Longbow or crossbow: what does the evidence say?
The English longbow was a single stave of yew drawn by hand. The crossbow was a short, powerful bow fixed to a stock, spanned with the feet, a hook or a winder and shot from a trigger. The two met head on at Crécy in 1346 and again at Agincourt in 1415. Historians have not settled which was better. Clifford Rogers credits many English victories to the mass use of archers, while Kelly DeVries warns that this leaves out the soldiers and their leaders. At both battles the crossbowmen were placed where they could do little. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The crossbow was the older weapon of the two in medieval Europe's wars. In 1139 the Second Lateran Council condemned the murderous art of crossbowmen and archers when used against Christians, and both kept being used anyway. Two centuries later the armies of England relied on massed archers with the longbow, while France, Italy and most of the Continent relied on professional crossbowmen, many of them from Genoa.1
This is not a ranking. Below you will find the two weapons and the men who used them side by side, the battles where they met, and six questions on which a missile weapon can be judged, from rate of shooting to how long it lasted. Under each we give the strongest evidence for the longbow and the strongest for the crossbow, with the period writers and modern scholars who argue each case, and the weak points of each inside its own case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
LongbowEnglish and Welsh archers
CrossbowGenoese and Continental crossbowmen- Period
- The English armies of the Hundred Years' War, 1337 to 1453. Still issued on the Mary Rose, sunk in 1545
- In Europe from at least the First Crusade. Named beside arquebusiers in Mantua in 1570, last listed in an Urbino inventory in 1630
- Organisation
- Thousands of archers in each royal army, beside dismounted men-at-arms
- Companies of hired professionals, such as the Genoese under Grimaldi and Doria at Crécy
- Arms and armour
- A single piece of yew, 1.84 to 2.11 m on the Mary Rose, draw weights estimated at 65 to 175 lb. Arrows mostly of poplar
- A bow of horn and sinew or, later, of steel, on a wooden stock with a nut and trigger. Short, thick bolts with heavy iron heads
- Tactics
- Massed shooting from a defended line, behind stakes or carts
- In sieges, at sea and in the field: light crossbows by hand, heavy ones on stands
- Recruitment and cost
- Commoners who practised from youth, encouraged by royal writs such as that of 1363
- Hired professionals. The stirrup, hook or winder did the work of the arm
- Where they fought
- Scotland, France, the Wars of the Roses
- All over Europe and the Mediterranean, the Crusades, Italian city wars
Construction, dates and organisation as given by the Mary Rose Trust, the Metropolitan Museum, the Enciclopedia Italiana and the chroniclers cited below. We give no win and loss totals: both weapons were used side by side with others, and no source counts their battles the same way.2
Where they met: Crécy and Agincourt
Crécy, 26 August 1346
Crécy is the one great set piece in which massed crossbowmen opened the battle against massed longbowmen, and we have two near-contemporary accounts that disagree on almost every number. Jean Froissart, the Hainault chronicler, has about 15,000 Genoese crossbowmen in the French vanguard. Giovanni Villani, a Florentine writing within a few years, gives about 6,000 Genoese and other Italian crossbowmen under Carlo Grimaldi and Antonio Doria. For the English, Villani writes of some 30,000 English and Welsh archers. Jean le Bel, Froissart's own source, puts the whole French army at 20,000 men-at-arms and more than 100,000 foot. These are the chroniclers' figures, and none of them can be checked.3
Both writers describe a bad start for the crossbowmen. Froissart says they had marched six leagues that day under arms and told their constables they were in no state to fight. Then came a great rain with thunder, and after it the sun shone in the Frenchmen's eyes and on the Englishmen's backs. Villani mentions only a little rain before the battle began. Philip Jones's encyclopedia entry on the battle notes that many historians have speculated that wet strings spoiled the Genoese shooting, but neither chronicler says so.4

The exchange itself is short in both. The Genoese came forward with three shouts and shot, Froissart writes, and then the English archers stepped forth one pace and let fly their arrows together, so thick that it seemed snow. Villani puts it as a ratio: for every bolt the Genoese shot, the English shot three arrows, and they looked like a cloud in the air. He adds that the English stood behind and on top of a ring of carts covered with cloth that kept off the bolts, and that their bombards made a noise like thunder. When the Genoese turned, Froissart has Philip VI shout to kill these rascals who were blocking the way.5
Then the crossbowmen broke, and their own side finished them. Jean le Bel writes that the Genoese were soon beaten by the archers and would have fled, but the great lords' divisions rushed forward in no order and shut them in between themselves and the English, so that horses fell on them. Villani tells the same end: the second French line pressed so hard behind them that the Genoese were crushed against the carts, could not shoot, and turned, and the French knights, thinking they had been betrayed, killed them. The full story is in our article on the Battle of Crécy.6
Agincourt, 25 October 1415
Seventy years later the roles were the same but the crossbowmen played a smaller part. The Gesta Henrici Quinti, written by a chaplain in Henry V's army, says that after the siege of Harfleur the king had no more than 900 lances and 5,000 archers fit to fight. Hearing that the French planned to ride down his archers with mounted squadrons, Henry ordered every archer to cut a stake six feet long, sharpened at both ends, to plant in front of him.7
On the day, the Gesta says, the French crossbows stood behind their men-at-arms and on the flanks, loosed one hasty volley that hurt very few, and drew back before the strength of the English bows. The French cavalry that charged the archers was driven back by the rain of arrows or caught on the stakes. When their arrows ran out, the archers took up axes, stakes and swords. See the Battle of Agincourt and Henry V.8

Rate of shooting
The case for the longbow
The best period evidence is Villani's three arrows to one bolt at Crécy, from a Florentine with no reason to flatter the English. Philip Jones's encyclopedia entry on Crécy says a skilled archer could shoot up to twelve arrows a minute, and that volume of fire is the most important feature of any missile weapon.9
In a modern study of the longbow's effectiveness, Vinicius de Souza e Cruz cites an estimate that at Agincourt some 7,000 archers could have shot up to 14 arrows a minute each. That is an estimate, not a measurement, and we give it as his source does.10
The case for the crossbow
Speed was never the crossbow's selling point. Anna Komnene, the Byzantine princess who wrote about the crusaders' weapon in the 12th century, describes a man lying almost on his back, pressing both feet against the bow and pulling the string with both hands. The Enciclopedia Italiana lists the ways that labour was eased: a belt hook and a stirrup for the foot, then geared winders. The Royal Armouries notes that large crossbows had such heavy draw weights that spanning devices were needed to pull the string back.11
What the crossbowman got for that time was a weapon he could hold cocked and aim. The bolt waited in the groove, held by the nut, until he pulled the trigger, as the Enciclopedia Italiana describes the mechanism. A longbowman had to hold the full draw in his arms.12
Power and armour
The case for the longbow
The Mary Rose, Henry VIII's warship sunk in 1545, gives the only large set of real English war bows: 172 of the 250 listed for the ship, each a single piece of yew between 1,839 and 2,113 mm long. The Mary Rose Trust gives estimated draw weights of 65 to 175 lb, with a peak at 110 lb.13
Cruz reports tests with bows modelled on the Mary Rose finds: arrows from a bow of 120 lb, striking almost square on, pierced up to 2 mm of steel depending on its hardness, while glancing hits on angled plate tended to slide off. Jean le Bel describes what the arrows did to the French horses at Crécy: feeling the barbed shafts, one would not go forward, another reared as if mad, another kicked, another turned its back on the enemy, and others let themselves fall.14
The case for the crossbow
The crossbow's reputation was for sheer force. Anna Komnene writes that its short, thick bolts with heavy iron heads went through a shield, then through a heavy iron corselet and out the other side, and calls it a devilish invention. She describes a bolt that pierced a Latin count's shield and scale armour and reached his side. Brian Pavlac's encyclopedia entry on medieval warfare calls the crossbow an easy-to-use weapon that could puncture most armour.15
It killed a king. Roger of Howden records that at the siege of Châlus in 1199 an arbalister, Bertram de Gurdun, struck Richard the Lionheart in the arm from the castle wall, and that the wound killed him. The Enciclopedia Italiana notes that Richard had himself armed his infantry with crossbows, ignoring the Church's ban.16

Training and cost
The case for the longbow
England built its archers from the bottom up. On 1 June 1363 Edward III sent the sheriffs of London a writ to proclaim archery as a pastime in place of football and cock-fighting. The bow itself, the Mary Rose finds show, was a single piece of yew, with nothing to buy but the stave, the string and the arrows.17
The cost of that system was time. Cruz notes that a force of archers needed either permanent social measures, as in England, or a body of professionals kept in constant training, which few lords could afford. The Mary Rose's 24 wristguards, mostly leather, two stamped with the arms of Henry VIII and Katherine of Aragon, show that the habit was still alive in the 1540s.18
The case for the crossbow
The crossbow put the strength into the machine. Anna Komnene's man draws it with his legs and back, and later spanning devices did the pulling for him, as the Royal Armouries notes. Jones observes that a crossbowman needed little training, which is why the weapon could be hired by the company, as the French hired the Genoese at Crécy.19
It was not cheap. A Central European crossbow with a steel bow of about 1600 to 1650 in the Metropolitan Museum weighs 4.26 kg, and the separate cranequin used to wind it another 2.3 kg. The machine that saved training cost money and iron.20
Tactics and protection
The case for the longbow
The English used their archers as part of a system. At Crécy Froissart has the archers of the prince's division standing in the manner of a harrow with the men-at-arms behind them, and Villani has them behind a ring of carts. At Agincourt the Gesta describes the stakes. In both battles the archers shot from a defended position at an enemy who had to come to them. Pavlac describes the English formula as archers supported by dismounted knights, which beat both the Scots and the French.21
The case for the crossbow
The crossbow did not need that system. It was a weapon for the walls and the decks as much as for the field: Froissart has archers and crossbows shooting at each other across the ships at Sluys in 1340, and the Enciclopedia Italiana lists heavy crossbows mounted on stands for the defence of walls. At Crécy the Genoese were sent in first, after a long march, with their own cavalry pressing in behind them, as Jean le Bel tells it.22
The Church and the law
The case for the longbow
Canon 29 of the Second Lateran Council banned both weapons against Christians, so the bow carried the same stain as the crossbow. In England the longbow was instead promoted by the Crown: the writ of 1363 asked men to shoot on their days of leisure.23
The case for the crossbow
The ban itself is a measure of how much the Church feared what these weapons could do, and it was ignored: Richard I, as noted above, armed his own infantry with crossbows. Anna Komnene, who called the crossbow a devilish invention, tells the same story from Byzantium.24
What came after
The case for the longbow
The English kept the longbow as an issued weapon into the Tudor age. When the Mary Rose sank in 1545 she had 250 bows on her list, more than 2,000 complete arrows and some 7,000 fragments. Our pages on Towton and the Wars of the Roses follow the war bow into England's own civil wars.25
The case for the crossbow
The crossbow outlasted the war bow on the Continent and changed with the times. Steel bows and geared winders, like the cranequin of 1556 in the Metropolitan Museum, kept it powerful. The Enciclopedia Italiana finds crossbowmen named next to arquebusiers in a Mantuan edict of 1570 and the last crossbows in an Urbino inventory of 1630. It ended as a sporting and ceremonial weapon, as the Royal Armouries' target crossbows show.26
As soldiers, the Genoese crossbowmen also lasted: Zeus Longhi notes that despite Crécy they remained the core of Genoa's army and elite mercenaries, and that 700 of them took part in the last defence of Constantinople in 1453.27
How historians have judged them
The period writers were mostly struck by the longbow at Crécy. Froissart's snow of arrows and Villani's three to one are the core of every later account. On the other side, Anna Komnene's description of the crossbow is one of the most vivid accounts of a missile weapon in any medieval text.28
Modern historians argue about how much credit the bow deserves. Cruz summarises the debate between Clifford Rogers, who holds that many English victories were won because of the mass use of archers, and Kelly DeVries, who warns that this turns medieval history into technological determinism and leaves out the soldiers and their leaders. In Cruz's reading Rogers himself denies that any serious scholar credits the bow alone, and stresses the psychological effect of arrows falling together.29
Jones, in his entry on Crécy, calls the claim that the longbow caused a military revolution an exaggeration, since the feudal order was already in decline.30
The evidence itself is lopsided. Most of what we know about Crécy and Agincourt comes from the side that won or from writers who admired it, and in both battles the crossbowmen were placed where they could do little, ahead of their own cavalry or behind their own men-at-arms. The crossbow's best witnesses are its victims: a Byzantine princess and a dying king.31
Battles on the site
Every battle page on Echoes of Battle where English archers met crossbowmen, the other battles of the longbow and the crossbow, and the guides that set them in context.
Head to head · 1346The Battle of Crécy, 1346: the longbow's day
Head to head · 1415The Battle of Agincourt, 1415: the longbow's day
Longbow · 1356Battle of Poitiers, 1356: the day England took a king
Longbow · 1424Battle of Verneuil, 1424: the second Agincourt
Longbow · 1428 to 1429Siege of Orléans 1428 to 1429: How Joan of Arc Broke It
Longbow · 1298Battle of Falkirk 1298: Wallace, Edward I and Who Won
Longbow · 1314Battle of Bannockburn, 1314: how Scotland won its freedom
Longbow · 1461Battle of Towton 1461: England's Bloodiest Battle?
Crossbow · 1191The Battle of Arsuf, 1191: Lionheart vs Saladin
Killed by a bolt · 1199Richard the Lionheart
Guide · 1337 to 1453The Hundred Years' War, 1337 to 1453
CommanderHenry V
CommanderJoan of Arc
Another bowHorse Archers
RankingThe Greatest Battles of the Middle Ages: a guide
QuizHow Well Do You Know Medieval Battles?
Sluys, Nájera, Patay and Formigny, where archers met crossbowmen or guns, do not have pages yet.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For the longbow
- Three arrows to every bolt at Crécy, by an Italian chronicler's count
- A simple weapon, one piece of yew
- Draw weights of up to 175 lb on the Mary Rose bows
- Crécy and Agincourt, where crossbowmen were driven off
- A whole country trained to use it
For the crossbow
- Bolts that went through shield and mail, by a witness's account
- Could be held cocked and aimed
- Usable by men without years of practice
- Killed Richard the Lionheart
- In service across Europe for some five centuries
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Is a weapon better if only a nation that trains from youth can use it well?
- Should Crécy count against the crossbow, when the Genoese came off a long march and were cut down by their own knights?
- Which matters more: how fast a weapon shoots, or how hard each shot hits?
- If the English relied on stakes, carts and dismounted men-at-arms, how much credit goes to the bow itself?
- Why did most of Europe keep the crossbow long after Crécy?
- How far can we trust battles whose story comes mainly from the winners?






