Sparta or Athens: what does the evidence say?
Sparta was the first land power of classical Greece, Athens the first sea power. They fought side by side against Persia in 480 and 479 BC and against each other in the Peloponnesian War of 431 to 404 BC, which ended with Athens' surrender to Sparta. Historians have not settled it. Sparta had the best army and won the war, with Persian money. Athens had the best navy and the richer empire, and held out for years after its disaster in Sicily. Thucydides blamed Athens' defeat on its own politics, a reading Kagan challenged point by point. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
Thucydides, the Athenian general who wrote the history of their war, put the contrast in a single sentence: once Persia had been driven off, Greece split into two camps, one led by Athens, the first naval power, the other by Sparta, the first military power. The Enciclopedia Italiana calls the war that followed the bloodiest ever fought among Greeks.1
This is not a ranking. Below you will find the two cities side by side, the campaigns in which they met, and six questions on which a state at war can be judged, from its army to what it left behind. Under each we give the strongest evidence for Sparta and the strongest for Athens, with the ancient writers and modern historians who argue each case, and the weak points of each inside its own case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
SpartaLacedaemon, head of the Peloponnesian League
AthensHead of the Delian League- Kind of power
- Land, with an army of citizen hoplites and many allies
- Sea and money, with a league of islands and coastal cities
- Government
- Ruled by law: "law is their master", in the words Herodotus gives an exiled Spartan king
- Democracy, in which, says one critic, the poor who rowed the fleet held power
- The city
- Villages without a city wall
- The Acropolis and its monuments, the Long Walls to Piraeus
- At Plataea, 479 BC
- 10,000 Lacedaemonians, 5,000 of them Spartiates
- 8,000 Athenians, holding the left wing
- At sea, 480 BC
- 10 ships at Artemisium
- 127 ships at Artemisium, the largest Greek contingent
- Money
- No tribute empire, later Persian subsidies
- Tribute from the allies, a sixtieth of it dedicated to Athena and listed in stone from 454/3 BC
- Citizens
- Fewer than 1,000 Spartiates in Aristotle's day
- A much larger citizen body
- Battles named here
- Thermopylae, Plataea, Sphacteria, Mantinea, Aegospotami, Leuctra
- Marathon, Salamis, Plataea, Sphacteria, Syracuse, Aegospotami
Figures from Herodotus for 480 and 479 BC, with Aristotle, the Attic tribute lists and modern scholarship on Sparta. We give no win and loss totals: most battles of the war were fought by allies on both sides, and no source counts them the same way.2
Where they met: allies, then enemies
Allies against Persia, 480 to 479 BC
Before they were enemies they were allies. At Artemisium in 480 BC, Herodotus counts 127 Athenian ships in the Greek fleet against 10 from Sparta. At Plataea the next year the Spartans held the right wing with 10,000 Lacedaemonians, 5,000 of them Spartiates, each attended by seven helots, and the 8,000 Athenians held the left. Our pages on Thermopylae, Salamis and Plataea tell those battles.3

Pylos and Sphacteria, 425 BC
The war's first great shock fell on Sparta. An Athenian force fortified Pylos on the coast of Messenia, and Spartan hoplites were cut off on the island of Sphacteria. Thucydides counts 292 men taken alive to Athens, about 120 of them Spartiates, after a blockade of 72 days, and writes that nothing in the war surprised the Greeks so much. Diodorus gives the same 120 Spartiates and 180 allies, brought to Athens in chains by Cleon.4
The surrender left traces in Athens that can still be seen. Pausanias, travelling in the 2nd century AD, saw bronze shields in the Painted Stoa said to be those of the Spartans taken on Sphacteria, smeared with pitch to keep off rust. In 1936 excavators of the American School found one such bronze shield in a cistern on Kolonos Agoraios, the Agora excavation record notes, inscribed in punched letters as Athenian loot from the battle of Pylos of 425 BC.5
Mantinea, 418 BC
Sparta answered on land. At Mantinea it beat an army of Argives, Mantineans and Athenians in what Thucydides calls the greatest battle for a very long while among the Greeks. He gives the losses of the other side as 700 Argives and allies, 200 Mantineans and 200 Athenians and Aeginetans with both their generals, against about 300 Spartans by report, and says the charge of cowardice over Sphacteria was wiped out by this single action.6
Sicily, 415 to 413 BC
Athens' greatest blow fell far from Sparta. Diodorus records that the expedition sailed with 140 triremes and more than 7,000 allied troops besides the crews. A Spartan, Gylippus, led the defence of Syracuse. The Enciclopedia Italiana says Athens lost almost its whole fleet in the harbour of Syracuse and thousands of men in the retreat.7
Aegospotami and the surrender, 405 to 404 BC
The war ended at sea. Xenophon, Plutarch and Diodorus all give the Athenian fleet at the Hellespont as 180 ships. Lysander caught it on the beach at Aegospotami while the crews were scattered ashore. Xenophon says only Conon's ship, seven others and the state galley Paralus got away, and that the other 171 were taken, and Plutarch says Lysander took 3,000 prisoners with their generals.8
In spring 404 BC Athens surrendered. Xenophon describes the Long Walls coming down to the music of flute girls, the allies thinking that day the beginning of freedom for Greece, and Plutarch tells the same scene, adding that Lysander set up thirty rulers in the city and a Spartan garrison on the Acropolis.9

War on land
The case for Sparta
In a pitched battle no Greek state could match Sparta. Herodotus has the exiled king Demaratus warn Xerxes that the Spartans, fighting together, are the best warriors on earth, because law is their master and it bids them never to flee from any multitude of men but to stand and conquer or die. At Plataea, he writes, the Spartans took the post of honour on the right wing.10
The case for Athens
Athens did not need to win on land to survive, and Sphacteria showed that Spartans could be beaten. An Athenian critic of the democracy known as the Old Oligarch, in a short treatise long attributed to Xenophon, observed that the Athenians stored their goods on the islands, trusting to their command of the sea, and let Attica be ravaged without a sigh. The historian Donald Kagan, as Tim Rood sums him up, thought this defensive strategy of Pericles weaker than Thucydides allowed.11
War at sea
The case for Sparta
Sparta learned to fight at sea and won the war there. Diodorus records that at Notium in 406 BC, while Alcibiades was away, Lysander beat the Athenian fleet and took 22 ships. At Aegospotami he caught the last great Athenian fleet on the beach, and Plutarch writes that he ended in a single hour a war of unmatched length and variety.12
The case for Athens
Athens was the sea power of Greece from the Persian Wars on: at Artemisium it supplied 127 ships, by far the largest contingent in Herodotus' list. The Old Oligarch explains the politics behind it: it was the common people who manned the fleet, the steersmen, boatswains and rowers, who gave the city its power, far more than its heavy infantry. Even late in the war Athens could win at sea, as at Arginusae in 406 BC, which Diodorus describes.13

Money
The case for Sparta
Sparta found the money it lacked. Xenophon has the Persian prince Cyrus tell the Spartan envoys that he had brought 500 talents, and that if this ran out he would coin the gold and silver throne he sat on. Plutarch describes Lysander winning Cyrus over against the satrap Tissaphernes, whose meagre subsidies had held the fleet back.14
The case for Athens
Athens began the war rich. Thucydides gives an average revenue of 600 talents a year from the allies' tribute, 6,000 talents of coined silver on the Acropolis, and an army of 13,000 hoplites with 16,000 more on guard and 300 triremes. The tribute was recorded in stone: Attic Inscriptions Online explains that from 454/3 BC a sixtieth of each city's payment was dedicated to Athena and listed on stelai on the Acropolis, the first of them some 3.8 metres high.15
Decisions
The case for Sparta
Sparta's system was stable and its citizens drilled for war. Paul Cartledge, as his reviewer in the Bryn Mawr Classical Review describes his work, saw it as an armed camp whose citizens dined in their messes every night. When its ships finally won, Sparta used the moment: within months of Aegospotami, Plutarch tells, Athens had surrendered.16
Its slowness was notorious, and an Athenian historian enjoyed saying so. In 411 BC, when Athens had lost Euboea and had no fleet to defend Piraeus, the Spartans did not attack, and Thucydides calls them the most convenient people in the world for the Athenians to be at war with.17
The case for Athens
Athens could take risks no other Greek state would, and paid for some of them. In a speech Thucydides writes for the Corinthians, the Athenians are born to take no rest themselves and give none to others, while the Spartans have a genius for keeping what they have and a total want of invention. Yet Thucydides also blames Pericles' successors for a host of blunders, the Sicilian expedition among them, and says Athens fell in the end to its own internal disorders.18
Not everyone accepts that verdict on the assembly. Ugo Fantasia, as Bruno Bleckmann reports, argues that by leaving out Athens' treaty with Segesta, Thucydides made the people's vote for Sicily look far more irrational than it was. Kagan went further and held that Thucydides was writing partly to defend the generals blamed for Sicily and for Amphipolis, himself among them.19
Citizens and manpower
The case for Sparta
Every Spartiate was a soldier, but the numbers were small and shrinking. The Enciclopedia Italiana puts the Spartiates at 8,000 in 480 BC, reduced to a quarter of that by the 4th century, and Aristotle writes that their land could support 1,500 cavalry and 30,000 infantry, yet the citizens numbered not even a thousand, so that the city could not survive a single blow and was ruined for want of men.20
The whole system rested on the helots, the unfree population of Laconia and Messenia who worked the land: at Plataea, Herodotus says, each Spartiate was attended by seven of them. Ellen Millender, reviewing a volume on the helots, reports Paul Cartledge's view that their brutal treatment and the shortage of Spartan citizens help explain their unusual revolts, and Susan Alcock's warning that the evidence is so thin that the helots have become a kind of Rorschach test for historians.21
Leuctra in 371 BC showed what that meant. Xenophon says nearly a thousand Lacedaemonians fell there, among them some 400 of the 700 Spartiates present. Diodorus gives more than 4,000 Lacedaemonian dead against about 300 Boeotians. The figures differ widely, and both are given here.22
The case for Athens
Athens drew on a far larger population, and its fleet was manned by the poorer citizens, as the Old Oligarch complained. Its losses were still terrible: the Enciclopedia Italiana counts thousands dead in the retreat from Syracuse. Stewart Flory, reviewing Victor Davis Hanson's study of the war, notes that Hanson builds his case on its death toll, and warns that the ancient figures he relies on are often exaggerated.23
What came after
The case for Sparta
Sparta won the war and led Greece for a generation. The Enciclopedia Italiana describes its hegemony after 404 BC, backed by Persian support that was confirmed in the King's Peace of 386 BC. It also records how it ended: Sparta's harsh rule over its allies broke up its league, and after Leuctra in 371 BC the lead passed to Thebes and Messenia was lost. Xenophon's account of Leuctra shows how heavy the blow was.24
The case for Athens
Athens lost the war but kept what it had built, and its monuments still shape how both cities are seen. Thucydides remarked that no visitor could guess Sparta's power from its plain villages, a passage Cartledge, his reviewer notes, explains by Sparta's lack of a city wall and of urban splendour.25
The record of its empire survives too. The tribute lists of the Delian League, inscribed from 454/3 BC, are the most massive of all Athenian inscriptions, Attic Inscriptions Online notes, and the portions dedicated to Athena probably helped pay for the Periclean buildings on the Acropolis.26
The Enciclopedia Italiana draws a darker conclusion for both. The war left Greece so impoverished and weakened, it suggests, that this may be one reason why the Greeks resisted Macedon so little sixty years later, when Philip II marched south.27
How historians have judged them
The ancient judgement comes mostly from Athenians. Thucydides admired Pericles' strategy and blamed Athens' defeat on its own politics, a reading Kagan challenged point by point: in his view, as Rood lists it, Thucydides was wrong that the war was inevitable, wrong about Pericles' strategy and unfair to Cleon at Pylos. Aristotle explained Sparta's decline by its shrinking citizen body.28
Others defend Thucydides. Rood himself disputes Kagan's reading of the passage on the war's causes, and Fantasia, Bleckmann notes, sees little reason to challenge Thucydides' authority, holding that even his speeches can help reconstruct events. Paul Cartledge argued that Sparta was as foreign to other Greeks as the Soviet Union and China were to the West of the 1960s, and that the Spartan mirage, the legend built around it, can be studied but never fully dispelled.29
For Victor Davis Hanson the war was unlike any other because of the lives it cost, a reading that Flory finds rich in insight but weak in its use of ancient numbers. Between the Athenian witness, the Spartan mirage and the body count, the evidence leaves room for more than one verdict.30
Battles on the site
Echoes of Battle has no page yet for a battle between Sparta and Athens. These are the pages on the wars they fought together, the men who led them, and the guides that set them in context.
Sparta leads · 480 BCThe Battle of Thermopylae, 480 BC: the 300 and the Hot Gates
Athens' fleet · 480 BCThe Battle of Salamis, 480 BC: the narrows that saved Greece
Side by side · 479 BCThe Battle of Plataea, 479 BC: Persia driven out
Athens and Plataea · 490 BCThe Battle of Marathon, 490 BC: the day Athens saved itself
Guide · 499 to 449 BCThe Greco-Persian Wars (499 to 449 BC): Causes, Major Battles and Who Won
Spartan kingLeonidas
Athenian leaderPericles
Athenian commanderThemistocles
Athenian commanderMiltiades
Their common enemyXerxes I
After themPhilip II of Macedon
ExplainerWhat Was a Phalanx?
RankingThe Greatest Battles of Ancient Greece
RankingThe Greatest Commanders of Ancient Greece
RankingThe Greatest Naval Battles in History
QuizHow Well Do You Know Greek Battles?
Sphacteria, Mantinea, Syracuse, Notium, Arginusae, Aegospotami and Leuctra do not have pages yet. See also Spartan vs Samurai.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For Sparta
- The strongest army in Greece, proved again at Mantinea
- The post of honour at Plataea, with 5,000 Spartiates
- A navy built almost from nothing that won at Notium and Aegospotami
- Victory in the war, and Athens' surrender in 404 BC
- A system that drilled every citizen for war
For Athens
- The largest contingent of the Greek fleet against Xerxes
- Sphacteria, the surrender no one thought possible
- Money enough for a fleet of 300 triremes
- A citizen body large enough to replace its losses
- An empire documented in stone on the Acropolis
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Does winning the war make Sparta the stronger state, when it needed Persian money to build the fleet that won it?
- Should Athens be judged by Pericles' strategy or by the assembly's choices after him, Sicily above all?
- Is a state that cannot replace its citizens strong or brittle?
- How far can we trust Thucydides, an exiled Athenian general, on Athenian mistakes and Spartan virtues?
- Which counts more: the battles each won, or what each still had after 404 and 371 BC?
- Was the real winner Persia, which paid for Sparta's fleet?





