Alexander or Caesar: what does the evidence say?
Alexander the Great (356 to 323 BC) and Julius Caesar (100 to 44 BC, though some date his birth to 102) never met. Caesar was born more than two centuries after Alexander died. Alexander conquered the Persian Empire with the army his father had built. Caesar conquered Gaul and then won a Roman civil war. Ancient writers mostly refused to choose. Napoleon put both on his short list of commanders an officer should study. Dodge called Alexander the captain of fortune and gave Caesar a middle place. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The comparison is almost as old as Caesar himself. The Greek historian Appian, closing his account of Caesar's murder, called him a man fit to be compared with Alexander, and listed what the two shared: the greatest ambition, the greatest skill in the art of war, speed in carrying out their decisions and a reckless disregard of danger. He also named the difference that matters most here. Alexander set out from a monarchy founded by his father Philip, Caesar from a private station, well born but wholly without wealth.1
This is not a ranking. Below you will find the two careers side by side, the places where their stories touch, and six questions on which a general can be judged, from strategy to the price his enemies paid. Under each we give the strongest evidence for Alexander and the strongest for Caesar, with the weak points of each, and the ancient writers and modern historians who argue each case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
- Lived
- 356 to 323 BC
- 100 to 44 BC (some date his birth to 102)
- Origin
- Pella, son of King Philip II of Macedon
- Rome, the patrician family of the Julii
- First command
- King of Macedon in 336 BC, at about 20, after his father was murdered
- Further Spain after his praetorship, back in Rome in 60 BC
- Years in command
- 336 to 323 BC, as king
- Spain, then Gaul 58 to 50, the civil war 49 to 45 BC
- Notable opponents
- Darius III, the Persian satraps, Spitamenes, Porus
- Ariovistus, the Nervii, Vercingetorix, Pompey, Pharnaces II, Pompey's sons
- Pitched battles counted
- Four great battles: Granicus, Issus, Gaugamela, Hydaspes
- Fifty in all, says Pliny. Thirty in Gaul alone, says Appian
- Battles named here
- Granicus, Issus, Gaugamela, Hydaspes, Tyre
- The Sambre, Gergovia, Alesia, Pharsalus, Munda
- Death
- At Babylon in 323 BC, aged 32
- Killed in the Senate on 15 March 44 BC
Dates, origins and commands from Arrian and Suetonius, with the Encyclopaedia Iranica for Alexander's battles and the 1911 Britannica for Caesar's birth. The battle counts are the ancient writers' own claims. No source counts the victories and defeats of both men the same way, so we give no totals.2
Where their stories meet
They never met. Alexander died at Babylon in 323 BC, and Caesar was born in Rome some two hundred and twenty years later. What links them is that Caesar knew Alexander's story, measured himself against it, and fought in the world Alexander had left behind.
Caesar measures himself against Alexander
The ancient writers tell two separate stories. Suetonius sets the first at Gades in Spain, where Caesar served as quaestor. Seeing a statue of Alexander in the temple of Hercules, he heaved a sigh, as if impatient that he had done nothing noteworthy at an age when Alexander had already brought the world to his feet, and asked to be released from his post.3
Plutarch tells of Caesar in Spain reading a history of Alexander, falling silent for a long time and then bursting into tears, because Alexander at his age was already king of so many peoples, while he had achieved no brilliant success.4
The Roman historian Velleius Paterculus, writing under Tiberius, made the comparison a matter of character. In the size of his ambitions, the speed of his campaigns and his endurance of danger, he wrote, Caesar closely resembled Alexander, but only Alexander when he was free from wine and master of his passions.5
Two lives in one book
Plutarch opens his Alexander with the words: it is the life of Alexander the king, and of Caesar, who overthrew Pompey, that I am writing in this book.6
Appian's comparison runs over several chapters. In the family legends both men descended from Jupiter, Alexander through Aeacus and Hercules, Caesar through Anchises and Venus. Both mocked the omens of their own deaths, and both died while planning new wars. Appian also marks a difference in the record. Alexander, he says, was never defeated and finished almost every war in one or two battles. Caesar's forces were put to flight at Dyrrachium and in Africa, though Caesar himself, in Appian's words, was victorious at the end of every war.7
Caesar in Alexander's world
Caesar fought in the city Alexander had founded. During the Alexandrian war, Appian writes, Caesar was cut off on a bridge, threw off his purple cloak, leapt into the sea and swam under water to a friendly ship.8
When he was killed he was preparing a war against the Parthians, who ruled much of the old Persian empire Alexander had conquered. Cassius Dio says the Romans, longing to avenge Crassus, voted him the command of that war, and Suetonius that he meant to march by way of Lesser Armenia and test the enemy before risking a battle. Nine years earlier the Parthians had destroyed Crassus and his army at Carrhae.9

Strategy: the plan for a whole war
The case for Alexander
From the start Alexander aimed at the whole Persian empire. The French historian Pierre Briant, writing in the Encyclopaedia Iranica, says that from 334 BC he had in view the whole extent of the empire as it had been under Darius I. After beating Darius at Issus in November 333 he did not chase him to the Euphrates. He turned south to Phoenicia and Egypt, in line with a plan made at Miletus the year before: to take the whole Aegean front of the empire, its soft underbelly, Briant writes, which had rebelled several times in that century. Only then, on 1 October 331, did he meet Darius again at Gaugamela.10
The weak point is that the plan had no natural end. In 326 BC, at the river Hyphasis in the Punjab, his army refused to go further. Arrian gives the speeches of Alexander and of his officer Coenus and records the soldiers' joy when the king gave way: by them alone, they said, he had let himself be beaten. Plutarch says they had had all they could do to beat Porus and refused outright when he insisted on crossing the Ganges as well.11
The case for Caesar
In the civil war Caesar faced enemies spread from Spain to Africa and the East, and beat them one group at a time. Suetonius lists the order: Italy, then Pompey's legions in Spain, Massilia, Pompey himself in Macedonia, Alexandria, Pontus, Africa and Spain again. The American soldier and historian Theodore Ayrault Dodge, in his Great Captains of 1889, called it the best example in history of the proper use of central lines on a gigantic scale, an idea often credited to Napoleon, and judged Caesar's strategy broad and far-seeing.12
Dodge was just as frank about the risks. He thought the crossing of the Rhine and the first landing in Britain had no strategic value, and said Caesar owed it to simple fortune that he ever returned from Britain to Gaul. He moved over to Epirus in 48 BC, Dodge wrote, with a temerity from which arch luck alone could save him. Suetonius gives the other side of the same man: it is a question, he says, whether Caesar was more cautious or more daring, for he never led his army where an ambush was possible without first reconnoitring the ground.13
Battlefield tactics
The case for Alexander
Briant names four great pitched battles: the Granicus in May 334, Issus in November 333, Gaugamela on 1 October 331 and the Hydaspes in the spring of 326. Alexander won all four.14
At Gaugamela, Arrian reports, the army of Darius was said to number 40,000 cavalry and 1,000,000 infantry against Alexander's 7,000 cavalry and about 40,000 infantry. Diodorus gives Darius 800,000 foot and 200,000 horse. Neither is a real count, but both show that the ancient writers believed the odds were heavily against him.15
At the Hydaspes he faced Porus and his elephants across a river in flood. Arrian describes how he left Craterus on the bank opposite Porus with orders not to cross until Porus moved off, then made a secret march with picked troops to a wooded island and headland upstream and crossed there in a night of thunder and rain that drowned the noise. Dodge names Alexander's wedge at Arbela, the other name for Gaugamela, beside Epaminondas' oblique order and Hannibal's line at Cannae, as the kind of striking tactical formation he could not find in Caesar's battles. Caesar's tactics, he wrote, were simple.16
The case for Caesar
At Pharsalus in 48 BC Caesar's 22,000 foot faced 45,000, and his 1,000 horse faced 7,000, by the figures Plutarch gives, and Appian has the same 22,000 against more than double the number. Pompey massed his best cavalry to ride round Caesar's right. Caesar, Appian writes, hid 3,000 of his bravest foot soldiers there with orders to rise when the horsemen tried to outflank him and thrust their spears at their faces. The charge was driven off the field.17
Suetonius says Caesar joined battle both after planning his moves in advance and on a sudden opportunity, often straight after a march and sometimes in the foulest weather, when no one expected him to move. Only in his later years, Suetonius adds, did he grow slower to engage, believing that the more often he had won, the less he should tempt fate.18
His record has a clear defeat. At Gergovia in 52 BC, by his own account, his troops were driven from the hill with the loss of forty-six centurions and nearly seven hundred soldiers. Next day he told the army that he required discipline and self-restraint from his soldiers no less than courage. The summary of Livy's lost books also records the hard sieges of Avaricum and Gergovia that year.19
Sieges and engineering
The case for Alexander
Tyre, an island city off the Phoenician coast, held out against him for seven months in 332 BC, as both Diodorus and Briant record, before it was taken by storm. Gaza held out for several weeks more.20
In Sogdiana in 327 BC the defenders of a mountain stronghold laughed at him and told him to find soldiers with wings. Arrian tells how he offered twelve talents to the first man up the cliff, and how volunteers climbed it at night and took the rock.21
He led many assaults himself. Storming a town of the Malli in India, Arrian writes, he was among the few on the wall when the ladders broke, fought on inside it and was shot with an arrow through his breastplate into the chest. Appian tells the same story as one of his parallels with Caesar: struck in the breast and neck, Alexander was rescued with difficulty by Macedonians who broke down the gates.22
The case for Caesar
Caesar dug and built where Alexander stormed. In 55 BC he bridged the Rhine, and the whole work, he writes, was finished in ten days from the day the timber began to be collected. At Alesia in 52 BC he shut Vercingetorix inside one ring of siege works and built a second, facing out, fourteen miles round, against a relief army he puts at 8,000 horse and about 250,000 foot. Both rings held, and Vercingetorix surrendered. Velleius wrote that his feats about Alesia were such as a mere man would scarcely dare to attempt and hardly anyone but a god could carry through.23
Dodge draws the contrast plainly. In field fortification, he wrote, Caesar was far in the lead, Hannibal followed at a long interval, and Alexander made little or no use of it. In regular sieges, though, he set Alexander and Caesar side by side, both much higher than Hannibal.24

Leading men
The case for Alexander
Alexander led from the front. At the Granicus, Arrian writes, a Persian noble broke his helmet with a scimitar, Alexander killed him with a lance through the breastplate, and Cleitus cut off the arm of a second attacker before he could strike. Arrian's portrait of the king says he was exceedingly fond of incurring danger, and very renowned for rousing the courage of his soldiers and dispelling their fear by his own freedom from fear.25
Inside his army there were breaking points. Briant lists three crises among the Macedonian nobles: the execution of Philotas and Parmenio in 330, the killing of Cleitus in 328 or 327, and the quarrel over prostration before the king in 327.26
The case for Caesar
Dodge draws the contrast that matters here. Alexander, like Hannibal and Frederick, owed his military training and his army to his father, while Caesar was the only one of the great captains who trained himself to arms.27
Suetonius says he valued his soldiers only for their courage, called them comrades rather than soldiers, and that in the civil war not one of them deserted, while many who were captured refused to save their lives by fighting against him.28
On the Sambre in 57 BC, Plutarch writes, the army would have been lost had Caesar not snatched a shield and thrown himself into the front line.29
Appian, who knew both stories, warns against seeing either army as simply devoted. The soldiers of both men, he says, were zealous in battle but often disobedient and mutinous because of the hardness of their work, and both armies mourned their commanders when they were dead.30
The price of conquest
The case for Alexander
Both conquests were bloody, and the sources say so. When Thebes rebelled in 335 BC, Plutarch writes, Alexander sold the people into slavery, more than thirty thousand of them, and more than six thousand had been killed. Diodorus gives the same numbers. At Tyre, Diodorus says, more than seven thousand were cut down in the streets, the women and children were sold, and some two thousand men of military age were crucified.31
His own army paid as well. On the march back through the Gedrosian desert in 325 BC, Arrian writes, the heat and lack of water destroyed a great part of the army, and he reports a claim of the admiral Nearchus that Alexander chose the route partly from a desire to outdo Cyrus and Semiramis, who were said to have barely escaped it.32
The case for Caesar
For Gaul the ancient figures are larger still. Plutarch writes that in less than ten years Caesar took more than eight hundred towns, subdued three hundred peoples and fought three million men, killing a million and capturing as many more. Pliny the Elder counts 1,192,000 killed in his battles, not counting the civil wars, and refuses to set it down as glory, calling it an outrage committed upon mankind. Velleius puts the dead at more than four hundred thousand, with a greater number taken prisoner. These are ancient claims, built largely on Caesar's own reports, and they do not agree.33
In 55 BC Caesar held the envoys of two German peoples, the Usipetes and Tencteri, and attacked their camp. He writes that their whole number had been 430,000 souls and that the Romans returned without the loss of a man. Dodge called it perhaps the most gigantic piece of cruelty ever charged to the score of civilised man. The historian Kurt Raaflaub notes that Caesar now stands accused of genocide. Without excusing him, he reads the Gallic war against ancient customs of imperial warfare, and sets the brutal conqueror beside the clement victor who made clemency one of a ruler's cardinal virtues.34
What came after
The case for Alexander
Alexander held together an empire from Greece and Egypt to the Indus. Briant stresses how much of the Persian order he kept: the system of satrapies was maintained, a Persian, Mazaeus, was made satrap of Babylon in October 331, and many of his new cities stood on sites already in use under the Persian kings. Strabo sums up the end. Alexander reigned over Asia for ten or eleven years, and then the rule of Asia was divided among his successors and their descendants.35
Arrian, writing more than four centuries later, closed his history by saying that there was then no race of men, no city, nor even a single person whom Alexander's name had not reached, and that a hero so unlike any other could not have been born without the gods.36
The case for Caesar
Caesar made Gaul a Roman province paying a yearly tribute of 40,000,000 sesterces, Suetonius says. He reformed the calendar, setting the Roman year by the sun, as the Egyptians reckoned it, and Appian notes that none of the men who killed him escaped, because his adopted son hunted them all down. His heir became Augustus, the first emperor.37
The 1911 Britannica, in an entry by Henry Stuart Jones, says that historians have always recognised his commanding genius, and that their verdict on Caesar has always been coloured by their political sympathies. Dodge called him the greatest character in history, and also a man of a singularly blunted conscience.38
How historians have judged them
The ancient writers mostly refused to choose. Appian built his comparison on equal terms and closed it with the different starting points. Velleius made Caesar the equal of Alexander only when Alexander was sober.39
Plutarch paired them in one book, and in his Caesar argued that set beside Fabius, Scipio and Metellus, Sulla, Marius and even Pompey, Caesar would be found to surpass them all in his achievements. Pliny admired Caesar's energy but would not count the dead as glory.40
Napoleon put both on the short list of commanders an officer should study. In the maxims later collected from his sayings, Alexander, Hannibal and Caesar, with Gustavus Adolphus, Turenne and Frederick, have all acted upon the same principles, and their campaigns should be read again and again. Dodge compared them directly. Alexander was always daring, never cautious, he wrote, while Caesar was over-daring and over-cautious by turns. Alexander would always remain the captain of fortune, Hannibal the captain of misfortune, and Caesar held a middle place. Of Alexander's life work he wrote that it surpasses anything in history.41
Modern scholars have pushed each image in a different direction. Briant warns that stressing the three great victories over Persia has led to underestimating the strength and tenacity of the Persian resistance. For Caesar, the reviewer Josh Levithan found Adrian Goldsworthy's biography masterful on military matters, but thought it made a better case for the richness of Roman culture than for the peculiar greatness of Caesar. Raaflaub sets the brutal conqueror of Gaul beside the clement victor of the civil war.42
Battles on the site
Every battle page on Echoes of Battle that involves one of the two men, with the guides that set them in context. Granicus, Tyre, Gergovia, Dyrrachium and Munda have no page of their own yet.
Alexander in command · 333 BCBattle of Issus
Alexander in command · 331 BCBattle of Gaugamela
Alexander in command · 326 BCBattle of the Hydaspes
Caesar in command · 52 BCBattle of Alesia
Caesar in command · 48 BCBattle of Dyrrachium
Caesar in command · 48 BCBattle of Pharsalus
Context · 53 BCCarrhae: Rome meets Parthia
Guide · 336 to 323 BCThe Wars of Alexander the Great
Guide · 88 BC to AD 324The Roman Civil Wars
CommanderAlexander the Great
CommanderJulius Caesar
CommanderPhilip II of Macedon
Head to headPompey vs Caesar
Head to headPhalanx vs Legion
RankingThe Greatest Commanders of Ancient Greece
RankingThe Greatest Commanders of Ancient Rome
QuizHow Well Do You Know Ancient Battles?
For the wider field, see the greatest military commanders in history and the greatest battles of the Persian Empire, which covers the Granicus.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For Alexander
- Four great pitched battles, all won, against armies the sources call far larger
- The Persian Empire conquered in about eleven years
- Tyre taken after seven months, the Sogdian Rock by climbers
- Led from the front, from the Granicus to the wall of the Malli town
- Kept the Persian system and governed it through Persians as well as Macedonians
For Caesar
- Built his career and his army from a private start
- Gaul conquered in nine years, with Alesia as the masterpiece of siege works
- Beat Roman armies under the best generals of his day
- Came back from defeats at Gergovia and Dyrrachium to win each war
- A political revolution that outlived him, from the calendar to the empire of Augustus
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Is it harder to use the best army in the world perfectly, or to build an army and a career from a private start?
- Should Caesar's defeats count against him, or his recoveries for him, when Alexander, in Appian's words, was never defeated?
- Does it matter that many of Caesar's opponents were Roman armies trained like his own?
- How far can we trust Caesar's own Commentaries, and Arrian writing more than four centuries after Alexander?
- Which counts for more, an empire that split at the founder's death, or a revolution that outlived its maker?
- Should the cost to the conquered, at Thebes and Tyre or among the Usipetes and in Gaul, weigh in judging a general at all?







