PLSubscribe
The Death of Paulus Aemilius at the Battle of Cannae, painted by John Trumbull in 1773: the wounded Roman consul sits among the fallen as an officer offers him his horse

Rome vs Carthage

Military history · Head to head · Evidence for both, the verdict is yours · ~16 min read · Updated November 2026

John Trumbull, 1773, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

In short

Rome or Carthage: what does the evidence say?

Rome and Carthage fought three Punic Wars between 264 and 146 BC. Rome won all three: the first gave it Sicily, the second ended with Hannibal's defeat at Zama in 202 BC, and the third with Carthage destroyed. Historians give different reasons. Polybius credited the Roman constitution and citizen army. Mommsen thought the two powers equally matched at the start, but wrote that Carthage never made up for its lack of a land army and of allies of its own. This page sets out the evidence for each side and leaves the final verdict to you.

Carthage was a trading city on the coast of Africa with the best fleet in the western Mediterranean. Rome was a farming republic in Italy with a citizen army and a web of Italian allies. Treccani notes that the two were at first on friendly terms, and that their interests collided in Sicily after Rome's war with Pyrrhus. Mommsen, comparing their resources, agreed with the judgement of a sagacious and impartial Greek that when the struggle began they were on the whole equally matched.1

This is not a ranking. Below are the two powers side by side, the three wars in which they met, and six questions on which a state at war can be judged, each with the strongest evidence for Carthage and for Rome. At the end the decision is yours.

Side by side

Carthaginian glass head pendant of the 4th to 3rd century BCCarthageQart-hadasht
Roman warship with armed men on deck, from a relief at PraenesteRomeThe Roman Republic
Wars
264 to 241, 218 to 201, 149 to 146 BC
The same three wars
Government
An aristocratic republic in which, Polybius says, the people had already won the chief voice
An aristocratic republic in which the Senate still decided
Army
African subjects, allied tribes and hired mercenaries
Citizens and Italian allies, raised by levy
Navy
The leading sea power of the western Mediterranean
Almost none in 264 BC, then built on a captured Carthaginian model
Men under arms
No total recorded
Over 700,000 foot and 70,000 horse able to bear arms in 225 BC, by Polybius' count
Best-known commanders
Hamilcar Barca, Hannibal, Hasdrubal, Mago
Duilius, Lutatius Catulus, Fabius, Marcellus, Scipio Africanus, Scipio Aemilianus
End
Taken and destroyed by Scipio Aemilianus in 146 BC
Made Africa a Roman province, governed from Utica

Dates and outcomes from the Treccani encyclopedia, government, army and navy as Mommsen and the ancient writers describe them. Both images are period objects, not portraits of a state: a Carthaginian glass pendant of the 4th to 3rd century BC in the Metropolitan Museum, and a Roman warship relief. We give no win and loss totals because the sources count the battles differently.2

Where they met: three Punic Wars

The First Punic War, 264 to 241 BC

The war began in Sicily in 264 BC, when the Mamertines of Messana asked Rome for help. The summary of Livy notes that this was the first time the Romans crossed the sea with an army. Rome had no real navy. Polybius says the Romans used a captured Carthaginian decked ship as a model and built their whole fleet on its pattern.3

To make up for poor seamanship they fitted their ships with a boarding bridge, the raven. Florus describes the effect: the heavy, slow Roman ships came to grips with the swift enemy craft, and grappling irons that the enemy had laughed at before the battle fastened on their ships and made them fight as if on dry land.4

Frontinus credits the consul Duilius with the invention: seeing his heavy ships eluded by the mobile Carthaginian fleet, he devised a grappling hook, so that his men could lay gangways over the bulwarks and fight hand to hand on the enemy's own vessels.5

Grappling irons the enemy had laughed at before the battle made the Carthaginians fight as if on dry land.

Rome then took the war to Africa and lost an army. Eutropius says the consul Regulus was beaten by the Spartan Xanthippus, whom Carthage had hired, that thirty thousand Romans were killed, five hundred captured with Regulus and only two thousand escaped. Frontinus credits Xanthippus with bringing the Carthaginians down from the hills to level ground, where their elephants broke the Roman ranks.6

The summary of Livy adds the most famous story of the war. Carthage sent the captive Regulus to Rome to negotiate peace or an exchange of prisoners, on oath to return if he failed. He advised the Senate to refuse both, went back to his captivity, and was put to death.7

The war was decided at sea in 241 BC. Leading Romans paid for a new fleet of two hundred ships out of their own pockets, Polybius says, to be repaid if all went well, and Lutatius Catulus won at the Aegates Islands. Polybius calls it the longest, most continuous and greatest war he knew of. Rome lost about seven hundred quinqueremes, counting those wrecked in storms, and Carthage about five hundred. Eutropius says no sea battle had ever been fought with such forces as at the Aegates.8

Ancient relief of a Roman warship with armed men on deck
A Roman warship with soldiers on deck, from a relief at the Temple of Fortuna Primigenia at Praeneste, as reproduced by Élisée Reclus in 1905. Public domain

The Second Punic War, 218 to 201 BC

Carthage rebuilt its power in Spain, and in 219 BC Hannibal besieged and took Saguntum, an ally of Rome. He marched over the Alps and destroyed Roman armies at the Trebia, Lake Trasimene and Cannae. After Cannae, Mulligan's chronology records, Capua and many regions of southern Italy went over to him and he allied with Philip V of Macedon.9

Rome held on. Syracuse fell to it in 212 BC and Capua in 211. Scipio took New Carthage in 209, Hasdrubal was destroyed at the Metaurus in 207, and in 204 Scipio landed in Africa. Carthage recalled Hannibal, and at Zama in 202 BC Scipio beat him. The full story is in our guide to the Punic Wars.10

The Third Punic War, 149 to 146 BC

The last war was short and one-sided. Treccani says the Carthaginians would have given in to every Roman demand except the order to abandon their city and build a new one ten miles from the sea. After three years of resistance Scipio Aemilianus took the city in 146 BC. Appian says 50,000 men and women came out of the citadel to surrender, and Florus that the fire burned for seventeen days.11

Engraving of a kneeling man holding out an olive branch before a Roman general
Hasdrubal, the last commander of Carthage, kneels with an olive branch before Scipio Aemilianus in 146 BC, as Appian tells it. Engraving after Silvestre David Mirys, 1799, Bibliothèque nationale de France. Public domain

Sea power

The case for Carthage

Polybius, no friend of Carthage, grants it the sea: the Carthaginians are superior at sea in efficiency and equipment, because seamanship has long been their national craft. Mommsen adds that their rowers were well trained, their captains expert and fearless, and that it was at Carthage that ships with more than three banks of oars were first built.12

Even after Mylae Carthage could still beat Roman fleets. At Drepana in 249 BC, Eutropius writes, the consul Claudius fought against the omens and lost: of 220 ships he escaped with thirty, ninety were taken and the rest sunk. His colleague lost another fleet in a storm.13

The case for Rome

Rome learned the sea in a single war. Treccani says the Romans saw early that Carthage had to be beaten at sea, because its fleet could always bring more mercenaries from Africa, and that Duilius' victory at Mylae proved the new fleet. At the Aegates, Eutropius writes, the Romans took sixty-three Carthaginian ships and sank 125.14

War on land

The case for Carthage

Carthage's generals won the greatest land battles of the wars. Xanthippus destroyed Regulus' army in 255 BC. Hannibal won at the Trebia, Trasimene and Cannae. At Cannae, Livy gives 45,500 Roman infantry and 2,700 cavalry killed, and Eutropius forty thousand foot and 3,500 horse, among them a consul and some twenty former consuls and praetors. Polybius' figure, about seventy thousand dead, is higher still.15

Hannibal kept winning after Cannae. Mulligan's chronology records a Roman army defeated at the Silarus in 212 BC and another destroyed at Herdonea in 210, and the consuls Marcellus and Crispinus ambushed and killed in 208.16

Battle map of Cannae with Carthaginian units in blue closing around the Roman army in red beside the Aufidus river
The double envelopment at Cannae, 216 BC, the heaviest defeat Rome suffered in the wars. After the US Military Academy history atlas. Public domain (US government work), via Wikimedia Commons

The case for Rome

Polybius judges that in military service on land the Romans were much more efficient, because they devoted their whole energies to it while Carthage neglected its infantry. Rome lost battles and kept fighting. Plutarch reports Pyrrhus' famous remark a generation earlier, that one more victory over the Romans would ruin him, because their army filled up again as if from a gushing fountain.17

Mulligan's chronology shows the same in figures: in 213 BC, three years after Cannae, the Romans raised an army of over 200,000 men.18

After Trasimene Rome also found a strategy that suited its numbers. Plutarch says the dictator Fabius Maximus would not fight Hannibal out but meant, having plenty of time, money and men, to wear down his strength, his scanty resources and his small army, keeping to the hills out of reach of his cavalry. Plutarch also reports Posidonius' saying that Fabius was Rome's shield and Marcellus its sword, and Hannibal's own remark that he feared Fabius as a tutor but Marcellus as an adversary.19

Rome also found generals who could beat the Barcids. Scipio took New Carthage, won at Ilipa and the Great Plains, and at Zama defeated Hannibal himself. Treccani says Scipio had perfected an encircling tactic superior to Hannibal's.20

Florus admires the march that won the Metaurus in 207 BC: the two consuls, Nero at one end of Italy and Livius at the other, joined their armies with such skill and speed that they surprised Hasdrubal before Hannibal knew they had moved.21

Manpower and soldiers

The case for Carthage

Carthage could pay for an army almost at will. Mommsen writes that such an army could be raised to almost any strength, that the Libyan subjects made good infantry and unsurpassed light cavalry, and that in the ability of its officers, knowledge of arms and courage it could match Rome's. Its money also built the war machines and the stalls for three hundred elephants under the walls of the city.22

The case for Rome

Rome's soldiers were its own citizens and allies. Polybius writes that Carthage depended for its freedom on the courage of mercenaries, Rome on the valour of its own people. In 225 BC, he says, the Romans and their allies able to bear arms numbered more than seven hundred thousand foot and seventy thousand horse, while Hannibal invaded Italy with fewer than twenty thousand men.23

The census figures tell the same story. Eutropius records a census of 292,334 citizens taken before Rome had yet fought outside Italy, and the summary of Livy 297,797 at the census in its middle years, in both cases citizens only, without the allies.24

Carthage paid for its system. After the First War its unpaid mercenaries revolted, and Polybius says the war that followed lasted three years and four months and far excelled all wars he knew in cruelty. Mommsen writes that more than once Carthage found its paid soldiers more dangerous than its enemies.25

Allies

The case for Carthage

Hannibal's plan was to break up Rome's alliance in Italy, and for a time it worked. Capua and many communities of the south went over to him after Cannae, and he made an alliance with Philip V. Michael Fronda's study of southern Italy, as Kathryn Lomas sums it up, argues that each community's choice was driven mainly by local self-interest and rivalries, which gave Hannibal openings.26

The case for Rome

Most of the allies held. Treccani notes that all of central Italy and several southern centres stayed loyal, which let Rome resist and return to Fabius' strategy of wearing Hannibal down, and judges that Hannibal misread the cohesion of the Italian federation. Mommsen contrasts Italy, where most towns kept their walls and a chain of Roman fortresses held the peninsula, with Africa, where Carthage dared not fortify its subject cities.27

Rome also turned Carthage's African allies. The Numidian king Masinissa fought for Scipio at Zama, where, Frontinus writes, he led the Numidian horse on one wing, and Livy says his horsemen helped drive the Carthaginian cavalry from the field.28

Government and endurance

The case for Carthage

Carthage recovered from defeat twice. After losing Sicily and then Sardinia and Corsica, it rebuilt its power in Spain under the Barcids, Treccani notes, and after 201 BC it recovered as a trading state. Mommsen says it spent all its money and skill on the walls of the capital, and that more than once nothing but those walls saved the state.29

Its own historians are lost, and almost everything we know comes from the winners. Nepos, one of the few ancient writers to praise a Carthaginian, says Hannibal surpassed other commanders in skill as much as Rome surpassed other nations in courage, and blames the jealousy of his fellow citizens for his defeat.30

The case for Rome

Polybius' explanation is the constitution. At Carthage the people already had the chief voice in deliberations, at Rome the Senate still did, so the Roman decisions were better, and although the Romans met with complete disaster, they won in the end by the wisdom of their counsels. Livy, after Cannae, has Hannibal's cavalry commander Maharbal tell him he knew how to win a victory but not how to use it, and adds that the delay is believed to have saved the City.31

Florus describes what Rome did instead: the Romans took down the arms hanging in the temples, freed slaves to fight, and when the treasury was empty the senators gave up their own gold. Eutropius adds that after Cannae no Roman would even speak of peace.32

Peace terms and the end

The case for Carthage

Carthage paid. In 241 BC the Roman people rejected the first terms and sent commissioners who halved the time to pay, added a thousand talents to the 2,200 already agreed and took the islands between Sicily and Italy, Polybius writes. In 201 BC Carthage gave up its warships except ten triremes, its elephants and the right to make war without Rome's consent, and owed ten thousand talents over fifty years, Livy says.33

Cato made the case in the Senate with a prop. Plutarch says he let fall a Libyan fig from the folds of his toga and, as the senators admired its size and beauty, told them that the country where it grew was only three days' sail from Rome.34

Its end came by Roman choice, not military necessity. Plutarch writes that Cato ended every speech in the Senate with the words that Carthage must be destroyed, while Scipio Nasica ended his with the opposite, that Carthage must be spared. Velleius says the city was hateful to the Roman name more because of jealousy of its power than because of any offence at that time.35

The case for Rome

Rome won every war it fought with Carthage, and the last one ended the city. Eutropius says Carthage was destroyed in the seven hundredth year after its founding, and that Scipio Aemilianus returned the spoils Carthage had taken from the cities of Sicily, Italy and Africa to their owners. Velleius says the city had stood for 672 years.36

The destruction was total. Appian describes six days and nights of fighting in the streets before the citadel surrendered, and Florus says the fire, lit by the defenders themselves, burned for seventeen days.37

Painting of Roman soldiers working a large catapult against the walls of a city
The Catapult by Edward Poynter, 1868: Roman soldiers work a siege engine against the walls of Carthage. Public domain

How historians have judged them

Ancient writers mostly explained the result from Rome's side. Polybius' account, quoted above, put it down to the Roman constitution and citizen army. Velleius blamed jealousy for the final destruction, and Florus marvelled at how Rome rose after Cannae as if from the dead.38

Although they met with complete disaster, they were finally by the wisdom of their counsels victorious over the Carthaginians in the war. Polybius, Histories 6.51

Mommsen thought the two powers equally matched when the struggle began, but argued that Carthage could never make up for the lack of a land army and of allies of its own, and that an invasion that only began a war in Italy ended one in Libya by turning it into a siege. Treccani, by contrast, stresses Hannibal's misjudgement of the Italian federation and Rome's economic motives in the last war: the wish to remove a trading rival and to find new land.39

Modern work has turned to the allies. Fronda, as Lomas reports, rejects the idea that Rome, Hannibal or other states pursued long-term strategic goals, and reads each Italian city's choice as a local, pragmatic decision. Lomas adds that much of this reconstruction must remain to some extent speculative.40

Battles on the site

Every battle page on the site where Rome and Carthage met, with the guides around them.

See also Hannibal, Scipio Africanus, Hamilcar Barca, Hannibal vs Scipio, the greatest commanders of Carthage and how the Roman legion worked. The sieges of Lilybaeum, Syracuse and Capua have no page of their own yet.

Your verdict

We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide which one you find more convincing.

For Carthage

  • The best fleet and seamen of the western Mediterranean
  • The greatest land victories of the wars, from Tunis to Cannae
  • Wealth that could hire an army almost at will
  • Recovery after two defeats, in Spain and then in trade
  • A history told almost entirely by its enemies

For Rome

  • A navy built from nothing that won the First War at sea
  • A citizen army that refilled after every defeat
  • Italian allies who mostly held after Cannae
  • A Senate that never spoke of peace when it was losing
  • Three wars fought, three wars won

Questions to weigh before you decide:

  1. Does winning the wars decide which state was stronger, or only which could afford to lose more?
  2. Should Carthage be judged by Hannibal's victories in Italy or by its failure to send him enough men?
  3. Was a citizen army an advantage in itself, or only because Rome had so many citizens and allies?
  4. How much of our picture comes from Polybius, a Greek close to the Scipios, and the Roman writers who followed him?
  5. Does the destruction of Carthage in 146 BC tell us about the balance of power, or only about Roman politics?

Frequently asked questions

Was Rome stronger than Carthage?

Historians give different answers. Mommsen thought the two powers equally matched when the struggle began, but argued that Carthage could never make up for its lack of a land army and of allies of its own. Polybius put Rome's victory down to its constitution and citizen army, and Treccani stresses Hannibal's misjudgement of the Italian federation. This page compares the evidence for both sides.

Who won the Punic Wars?

Rome won all three. The First Punic War (264 to 241 BC) ended with the Roman naval victory at the Aegates Islands and Carthage giving up Sicily. The Second (218 to 201 BC) ended with Hannibal's defeat at Zama in 202 BC. In the Third (149 to 146 BC) Scipio Aemilianus took and destroyed Carthage.

Why did Rome win the Punic Wars?

Historians give different answers. Polybius credited the Roman constitution, the Senate and a citizen army against Carthage's mercenaries. Mommsen stressed that Carthage never had a land army of its own and that an invasion of Africa turned any war into a siege. Treccani points to the loyalty of most of Rome's Italian allies. This page sets out the evidence for both sides.

Was Carthage stronger at sea than Rome?

At the start, yes. Polybius says the Carthaginians were superior at sea because seamanship had long been their national craft, and Rome had almost no fleet in 264 BC. Rome built one on a captured Carthaginian model, used a boarding bridge to fight as if on land, and won at Mylae in 260 and the Aegates in 241 BC.

How many Romans died at Cannae?

The sources disagree. Polybius gives about seventy thousand Roman dead, Livy 45,500 infantry and 2,700 cavalry, and Eutropius forty thousand foot and 3,500 horse.

What did Carthage have to pay Rome?

In 241 BC 3,200 talents over ten years, after Roman commissioners hardened the first terms of 2,200 talents over twenty years, and the islands between Sicily and Italy. In 201 BC 10,000 talents over fifty years, its warships except ten triremes, its elephants, 100 hostages and the right to make war without Rome's consent.

Why did Rome destroy Carthage in 146 BC?

Plutarch says Cato ended every speech with the words that Carthage must be destroyed, while Scipio Nasica argued it should be spared. Velleius wrote that Carthage was hateful to Rome more from jealousy of its power than from any offence at the time. Treccani adds economic motives and the provocation of Masinissa.

How long did the Punic Wars last?

The three wars ran from 264 to 146 BC, with long gaps of peace. Polybius calls the first, which lasted twenty-four years without a break, the longest, most continuous and greatest war he knew of.

Notes

A number in the text points to a note. Each note names the works that paragraph draws on, listed in full under Sources.

  1. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. ↩
  2. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, “Glass head pendant”. ↩
  3. Livy, “Periochae 16 to 20”. Polybius, “The Histories”. ↩
  4. Florus, “Epitome of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  5. Frontinus, “Stratagems”. ↩
  6. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. Frontinus, “Stratagems”. ↩
  7. Livy, “Periochae 16 to 20”. ↩
  8. Polybius, “The Histories”. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. ↩
  9. Bret Mulligan, “Chronology of Hannibal's Life”. ↩
  10. Bret Mulligan, “Chronology of Hannibal's Life”. ↩
  11. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Appian, “The Punic Wars”. Florus, “Epitome of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  12. Polybius, “The Histories”. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. ↩
  13. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. ↩
  14. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. ↩
  15. Livy, “The History of Rome”. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. ↩
  16. Bret Mulligan, “Chronology of Hannibal's Life”. ↩
  17. Polybius, “The Histories”. Plutarch, “Life of Cato the Elder”. ↩
  18. Bret Mulligan, “Chronology of Hannibal's Life”. ↩
  19. Plutarch, “Life of Cato the Elder”. ↩
  20. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Bret Mulligan, “Chronology of Hannibal's Life”. ↩
  21. Florus, “Epitome of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  22. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. ↩
  23. Polybius, “The Histories”. ↩
  24. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. Livy, “Periochae 16 to 20”. ↩
  25. Polybius, “The Histories”. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. ↩
  26. Bret Mulligan, “Chronology of Hannibal's Life”. Kathryn Lomas, “Between Rome and Carthage”. ↩
  27. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. ↩
  28. Frontinus, “Stratagems”. Livy, “The History of Rome”. ↩
  29. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. ↩
  30. Cornelius Nepos, “Hannibal”. ↩
  31. Polybius, “The Histories”. Livy, “The History of Rome”. ↩
  32. Florus, “Epitome of Roman History, Book I”. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. ↩
  33. Polybius, “The Histories”. Livy, “The History of Rome”. ↩
  34. Plutarch, “Life of Cato the Elder”. ↩
  35. Plutarch, “Life of Cato the Elder”. Velleius Paterculus, “Compendium of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  36. Eutropius, “Breviarium, Books II to IV”. Velleius Paterculus, “Compendium of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  37. Appian, “The Punic Wars”. Florus, “Epitome of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  38. Velleius Paterculus, “Compendium of Roman History, Book I”. Florus, “Epitome of Roman History, Book I”. ↩
  39. Theodor Mommsen, “The History of Rome, Book III”. Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, “Puniche, guerre”. ↩
  40. Kathryn Lomas, “Between Rome and Carthage”. ↩

Sources

Battles that changed the world

The turning points of history

Marathon, Gaugamela, Cannae, Constantinople, Waterloo, Stalingrad: the days the world changed course.

The same choice for every reader · why? ·

Relive the battles

Echoes of Battle brings 40 of history's greatest battles to life with narration, with a real-time tactical mode in the works. Subscribe below for new battle stories, and we will send word to your inbox the day it launches.