Samurai or knight: what does the evidence say?
The samurai were the mounted warrior class of Japan, the knights the mounted warrior class of medieval Europe. They never met in battle, so no source can tell us how a fight between them would have gone. Both did meet the same enemy, the Mongols. Knightly armies lost to them on land at Legnica and Mohi in 1241. Japan held both times, in 1274 and 1281, but the Nihon Kokugo Daijiten credits both the armed defence and the seasonal winds, and which weighed more cannot be measured. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The comparison is old. In 1899 the Japanese writer Nitobe Inazō published in the United States an English book on bushido and opened it by calling it the chivalry of Japan, a flower no less native to its soil than the cherry blossom. He explained that he had rendered the word roughly as chivalry, and that bushido literally meant the ways of the military knight. The Japanese encyclopedias on Kotobank date the bushido he described to ideas that grew from the Kamakura period and took their mature form in the Edo period, combined with Confucian thought.1
This is not a ranking, and it cannot be a duel. Below you will find the two side by side, the nearest the two worlds came to each other, and six questions on which a warrior class can be judged, from its weapons to what became of it. Under each we give the strongest evidence for the samurai and the strongest for the knight, with the period writers and modern reference works that argue each case, and the weak points of each inside its own case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
SamuraiJapan
KnightMedieval Europe- Period
- From the 10th and 11th centuries to the Meiji Restoration, after which samurai status disappeared
- From the 11th century to the 16th, when firearms and infantry ended the supremacy of heavy horse
- Organisation
- Retainers (gokenin) of the shogunate and of great lords, fighting under provincial commanders
- A landed class bound by feudal ties, often younger sons equipped to serve on horseback
- Arms and armour
- Bow and sword. Laced lamellar armour: a 14th-century yoroi in the Met weighs 17.3 kg
- Lance and sword. Mail, then plate: a Milanese armour of about 1575 in the Met weighs 21.5 kg, its horse armour another 39.9 kg
- Tactics
- Mounted archery in the early period, later armies built around foot soldiers and guns
- The mounted charge with the lance, dismounted fighting in some wars
- Recruitment and reward
- Hereditary warriors rewarded with land rights for deeds in battle
- Hereditary nobility, with land held for service
- Shared enemy
- The Mongol and Goryeo invasions of 1274 and 1281
- The Mongol invasion of Poland and Hungary in 1241
Periods, weapons and organisation as given by the Japanese reference works on Kotobank, the Enciclopedia Italiana and the Metropolitan Museum's records. The two never fought each other, so there is nothing to count.2
Where they came closest: the Mongol invasions
The samurai and the knight never met, but they met the same enemy. In 1241 the Mongols invaded Poland and Hungary, and our pages on Legnica and Mohi tell how those battles went. A few years later the Franciscan John of Plano Carpini travelled through Poland and Russia to the Mongol court and wrote a chapter on how Christians could resist them. Thirty years after that, the same empire under Kublai Khan sent two invasions against Japan, told below.3
Hakata Bay, 1274
The first invasion, the Yamakawa dictionary of Japanese history records, carried about 20,000 Mongol, Jurchen and Chinese troops and 8,000 Koreans of Goryeo, in some 900 ships. They took Tsushima and Iki, and on 20 October landed on the west of Hakata Bay. The Nipponica encyclopedia says the Japanese struggled against the Mongols' massed tactics and their exploding missiles, and the defenders fell back towards Dazaifu.4
That night the invaders returned to their ships and a great storm struck them. Nipponica puts those who never returned at more than 13,500. The Yamakawa dictionary adds reasons of its own for the failure: quarrels among the commanders of a mixed army, low morale and ships built in haste.5

Hakata Bay and Takashima, 1281
Japan prepared for a second attack. After 1274, the Yamakawa dictionary notes, the shogunate built a stone wall along Hakata Bay and set up a rota of Kyushu warriors to guard it. In 1281 Kublai sent two fleets: an eastern army of 40,000 Mongols, Chinese and Koreans in 900 ships and a southern army of about 100,000, mostly former Song troops, in 3,500 ships. The eastern army reached Hakata Bay but was kept from landing by the wall and the defenders, and fell back to Takashima.6
There, at the turn of the seventh month, a great storm almost destroyed the joined fleets, and Shogakukan's Daijisen dictionary places the wreck site off Kōzaki on Takashima, where many Mongol ships are said to have sunk. The Nihon Kokugo Daijiten notes that the great wind was later proclaimed as kamikaze, the divine wind.7
One samurai's war
The best witness on the Japanese side is a single warrior. Takezaki Suenaga, a retainer from Higo born in 1246, fought in 1274 under Shōni Kagesuke, went to Kamakura to claim a reward for his deeds and received the stewardship of Kaitō, and in 1281 took enemy heads again. He then had scrolls painted of his own actions. The encyclopedias on Kotobank call them one of the basic sources on the invasions and praise their exact depiction of men, horses, weapons and armour.8
Weapons and fighting
The case for the samurai
The samurai began as mounted archers. The Heibonsha encyclopedia traces the warrior ethic to a phrase that arose when warriors first set their way of life against that of the court nobles: the custom of those who take up bow and arrow. Takezaki's scrolls show him on horseback with the bow, and the Heibonsha entry on them notes what they reveal about the warriors' customs, way of fighting and weapons.9
The bow set the samurai apart from his European counterpart. Pavlac's entry on medieval warfare puts it in one line: unlike samurai, Western knights disdained the bow.10
The case for the knight
The knight was built for the charge. Brian Pavlac's encyclopedia entry on medieval warfare describes a mass of knights, secure in their saddles with stirrups and holding their lances tight under their arms, delivering a decisive blow. The English soldier John Cruso, writing in 1632, still described the lancer of the last knightly age: a horse that had to be very good and exceedingly well trained, and a rider long practised with a lance that took much labour to learn.11
Knights could also fight on foot. At Crécy, Froissart writes, the English men-at-arms stood in their divisions behind archers arranged in the manner of a harrow, and waited for the French to come to them.12

Armour
The case for the samurai
Japanese armour was light and flexible. The Metropolitan Museum's yoroi attributed to Ashikaga Takauji, made in the early to mid 14th century, weighs 17.3 kg as mounted, built of small plates laced together. In the 16th century, the Heibonsha encyclopedia notes, Japanese armourers made solid-plate cuirasses, among them the nanban-dō, European armour brought by Portuguese ships and remade for Japanese use.13

The case for the knight
European armour went further towards closing the body in steel. An Italian armour for man and horse in the Metropolitan Museum, of about 1575 to 1590, has a man's armour of about 21.5 kg and horse armour of nearly 40 kg with its saddle. Froissart's account of Crécy shows the cost of that steel: once the French men-at-arms and their horses were down in the press, he writes, they could not rise again.14
Against the Mongols
The case for the samurai
Japan held both times. In 1281, the Yamakawa dictionary says, the wall and the defenders kept the eastern army from landing at Hakata, and the invasion was already stalled before the storm. Takezaki Suenaga, the Nipponica entry on him records, fought in 1274 and took enemy heads again in 1281.15
The weak point is how much the sea and the storms did. The Nipponica entry says the fighting of 1274 ended undecided, with the invaders withdrawing that night before the storm struck, and both invasions ended with fleets wrecked by weather. Defending a coast against an army that had to cross the sea is not the same as meeting it on open plains.16
The case for the knight
European knights faced the Mongols on land, without a sea between, and Carpini's chapter shows what one witness thought they would need. He advised Christian princes to unite, to arm their men with strong bows and crossbows, iron maces and long-handled axes, to harden their arrowheads, to use lances with hooks to pull Mongols from their saddles, and never to pursue far, because the Tartar fights more by stratagem than by main force.17
Knightly armies lost in 1241, as our pages on Legnica and Mohi tell. Carpini's advice, written within a few years, is itself the evidence that Europeans thought their way of fighting had to change, and Pavlac notes that the Mongols went on to conquer the Russians, the Turks and China.18
Guns
The case for the samurai
Japan adopted the gun fast. In 1543, the Kotobank dictionaries record from the Teppōki, Portuguese who reached Tanegashima brought matchlocks, and the island's lord Tanegashima Tokitaka bought two and had his men learn to make and use them. Within a generation, at Nagashino in 1575, Oda Nobunaga's guns won a famous battle, and the same dictionary notes that firearms changed both tactics and castle building.19
The long peace that followed had its own cost. Under the Tokugawa ban on private war and the closed country, the Nipponica entry on the samurai notes, their fighting power declined, and they reached the end of the shogunate with almost no experience of real battle.20

The case for the knight
Europe met the gun first and changed its horsemen around it. Pavlac describes how longbows, then handguns and cannon, and finally Swiss pikemen in formation ended the effectiveness of the mounted warrior. Cruso describes the outcome in 1632: the lancer was replaced by the cuirassier, armed at all points with pistols and sword.21
The code
The case for the samurai
The samurai ideal had deep roots. The Heibonsha encyclopedia quotes a line from the medieval war tale Hōgen monogatari: before the commander a man fights on even if his father dies and his son is cut down, and traces the later split between the Confucian way of the warrior official, taught by Yamaga Sokō, and the way of the warrior set out in the Hagakure, with its line that the way of the warrior is found in dying.22
Much of what the world knows as bushido is later. Nitobe himself admitted that it was not a written code, and the dictionaries date its classic texts to the peaceful Edo period, when, Nipponica notes, samurai had almost no experience of real war, and his own book to 1899.23
The case for the knight
Chivalry was medieval in its own time. The Enciclopedia Italiana describes how the knights, at first notorious for brutality, took on under the Church's influence a knightly morality devoted to defending churches and the faithful, and how its code of loyalty, piety, courtesy and good faith comes down above all in French and Provençal literature.24
The Church also tried to limit the knight's wars. In 1139 the Second Lateran Council banned the murderous art of crossbowmen and archers against Christians, a rule kings ignored. Pavlac describes a code of honour immortalised by minstrels in courtly halls. Ideal and practice were as far apart in Europe as in Japan.25
What came after
The case for the samurai
The samurai outlived the knight by centuries as a class. They fought on through the age of guns at Nagashino and Sekigahara and ruled Japan until the Meiji Restoration, after which, Nipponica records, the sword ban and the equality of the four classes ended their status. Nitobe's book carried their ideal far beyond Japan.26
The case for the knight
The knight's place on the battlefield passed to new kinds of horse and foot, but the idea survived. The Enciclopedia Italiana notes that the knightly code later became the rules of honour, collected in Italy in Iacopo Gelli's Codice cavalleresco of 1892, and Nitobe chose the European word chivalry, quoting Burke on its passing, to explain Japan to the West.27
How historians have judged them
The comparison is itself a product of the 19th century. Nitobe wrote that he would not compare European and Japanese feudalism in detail, yet called bushido chivalry from his first page. The Japanese reference works treat bushido as an ethic that grew over centuries and was given its classic form in peacetime, and the Italian one treats chivalry the same way, as an ideal shaped by the Church and by literature.28
For the battles that do link the two worlds, the reference works stress different things. The Nihon Kokugo Daijiten credits both the armed defence and the seasonal winds for the two defeats, and notes that the wind was later proclaimed divine. Which weighed more cannot be measured. How much credit belongs to the samurai on the beaches of Hakata is the question the evidence leaves open.29
Battles on the site
Echoes of Battle has no page for a battle between samurai and knights, because there was none, and none yet for the Mongol invasions of Japan. These are the pages on each side's battles, on the Mongols who fought both, and the guides that set them in context.
Knights against Mongols · 1241Battle of Legnica, 1241: when the Mongols reached Europe
Knights against Mongols · 1241Battle of Mohi 1241: How the Mongols Crushed Hungary
Invaded Japan · 1274 and 1281Kublai Khan
Samurai · 1575Battle of Nagashino, 1575: the volley that broke the samurai cavalry
Samurai · 1600The Battle of Sekigahara, 1600: the battle that made a shogun
Samurai abroad · 1592 to 1598The Imjin War (1592 to 1598): Causes, Battles and Outcome
Knights · 1066The Battle of Hastings, 1066: the day England changed hands
Knights · 1346The Battle of Crécy, 1346: the longbow's day
Knights · 1415The Battle of Agincourt, 1415: the longbow's day
Knights · 1410The Battle of Grunwald, 1410: the day the Teutonic Order broke
CommanderOda Nobunaga
CommanderTokugawa Ieyasu
CommanderRichard the Lionheart
GuideThe Military History of Japan, from the Samurai to Today
Head to headMongol vs Knight
Head to headSpartan vs Samurai
The Bun'ei and Kōan invasions of 1274 and 1281 do not have pages yet.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For the samurai
- Mounted archers who could fight at a distance and up close
- Held the Mongols on the beaches in 1274 and 1281
- Light, flexible armour, and later European cuirasses adopted and remade
- Took up the gun within a generation of meeting it
- A warrior class that lasted into the 19th century
For the knight
- The armoured charge that dominated European battle for centuries
- Plate armour for man and horse
- Met the Mongols on open ground, with no sea in between
- A code of chivalry written down in its own age
- An ideal that Japan's own writer borrowed to explain bushido
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Can two warriors who never met be compared at all, or only the societies that made them?
- Does Japan's defence in 1274 and 1281 say something about the samurai, or about the sea and the storms?
- Is the right comparison the samurai archer of 1274 or the armoured officer of 1600, the knight of 1066 or of 1500?
- How much of what we think we know about both comes from later ideals, bushido books and romances?
- Which matters more: the man, his armour, or the army around him?
Cast your vote below and see how other readers have judged them.






