Heavy or light cavalry: what does the evidence say?
Heavy cavalry was armoured horsemen on big horses, kept back for the decisive charge. Light cavalry was faster riders on lighter horses who scouted, screened, raided and pursued. They met as enemies, from the Parthian horse archers at Carrhae to the Russian horse at Balaclava, and far more often worked side by side. The two most quoted theorists took different sides. Nolan called the light cavalry's service the most important in the field and heavy cavalry more formidable in appearance than in reality. Jomini wanted a balance, with lance-armed cuirassiers to break squares. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The two names cover more than two thousand years, and their meaning shifted. The Parthians who destroyed a Roman army in 53 BC combined mail-clad lancers with a far larger number of mounted archers. The hussar, to take one name, began as light horse in Hungary, the Enciclopedia Italiana notes, was taken up in Prussia by Frederick II and in France by Napoleon, and spread to almost every European army after the wars of the Revolution.1
In the 1850s the British cavalry officer Louis Nolan still divided the arm into heavy, middle and light horse, each with its own work, and wrote that none of them was fit to perform all the duties a horseman is asked for in the field.2
This is not a ranking. Below you will find the two kinds of horse side by side, the battles where they met, and six questions on which a cavalry arm can be judged, from the shock of the charge to what became of it. Under each we give the strongest evidence for heavy and for light cavalry, with the period writers and theorists who argue each case, and the weak points of each inside its own case. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
Heavy cavalryCataphracts, men-at-arms, cuirassiers
Light cavalryHorse archers, hussars, chasseurs, Cossacks- Period
- From the Parthian mail-clad horse to the French cuirassiers of World War I
- From the Parthian and steppe horse archers to the Cossacks and light regiments of the 19th century
- Organisation
- Held in hand for the decisive charge, in close lines with reserves behind
- Spread out in advance, on the flanks and in the rear of the army
- Arms and armour
- Lance or heavy sword, armour for the rider and often the horse, an iron cuirass in the 19th century
- Bow, sabre, lance or pistol, little or no armour
- Tactics
- The charge in line at the trot or gallop, at the moment of decision
- Scouting, screening, raiding supplies, harassing fire, pursuit
- Recruitment and cost
- Big men on big, well trained horses, kept fresh with great care
- Smaller horses and plenty of them: the Mongols rested each mount three or four days
- Where they fought
- Iran and the Near East, medieval and early modern Europe, Napoleon's battles
- The steppe, the Near East, every European army from the 16th century on
Roles and equipment as the ancient and medieval writers, the Enciclopedia Italiana and the museums cited below describe them. We give no win and loss totals: the two kinds of horse almost always fought in the same armies, and no source counts their battles apart.3
Where they met: Carrhae and Balaclava
Carrhae, 53 BC: one army with both
The clearest ancient case is an army that used both kinds of horse against infantry. Plutarch says the Parthian commander Surena travelled with a thousand mail-clad horsemen and a still greater number of light-armed cavalry as his escort. When the Romans first saw them, he writes, the Parthians dropped the covers from their armour and showed helmets and breastplates of glittering steel, on horses clad in plates of bronze and steel.4
Cassius Dio explains how the two arms worked together. If the Romans locked shields against the arrows, the armoured lancers charged into them, and if they spread out to escape the lancers, the archers shot them down. Plutarch adds that when the Romans hoped the archers would run out of arrows, they saw camels loaded with fresh supplies. The story of Crassus' defeat is told in full on our page on the Battle of Carrhae.5
Balaclava, 25 October 1854: both brigades in one morning
On the British side at Balaclava the Heavy and the Light Brigade fought within an hour of each other. The National Army Museum puts the Heavy Brigade at 800 horsemen against a Russian cavalry force about 3,000 strong. William Howard Russell of The Times watched the Greys and the Enniskilleners ride straight at the centre of the Russian mass: the shock was but for a moment, he wrote, and the Russians retired in confusion.6
Lord George Paget, who commanded the Light Brigade's second line and watched from close by, described the same fight with less glory. The Heavies never went faster than about eight miles an hour, he wrote, scrambling through a vineyard over eighty or a hundred yards, and the Russians halted within twenty yards of the ditch as if bewildered. The museum gives the advance as little faster than a trot, lasting about ten minutes, and Paget says the fight itself took no more than five.7
Then came the order to the Light Brigade. Russell records that the guns opened on it at 1,200 yards, from thirty iron mouths, and that Captain Louis Nolan, who carried the order, was killed by the first shot. Of the 673 men who rode, the National Army Museum says, about 260 were killed or wounded and 475 horses were lost, and Russell writes that it was all the Heavy Brigade could do to cover the retreat of the survivors. See the Battle of Balaclava.8

The charge
The case for heavy cavalry
The decisive blow was what heavy cavalry was for. Nolan defines it as large men in defensive armour on heavy, powerful horses, held in hand for decisive charges on the day of battle. Mariano Borgatti's entry on the cuirassier in the Enciclopedia Italiana describes the heavy cavalry of the 16th and 17th centuries as horsemen meant to overthrow the enemy more by shock than by their weapons.9
The armoured horseman was also built to impress. Ammianus Marcellinus, describing the emperor Constantius II's entry into Rome in 357, writes of the fully armoured cavalry called clibanarii, masked and covered limb by limb in thin iron plates that moved with the body, so that you might have taken them for statues rather than men.10
Balaclava shows that this could still work in 1854. The Heavy Brigade, by the museum's count little more than a quarter the size of the Russian force, broke it in minutes, and Russell has the 4th and 5th Dragoon Guards finishing the rout by riding at its flank.11
The case for light cavalry
The military theorist Antoine-Henri Jomini gives the light horse the most deadly charge of all: thrown at the flank or rear of an enemy line at the moment it is attacked in front, cavalry may cause the loss of the enemy's army, and this, he writes, is a duty for which light cavalry is particularly fitted.12
Light horse could also hit hard. Procopius, describing the mounted archers of the emperor Justinian's armies, says they rode in corselets and greaves with bow, sword and sometimes a spear, could shoot to either side at full speed, in pursuit or in flight, and drew to the ear with enough force that neither shield nor corselet could stop the arrow.13
Its limit is just as clear in Jomini. Irregular horse like the Cossacks, he writes, could defeat the best cavalry in skirmishes, but could not be relied on in the regular battles that decide a war: valuable accessories to an attack in line, but alone they lead to no decisive results.14
Scouting and supply
The case for heavy cavalry
The heavy horse was spared these tasks on purpose, so that it would be fresh on the day. Nolan writes that the greatest possible care was taken of it in the field: it did no outpost duty, no foraging and no reconnoitring, and could not even escort a convoy, because its horses fell off in condition on the road. It was kept for the one task only it could do.15
The case for light cavalry
Nolan calls the light cavalry's service the most important in the field. It watched over the safety of the army, constantly hovering in advance, on the flanks and in the rear to prevent surprise, and cut off the enemy's supplies and communications. The Enciclopedia Italiana notes that once infantry and firearms ended the supremacy of cavalry at the end of the 15th century, the arm survived above all for exploration before battle, besides shock and pursuit during it.16
The steppe armies show how far this could go. John of Plano Carpini, the papal envoy who travelled to the Mongols in the 1240s, says each warrior carried two bows or one good one and three quivers, and that a horse ridden one day was not ridden again for three or four days. Dio says the Parthians led whole droves of horses with them on campaign, so that they could change mounts and ride up suddenly from a distance.17
Against infantry and guns
The case for heavy cavalry
Jomini thought only the heaviest horse could break formed infantry: to break good squares, cannon and lancers are required, or better still cuirassiers armed with lances. At Carrhae, as Dio tells it, it was the Parthian lancers' charge that punished the Romans for closing ranks. Jomini is just as frank about the limits. A charge against squares of good infantry in good order cannot succeed, he writes, and the great French charges at Waterloo were admirable but failed because they were unsupported.18

The case for light cavalry
Light horse with missiles could wear infantry down where a charge could not. At Carrhae, Plutarch writes, the Parthians stood at long intervals and shot from all sides, and the Roman light troops sent out against them ran back for shelter under the arrows.19
Against guns, light cavalry has both the worst and one of the best days in the record. At Balaclava the Light Brigade rode a mile and a half of open plain into a battery, as Russell describes. At Somosierra on 30 November 1808, the Polish light horse of Napoleon's Guard took a mountain pass held by Spanish guns and infantry in a charge of a few minutes, as Jolanta Niklewska writes in her study of the charge, and Magdalena Pawlak describes the same charge on the Spanish batteries in her study of its painters.20
Horses and cost
The case for heavy cavalry
A heavy horseman was an investment, and armies treated him as one. The English soldier John Cruso wrote in 1632 that the lancer needed a horse that was very good and exceedingly well exercised, and a rider long practised with the lance.21
The case for light cavalry
Light cavalry let an army use every horse it had. Nolan observes that a horse unfit to carry a cuirassier would be lost to the service unless used by the dragoons or the light cavalry, and that the large Continental armies, unable to make all their horse good, fell back on a system of expedients. The armour and equipment of the heavy horseman, he adds, detract from the speed and lasting qualities of the horse.22
The steppe answer was numbers. Dio says the Parthians practised archery and riding from boyhood on land made for raising horses, and Carpini that the Mongols ran their horses in rotation. Carpini also notes that the richer Mongols wore iron or leather armour and rode armoured horses, a reminder that even the classic light horse armies had a heavy core.23
Firearms
The case for heavy cavalry
Firearms at first made the heavy horseman heavier. Cruso describes the cuirassier, armed at all points and carrying two pistols, as a recent invention that replaced the lancer. Jomini, two centuries later, still thought the iron cuirass the best armour for heavy cavalry and saw no use for the carbine on horseback, since a horseman had to halt to shoot it with any accuracy.24
The case for light cavalry
Jomini allows pistol fire a place only for outpost duty, for charges in open order, and when light cavalry wants to annoy infantry and draw its fire before a charge. Cruso, in 1632, already describes lighter horsemen built around firearms, the harquebusier and the carabine, mounted on swift or middling horses. The Enciclopedia Italiana dates the end of cavalry's supremacy to firearms and well drilled infantry at the end of the 15th century, after which the arm survived mostly in the roles light cavalry already filled.25
What came after
The case for heavy cavalry
The heavy horseman lasted into the machine age. The Australian War Memorial records that France had twelve cuirassier regiments in World War I, the last cavalry in Europe to wear breastplates in the field, under a brown cloth cover.26
The case for light cavalry
The light horseman's work outlived the horse. The Enciclopedia Italiana notes that during World War II armoured vehicles replaced the horses of the cavalry, and that cavalry so transformed kept its old tasks of exploration, preliminary fighting and mobile defence in retreat. Our page on Mokra in 1939 follows Polish cavalry fighting in that war.27
How the theorists judged them
The two most quoted 19th-century writers took different sides. Nolan argued that heavy cavalry was more formidable in appearance than in reality and that the light cavalry's service was the most important in the field. Jomini wanted cuirassiers with lances for breaking squares, lancers in the front rank, hussars to follow up, and irregular horse for skirmishing, a balance between the two.28
History added an irony. Nolan, the champion of light cavalry, carried the order that sent the Light Brigade down the valley at Balaclava and was, in the National Army Museum's words, the very first man to be killed in the charge. The museum leaves open whether he meant to prove his own theories on the potency of a cavalry attack.29
The eyewitnesses at Balaclava judged the day by its orders as much as by its horsemen. Russell quotes the maxim that cavalry never act without support, and notes that the Light Brigade's only support was the heavy cavalry far behind it. Paget, who rode with the light horse, praised the Heavies' courage but would not call their scramble through the vineyard a charge.30
Battles on the site
Battle pages on Echoes of Battle where heavy and light cavalry met or worked together, with the guides that set them in context.
Both brigades · 1854The Battle of Balaclava
Lancers and horse archers · 53 BCBattle of Carrhae 53 BC: How Parthia Destroyed Crassus
Light horse against guns · 1808Battle of Somosierra, 1808: the charge that opened the road to Madrid
Cuirassiers · 1815The Battle of Waterloo, 1815: the end of an empire
Heavy and Numidian horse · 216 BCThe Battle of Cannae, 216 BC: Hannibal's perfect trap
Companion cavalry · 331 BCThe Battle of Gaugamela, 331 BC: Alexander breaks an empire
Cavalry · 378Battle of Adrianople, 378: how the Goths destroyed Valens and his army
Horse archers · 1071The Battle of Manzikert, 1071: the day Byzantium broke
Knights and horse archers · 1191The Battle of Arsuf, 1191: Lionheart vs Saladin
Knights and Mongols · 1241Battle of Legnica, 1241: when the Mongols reached Europe
Mamluks and Mongols · 1260Battle of Ain Jalut 1260: Who Won and How the Mongols Lost
Hussars and reiters · 1605Battle of Kircholm, 1605: the winged hussars' finest hour
Seydlitz's horse · 1757Battle of Rossbach, 1757: Frederick the Great's ninety-minute victory
Mamluk horse · 1798Battle of the Pyramids, 1798: Bonaparte's squares break the Mamluks
Cuirassiers · 1807Battle of Friedland, 1807: the victory that brought Russia to Tilsit
Cavalry · 1812The Battle of Borodino, 1812: the bloodiest day
Cavalry battle · 1920The Battle of Komarów, 1920: the last great cavalry battle
Cavalry · 1939The Battle of Mokra, 1939: Polish cavalry against German tanks
GuideHorse Archers
RankingGreatest Cavalry Charges
RankingThe Largest Cavalry Battles in History
RankingThe Most Famous Cavalry Units in History
Head to headWinged Hussars vs Cuirassiers
Head to headMongol vs Knight
Mars-la-Tour in 1870, Eylau in 1807 and Omdurman in 1898, often cited in this debate, do not have pages yet.
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.
For heavy cavalry
- The decisive charge, as at Balaclava against odds of nearly four to one
- The only horse Jomini trusted to break good squares
- Armour for man and horse, from the Parthians to the cuirassiers
- Kept fresh for the day of battle
- Breastplates still worn in the field in 1914
For light cavalry
- Scouting and screening, in Nolan's words the most important service in the field
- The flank and rear attack Jomini thought could destroy an army
- Horse archers who, with lancers, destroyed a Roman army at Carrhae
- Somosierra, a pass taken in minutes
- A role that survived into the age of armoured vehicles
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Should cavalry be judged by its rare decisive charges or by its daily work of scouting and supply?
- Was heavy cavalry beaten by light cavalry, or by infantry and firearms?
- Do the Heavy Brigade's success and the Light Brigade's losses at Balaclava say more about the two arms or about the orders they were given?
- When hussars and lancers charged in line like heavy horse, does the distinction still hold?
- At Carrhae the two kinds of horse won together. Can either be judged alone?
- Which matters more for an army: the blow that breaks a line, or the horsemen who make sure the enemy never surprises you?




