baggage camels in front of his army against the Lydian horse, because the horse has a fear of the camel and cannot endure its sight or smell. The cavalry Croesus most relied on became useless.18
Olmstead tells the same story and places the battle at the junction of the Hyllus and the Hermus, a plain later called the Field of Cyrus.19
A second tradition comes from Xenophon's Cyropaedia, which calls the battle Thymbra. The American soldier Theodore Ayrault Dodge, in his Great Captains of 1889, retold it from Xenophon: Croesus outnumbered Cyrus more than two to one, and Cyrus drew up a deep order of five lines that took the Lydian wings in flank as they wheeled to surround him. Dodge called Cyrus the first historical verity for the soldier.20
The two accounts cannot both be right. Herodotus has an indecisive battle at Pteria, then the camels on the plain before Sardis and a siege. Xenophon's set-piece battle, with its numbers and its five lines, is found only in the Cyropaedia, a book written to show what an ideal king should be.21
The case for Alexander
Alexander fought four great pitched battles, three against the armies of Persia and one against the Indian king Porus: the Granicus in 334 BC, Issus in 333, Gaugamela in 331 and the Hydaspes in 326. He won all four, and Diodorus describes each of them.22
At Gaugamela, Arrian reports, the army of Darius was said to number 40,000 cavalry and 1,000,000 infantry, against Alexander's 7,000 cavalry and about 40,000 infantry. Diodorus gives the Persians 800,000 foot and 200,000 horse. These are not real counts, but they show that the ancient writers believed the odds were heavily against him.23

Dodge, who put Cyrus at the start of his story, set the two side by side. Cyrus overran in his conquests almost as great a territory as Alexander, he wrote, but Alexander found war in a crude state and conducted it with the very highest art.24
Sieges
The case for Cyrus
Sardis, the Lydian capital, fell quickly. Herodotus says Croesus was taken after a siege of fourteen days.25
Olmstead describes the citadel being scaled after that short siege. Babylon itself, by the Babylonian chronicle, was entered without a fight.26
Herodotus tells Babylon differently, with the Babylonians beaten in the field and shut in their city until Cyrus made the river passable and sent his army in along its bed. He also tells what came after Sardis. Croesus was set on a pyre, and when Cyrus heard through interpreters what the captive king was saying, he reflected that he himself was but a man, was burning alive another man who had been no less fortunate, and ordered the fire put out.27
The case for Alexander
Tyre, an island city off the Phoenician coast, held out against Alexander for seven months in 332 BC, Diodorus records, before it was taken by storm.28
In Sogdiana in 327 BC the defenders of a mountain stronghold told him to find soldiers with wings. Arrian tells how he offered twelve talents to the first man up the cliff and how volunteers climbed it at night and took the rock.29
The conquered
The case for Cyrus
Cyrus's reputation for mercy is old. Herodotus records that the Persians called Darius a shopkeeper, Cambyses a master and Cyrus a father, because he was gentle and contrived all good things for them.30
On his cylinder from Babylon, Cyrus says he returned the images of the gods to their sanctuaries and gathered their peoples and returned them to their homes. Dandamayev concludes that Cyrus seems generally to have respected the customs and religions of conquered lands.31
The cylinder is also a piece of royal self-presentation. In it Cyrus calls himself king of the world, great king, mighty king, king of Babylon, king of Sumer and Akkad, king of the four quarters, son, grandson and descendant of kings of Anshan, and says that the people of Babylon bowed to him and kissed his feet.32

The evidence has another side. The same Babylonian chronicle says that after the battle at Opis Cyrus carried off the plunder and slaughtered the people, and Olmstead calls it an example of frightfulness after which his opponents lost courage.33
The Dutch historian R. J. van der Spek argues that Cyrus's much-praised religious tolerance was a time-honoured policy of many Near Eastern kings, not a new idea, and that Cyrus did not abstain from forcing nations into submission when it suited him.34
The chronicle itself gives the other half of the picture. After Cyrus entered Babylon, it records, the gods of Akkad that Nabonidus had brought into the city were returned to their own places over the winter months.35
The case for Alexander
Alexander kept much of what Cyrus had built. Briant writes that the Achaemenid system of satrapies was maintained, a Persian, Mazaeus, became satrap of Babylon in October 331, and in Egypt and Babylonia Alexander took unfailing care to respect local gods and cults. Briant calls this a shrewd policy, over-simply described as religious toleration, followed by the first Achaemenids.36
Van der Spek places Alexander with Cyrus among the conquerors who won popularity by appeasing local elites.37
He could also be merciless. At Tyre, Diodorus writes, more than seven thousand defenders were cut down, the women and children were sold and some two thousand men of military age were crucified.38
When Thebes rebelled in 335 BC, Plutarch says, more than thirty thousand of its people were sold into slavery.39
Persepolis, the capital the Persian kings had built after Cyrus, paid the heaviest price. Diodorus writes that Alexander called it the most hateful of the cities of Asia and gave it to his soldiers to plunder, all but the palaces, and that the palaces were later burned after a drunken feast at which the Athenian woman Thais urged him to set them alight.40
Plutarch tells the same story and gives Thais's reason: to punish the house of Xerxes, who had burned Athens. Some writers, he adds, told it differently. Strabo writes that Alexander carried off all the wealth of Persis to Susa.41
How it ended
The case for Cyrus
Cyrus died at war. Herodotus tells of a campaign against the Massagetae beyond the Araxes, a fierce battle in which the greater part of the Persian army was destroyed and Cyrus was killed, after he had reigned thirty years less one.42
Herodotus closes with the queen of the Massagetae, Tomyris, whose son Cyrus had taken by a trick. She had a skin filled with human blood, searched among the Persian dead for the body of Cyrus and plunged his head into it, saying that she would give him his fill of blood. Of the many stories of Cyrus's end, Herodotus says, this seemed to him the most credible.43
Dandamayev notes that the ancient accounts of his death differ: Ctesias has him wounded by an Indian spear in a war against the Derbici, Berossus has him die fighting the Dahae, and Xenophon has him die peacefully in his own capital.44
The empire did not die with him. It passed whole to his son Cambyses, who conquered Egypt, as Herodotus records, and Strabo writes that the rule of the Persians over Asia lasted about two hundred and fifty years.45
The case for Alexander
Alexander died at Babylon at 32, and Arrian gives his reign as twelve years and eight months.46
Strabo writes that after him the rule of Asia was divided among his several successors and their descendants, and then dissolved.47
What came after
The case for Cyrus
UNESCO describes Pasargadae, Cyrus's capital, as the first dynastic capital of the Achaemenid Empire and the capital of the first great multicultural empire in Western Asia, considered to be the first empire that respected the cultural diversity of its peoples.48
The Greeks admired him too: Dandamayev notes that Plato counted him a great conqueror and wise statesman and that Xenophon made him an ideal ruler.49
Xenophon's praise was the most extravagant. Cyrus, he wrote, did indeed eclipse all other monarchs before or since, whether they inherited their power or won it by their own efforts. Van der Spek warns that Cyrus was very successful in his propaganda and that modern historiography is still influenced by it.50
The case for Alexander
Alexander restored the empire, Briant writes, to the limits Darius I had given it, including the Indian lands, and planned a sea route between the Persian Gulf and the Red Sea as Darius had done. Many of his new cities were built on sites already used under the Persian kings.51

Arrian closed his history by saying that there was then no race of men, no city, nor even a single person whom Alexander's name had not reached.52
Dodge wrote that his life work surpasses anything in history.53
How historians have judged them
The ancient picture of Cyrus is mostly Persian tradition seen through Greek eyes, and much of it is kind. Herodotus records the Persians calling him their father. Xenophon turned him into a model king.54
Xenophon's opening shows how far the praise could go. Cyrus, he wrote, found the readiest obedience among subjects who lived days and months away and had never set eyes on him, and yet were willing to obey him.55
Modern scholars test that picture against the cuneiform sources. Van der Spek quotes the Cambridge Ancient History, where T. Cuyler Young calls Cyrus's policy one of remarkable tolerance, and then argues that it was traditional, pragmatic clemency, applied when useful. Olmstead admired Cyrus's speed but did not hide the slaughter at Opis.56
Van der Spek also warns against reading modern ideas into either man. Tolerance in antiquity, he writes, was almost never a matter of principle, and even the destruction of temples or the removal of cult images was not meant to prove that a god did not exist. What Cyrus and Alexander shared, in his view, was a shrewd mix of military force and negotiation with local elites.57
For Alexander, Briant warns that stressing the three great victories over Persia has led historians to underestimate the strength and tenacity of the Persian resistance. Dodge, comparing the two, gave Cyrus the first place in time and Alexander the highest art.58
Battles on the site
No battle of Cyrus has a page of its own yet. The ranking of the greatest battles of the Persian Empire covers three of them, and the pages below cover Alexander's war against the empire Cyrus founded. Pteria, Sardis, the Granicus and Tyre have no page of their own.
Cyrus in command · 539 BCOpis and the fall of Babylon
Cyrus in command · about 547 BCThymbra and Sardis
Cyrus in command · 550 BCPasargadae
Alexander in command · 333 BCBattle of Issus
Alexander in command · 331 BCBattle of Gaugamela
Alexander in command · 326 BCBattle of the Hydaspes
Guide · 336 to 323 BCThe Wars of Alexander the Great
RulerCyrus the Great
CommanderAlexander the Great
RulerDarius the Great
RankingThe Greatest Battles of the Persian Empire
QuizHow Well Do You Know Ancient Battles?
For the wider field, see Cambyses II, who took Egypt after his father's death, the greatest commanders of the Persian Empire, Alexander vs Caesar and Napoleon vs Alexander.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For Cyrus
- Built an empire from a small subject kingdom
- Media, Lydia, Central Asia and Babylonia in about thirty years
- Stratagem over numbers, as with the camels before Sardis
- A name for mercy, from the Persians' father to the cylinder of Babylon
- An empire that outlived him by about two hundred and fifty years
For Alexander
- Four great pitched battles, all won, against the royal army of Persia
- The whole empire of Cyrus and Darius taken in about eleven years
- Tyre, the Sogdian Rock and other sieges others thought impossible
- Kept the Persian order and governed through Persians as well as Macedonians
- Honoured Cyrus himself, and restored his tomb
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Is founding an empire a greater feat than conquering one that already exists?
- Should the long life of the Persian Empire count for Cyrus, when much of its organisation came under Darius I?
- How much of Cyrus's reputation is his own propaganda and Greek idealisation, and how much is fact?
- Alexander honoured Cyrus and tried to outdo him. Does the admirer's admiration settle anything?
- Do we judge Alexander by his battles, or by the fact that his empire did not survive him intact?
- With no reliable army sizes for Cyrus, can his generalship be compared at all with Alexander's?








