Spartan or samurai: what does the evidence say?
The Spartans were the citizen soldiers of a Greek city in the 6th to 4th centuries BC, the samurai the hereditary warriors of Japan from about the 10th century to the 19th. More than fifteen hundred years lie between them, so they never met, and we know of no historian who compares them directly. So there is no verdict to report, only two legends that each need correcting. The ancient witnesses quoted for Sparta were not Spartans themselves. The Japanese reference works separate the medieval way of bow and horse from the bushido written down in peacetime. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The comparison is ours, not the ancient writers'. It rests on separate evidence for each side: Greek historians and philosophers for Sparta, Japanese chronicles and reference works for the samurai. The two warrior classes do share some features worth weighing. Both faced invasions by the armies of great Asian empires, both became the subject of legends written largely by others, and both ended as fighting classes long before the legends did.1
This is not a ranking, and it cannot be a duel. Below you will find the two side by side, the two famous defences against invaders that invite the comparison, and six questions on which a warrior class can be judged, from training to legend. Under each we give the strongest evidence for the Spartan and the strongest for the samurai, with the period writers and reference works behind each case, and the weak points of each inside its own case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
SpartanSpartiate citizen hoplite
SamuraiJapanese warrior class- Period
- Above all the 6th to 4th centuries BC, until the defeat at Leuctra in 371 BC
- From the 10th and 11th centuries to the Meiji Restoration, after which samurai status disappeared
- Organisation
- A citizen body of a few thousand, drilled together and fighting in the phalanx, supported by helots
- Hereditary retainers of the shogunate and the great lords
- Arms and armour
- Spear, sword and a bronze-faced round shield
- Bow and sword, laced lamellar armour, later spears and guns: a 14th-century yoroi in the Met weighs 17.3 kg
- Tactics
- The heavy infantry line, holding its ground
- Mounted archery in the early period, then armies built around foot soldiers and firearms
- Recruitment and training
- Boys taken by the state at seven and trained in companies
- Born into the class, trained in mounted archery exercises such as shooting at running dogs
- Famous defence
- Thermopylae, 480 BC, against Xerxes of Persia
- Hakata Bay, 1274 and 1281, against Kublai's Mongol empire
As given by Herodotus, Plutarch, Xenophon and the Japanese reference works on Kotobank, with the Metropolitan Museum's record. We give no win and loss totals: the two never fought, and their battles were fought by whole armies.2
Two answers to one problem: Thermopylae and Hakata Bay
Spartans and samurai never met. The nearest thing to a shared test is the problem each faced from a great Asian empire: Persia invaded Greece in 480 BC, and the Mongol empire invaded Japan in 1274 and 1281. The parallel is our own way of comparing them, not one drawn by an ancient or modern historian we could find.3
Thermopylae, 480 BC
Herodotus lists the Greeks who held the pass: 300 Spartans, with about 2,800 more Peloponnesians, 700 Thespians and 400 Thebans. A Persian scout, he says, found the Spartans outside the wall exercising and combing their hair, and the exiled Spartan king Demaratus told Xerxes that this was their custom when they were about to risk their lives.4
When the pass was turned, Leonidas sent most of the allies away and stayed. Herodotus writes that most of the Greeks had broken their spears and fought on with swords, and at the end with hands and teeth, on a hillock behind the wall. The epitaph he quotes for the Spartans reads: foreigner, go tell the Spartans that we lie here, obedient to their commands. The battle is told in full on our page on Thermopylae.5
Hakata Bay, 1274 and 1281
In 1274, the Yamakawa dictionary of Japanese history records, about 28,000 Mongol, Jurchen, Chinese and Korean troops in 900 ships landed on Hakata Bay. The Nipponica encyclopedia says the Japanese struggled against the invaders' massed tactics, and the fighting ended undecided before a storm struck the fleet. In 1281 a stone wall built after the first invasion and the warriors of Kyushu kept an eastern army of 40,000 from landing, and a typhoon wrecked the joined fleets, some 140,000 men in all.6
One samurai left a record of his own part. Takezaki Suenaga, a retainer from Higo, fought in 1274, rode to Kamakura to claim his reward, and fought again in 1281, then had scrolls painted of his deeds. Thermopylae is remembered through an epitaph for 300 men who died together. Hakata is remembered through the claim of one man who survived and asked to be paid.7

Training
The case for the Spartan
No Greek state trained its citizens as Sparta did. Plutarch writes that newborn sons were examined by the elders, that at seven every boy was taken by the state and enrolled in a company, and that the boldest became its captain, so that boyhood itself was practice in obedience. Xenophon adds that the boys went barefoot, wore one garment all year and were allowed to steal food, to learn the skills of a raider.8
The same sources show the system's harsh side. Plutarch says infants judged weak were taken to a chasm under Mount Taygetus called the Apothetae, and Xenophon describes youths with whips set over the boys. This is how the Spartans' admirers described the system, not a modern measurement of it.9
The case for the samurai
The samurai trained as mounted archers from the start. The Heibonsha encyclopedia describes inuoumono, shooting with blunted arrows at dogs released in a fenced ring, as one of the three mounted archery exercises with kasagake and yabusame, popular from the Kamakura period on. The Nihon Kokugo Daijiten records the last one, held for the Meiji emperor in 1881.10
The samurai ideal of the bow and horse was old too. The Ōbunsha dictionary describes the way of bow and horse as the practical warrior ethic of the medieval period, built on loyalty between lord and retainer, courtesy, courage and plain living, which was given a theory only in the Edo period as bushido.11
How they fought
The case for the Spartan
The Spartan was a soldier of the line. Herodotus has Demaratus tell Xerxes that the Spartans, fighting singly, are as brave as any man living, and together the best warriors on earth, because law is their master and bids them never to flee but to stand and conquer or die. At Plataea in 479 BC, he records, the 5,000 Spartiates held the right wing, the post of honour.12
Thucydides, an Athenian with no reason to flatter them, describes the Spartans at Mantinea in 418 BC fighting long and stubbornly until the enemy broke, then pursuing only a short way, in what he calls the greatest battle among the Greeks for a very long time.13
The case for the samurai
The samurai changed with the wars he fought. The scrolls of Takezaki show a mounted archer, and Nipponica notes how exactly they render the weapons and armour of the 13th century. Three centuries later, the Kotobank dictionaries record, Japan had taken up the matchlock after 1543, and at Nagashino in 1575 guns decided a famous battle. The Metropolitan Museum's yoroi of the 14th century, 17.3 kg as mounted, shows the armour of the archer era.14

Duty and glory
The case for the Spartan
Sparta asked its men to put the city before themselves. Plutarch collects the sayings of Spartan mothers, among them the one who handed her son his shield and told him to come back with it or on it. Herodotus writes that he learned the names of all 300 who fell at Thermopylae, because they were worthy men.15
The case for the samurai
The samurai fought for his lord and for his own name. Takezaki went to Kamakura to press his claim and won the stewardship of Kaitō, the Nipponica entry on him records, and had his deeds painted to pass on to his descendants. The Heibonsha encyclopedia quotes the medieval ideal that before the commander a man fights on even if his father dies and his son falls.16
The best known line of the samurai code is late. The Hagakure, finished around 1716 from the talks of the Nabeshima retainer Yamamoto Tsunetomo, says that the way of the warrior is found in dying, and the Heibonsha entry on it, by Sagara Tōru, notes that it was written against the Confucian way of the warrior official.17
Defeat and surrender
The case for the Spartan
The Spartan ideal was never to surrender, and it held at Thermopylae. It broke at Sphacteria in 425 BC, when, Thucydides writes, 292 men were taken alive to Athens, about 120 of them Spartiates, and nothing in the war surprised the Greeks so much. One of their bronze shields, inscribed by the Athenians as loot from Pylos, was found in the Agora of Athens in 1936, the excavation record notes.18
The end came on the battlefield. At Leuctra in 371 BC, Xenophon writes, nearly a thousand Lacedaemonians fell, among them some 400 of the 700 Spartiates present. Diodorus gives more than 4,000 Lacedaemonian dead against about 300 Boeotians. The two figures cannot both be right, and we give both.19
The case for the samurai
The samurai's great defence succeeded, but not by courage alone. The Nihon Kokugo Daijiten credits both the armed defence and the seasonal winds for the two Mongol defeats, and records that the wind was later proclaimed kamikaze, the divine wind. The Yamakawa dictionary adds the invaders' own weaknesses, mixed armies, low morale and ships built in haste.20
The samurai class also had its long decline without a battle. Under the Tokugawa peace, the Nipponica entry on the samurai notes, they became salaried retainers who lost the independence of the old landholding warriors, and their fighting strength withered.21
Numbers and decline
The case for the Spartan
Sparta's citizen body was always small and shrank. The Enciclopedia Italiana gives about 8,000 Spartiates in 480 BC, later reduced to a quarter. Aristotle writes that their land could support 1,500 horse and 30,000 foot, but the citizens numbered not even a thousand, and the city could not survive a single blow.22
The system rested on the helots, the unfree farmers of Laconia and Messenia. At Plataea, Herodotus says, each Spartiate was attended by seven of them. Ellen Millender, reviewing a volume of studies on them, reports Paul Cartledge's view that their harsh treatment and the shortage of Spartan citizens help explain their revolts.23
The case for the samurai
The samurai lasted far longer as a class, and changed. The Nipponica entry on them describes how, in the long Edo peace under the ban on private war, their fighting power declined and they reached the end of the shogunate with almost no experience of battle. After the Meiji Restoration the sword ban and the equality of the four classes ended their status. The Heibonsha entry on the samurai adds that their army gave way to one of conscripts.24
Legend
The case for the Spartan
Much of what we know about Sparta was written by outsiders, many of them admirers. Paul Cartledge, as his reviewer in the Bryn Mawr Classical Review sums him up, held that the Spartan mirage, the legend that grew around the city, can be studied but never fully dispelled, and saw Sparta as being as foreign to other Greeks as the Soviet Union and China were to the West.25
The case for the samurai
The samurai legend has a modern author too. Nitobe Inazō's English book Bushido, the Soul of Japan, published in 1899, called bushido the chivalry of Japan and admitted that it was not a written code. The Kotobank dictionaries date the classic bushido texts to the peaceful Edo period.26
Nitobe also gave the West a curriculum. He listed the subjects of a samurai's education as fencing, archery, jujutsu, horsemanship, the use of the spear, tactics, calligraphy, ethics, literature and history, an ideal written down long after most samurai had stopped fighting. Even the Hagakure has its own legend: the Heibonsha entry calls the story that it was a banned book doubtful.27
How historians have judged them
We found no historian who compares Spartans and samurai directly, so there are no rival verdicts to set against each other here. What the scholarship does show is that each legend needs its own correction. For Sparta, modern work on the mirage and the helots warns against reading the admiring ancient writers at face value. For the samurai, the Japanese reference works separate the medieval way of bow and horse from the bushido written down in peacetime.28
The ancient witnesses quoted here for Sparta were not Spartans themselves, and much of the legend, Cartledge's reviewer notes, was built by others. The key witness for the samurai at Hakata wrote about himself to win a reward. Both kinds of evidence have to be read for what they were meant to do.29
Battles on the site
Echoes of Battle has no page for a battle between Spartans and samurai, because there was none. These are the pages on each side's battles and the guides that set them in context.
Spartans · 480 BCThe Battle of Thermopylae, 480 BC: the 300 and the Hot Gates
Spartans · 479 BCThe Battle of Plataea, 479 BC: Persia driven out
Greeks against Persia · 490 BCThe Battle of Marathon, 490 BC: the day Athens saved itself
Spartan kingLeonidas
Head to headSparta vs Athens: the rivalry that shaped ancient Greece
GuideThe Greco-Persian Wars (499 to 449 BC): Causes, Major Battles and Who Won
ExplainerWhat Was a Phalanx?
RankingThe Greatest Last Stands in History
Samurai · 1575Battle of Nagashino, 1575: the volley that broke the samurai cavalry
Samurai · 1600The Battle of Sekigahara, 1600: the battle that made a shogun
Samurai abroad · 1592 to 1598The Imjin War (1592 to 1598): Causes, Battles and Outcome
Invaded Japan · 1274 and 1281Kublai Khan
CommanderOda Nobunaga
CommanderTakeda Shingen
GuideThe Military History of Japan, from the Samurai to Today
Head to headSamurai vs Knight
Sphacteria, Leuctra and the Mongol invasions of Japan do not have pages yet.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For the Spartan
- A state training system from the age of seven
- The best heavy infantry of its age, by its enemies' admission
- Thermopylae, a stand to the last man
- A culture that put the city before the man
- Plataea, the post of honour on the right wing
For the samurai
- Mounted archers trained from youth, who later mastered the gun
- Hakata Bay, where two invasions failed
- A warrior class that lasted for most of a thousand years
- Adaptation from bow to spear to firearm
- An ethic of loyalty that outlived the battlefield
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Can warriors fifteen centuries apart be compared at all, or only the societies that made them?
- Is a soldier better because he never retreats, or because he wins and survives?
- How much of each legend was written by outsiders, admirers or later nationalists?
- Should Sphacteria and the Edo peace count as much as Thermopylae and Hakata Bay?
- Does the decline of both classes say something about professional warrior elites in general?
Cast your vote below and see how other readers have judged them.





