Washington or Cornwallis: what does the evidence say?
George Washington (1732 to 1799) commanded the Continental Army for the whole of the American Revolutionary War. Charles, Earl Cornwallis (1738 to 1805) was one of the most active British generals in it, for years as a subordinate of Howe and Clinton. Their armies met from Long Island in 1776 to Yorktown in 1781, where Cornwallis surrendered. Historians have not settled it. Stephen Brumwell writes that Washington cannot be rated an outstanding battlefield commander. John Bew calls Cornwallis one of Britain's most important generals, but no undiscovered military or strategic genius. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
The record between them is mixed. Cornwallis chased Washington across New Jersey in 1776 and turned his flank at Brandywine in 1777, and Washington slipped away from him by night before Princeton and trapped him at Yorktown four years later. John Bew, writing in 2014, calls Cornwallis the man who lost America, despite doing a better job than all of his predecessors, and notes that the surrender at Yorktown effectively signalled the end of the war.1
This is not a ranking. Below are the two careers side by side, the campaigns in which they actually met, and six questions on which a general can be judged, each with the strongest evidence for Washington and for Cornwallis, their own letters and the views of the historians who have weighed them. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
Charles, Earl CornwallisBritish Army- Lived
- 22 February 1732 to 14 December 1799
- 31 December 1738 to 5 October 1805
- Origin
- Popes Creek, Virginia, a planter family
- Grosvenor Square, London, eldest son of the first Earl Cornwallis
- Training
- Surveyor, then Virginia militia officer from 1752
- Eton, a military academy in Turin, ensign in the Grenadier Guards at 18
- Command in this war
- Commander in chief of the Continental Army, commissioned 19 June 1775, resigned 23 December 1783
- Senior commander under Howe and Clinton 1776 to 1778, commander in the South from 1780
- Battles named here
- Long Island, Trenton, Princeton, Brandywine, Monmouth, Yorktown
- Brandywine, Monmouth, Camden, Guilford Courthouse, Yorktown
- After the war
- First President of the United States, two terms
- Governor general of India, lord lieutenant of Ireland
- Death
- At Mount Vernon, Virginia
- In India
Dates, origins and commands from the National Park Service, the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, the Library of Congress and the American Battlefield Trust. No source we read gives a win and loss total for either man, so we give none.2
Where they met
New York and New Jersey, 1776
Around 22,000 British troops landed on Long Island in August 1776, the National Army Museum writes, and in the battle that followed Washington's soldiers were driven back and evacuated to Manhattan. None of the sources we read settles how large a part Cornwallis played in that battle. Stephen Brumwell, in Encyclopedia Virginia, writes that the defeat undermined Washington's faith in his troops and his readiness to fight the British in open battle.3
In November and December Cornwallis led the pursuit of Washington's retreating army across New Jersey. Howe praised to London the ability and conduct he displayed in the pursuit from Fort Lee to Trenton, a distance exceeding eighty miles. Charles Ross, who edited Cornwallis's papers in 1859, adds that Cornwallis had orders not to advance beyond Brunswick and arrived at Trenton on 3 December just in time to see the last boat crossing to the opposite bank.4
Assunpink Creek and Princeton, January 1777
On 26 December Washington's men took more than 1,000 Hessian prisoners at Trenton, the National Army Museum notes, and Cornwallis marched to retake the town. Washington reported to Congress that our situation was most critical, and our force small. On 2 January 1777 the British tried to cross the Assunpink Creek but, finding the fords guarded, halted and kindled their fires. At midnight, after renewing his own fires, Washington marched round by a back road to Princeton, a move, he wrote, that would avoid the appearance of a retreat.5
At Princeton on 3 January he beat a British force under Colonel Mawhood that was marching to join the main army. The American Battlefield Trust gives about 4,500 Americans against 1,200 British and losses of 75 and 270, while Washington's own estimate was that the British must have lost five hundred men, with near three hundred prisoners. The Trust sums it up: Washington had stolen a march on Cornwallis.6

Brandywine and Monmouth, 1777 and 1778
At Brandywine on 11 September 1777, in Ross's words, Cornwallis was detached with a strong corps to turn the enemy's flank, which he effected with little difficulty. Washington wrote to Congress that midnight that his intelligence of the crossing had been uncertain and contradictory, and that we have been obliged to leave the enemy masters of the field.7
The losses are given differently. The Trust counts 14,600 Americans and 15,500 British and Hessians, with losses of 1,300 and 587. The National Army Museum puts the British loss at 550 killed and wounded and the American at around 1,000. The defeat let the British occupy Philadelphia, though the Trust notes that most of Washington's army survived.8
At Monmouth on 28 June 1778 Cornwallis commanded the rear of Clinton's army as it marched from Philadelphia to New York, and attacked Greene's division before he was repulsed. Washington met troops fleeing under Charles Lee, removed Lee from command and carried on the fight. The Trust calls the battle inconclusive, with about 325 American and 381 British losses, and the museum a stalemate after which the British continued their march.9
The South without Washington, 1780 and 1781
Cornwallis then fought his own campaign in the Carolinas. At Camden on 16 August 1780 he defeated Horatio Gates. The museum puts the American loss there at 1,000 killed, wounded or captured, with another 132 missing, and the British at 313 killed and wounded and 64 missing. He went on to fight Nathanael Greene at Guilford Courthouse, and after meeting strong resistance in the Carolinas, the National Park Service writes, he decided that one way to lessen it was to knock Virginia out of the war.10
Yorktown, September and October 1781
Cornwallis reached Virginia on 20 May 1781, Christa Dierksheide and Woody Holton write in Encyclopedia Virginia, and later fortified Yorktown and Gloucester, facing each other across the York River. He had chosen them as a harbour that could shelter ships of the line, and in May he had written that he was inclined to think well of York. A French fleet under de Grasse came up from the West Indies, and the siege ran from 28 September to 19 October. On 9 October the allies opened a massive artillery bombardment, and after about a week of it his men were cut off and short of food.11
The numbers differ widely by source. The Park Service gives the allies about 16,000, made up of 5,500 Continentals, 3,000 Virginia militia and 7,600 French, against half that number of British. The National Army Museum gives a Franco-American force of 17,000, and the Trust 19,900 allies against 9,000 British. Cornwallis asked for terms on 17 October and his army marched out on the 19th. The museum adds that he had fallen back on Yorktown short of supplies, hoping the Royal Navy would support him, and that the arrival of the French fleet in Chesapeake Bay in September sealed his fate.12
The count of the surrender differs too. On 19 October Washington told Congress that the reduction of the British army under Lord Cornwallis was most happily effected and expected between five and six thousand prisoners exclusive of seamen. His official return, as the historian Henry Johnston reported in 1881, came to 7,247 men and 840 seamen. Johnston gives British losses during the siege, as published by the British themselves, as 156 killed and 326 wounded, and the American loss as 20 killed and 56 wounded.13
At the surrender General O'Hara led the British instead of Cornwallis, who pleaded illness, Johnston writes, and he was referred to General Benjamin Lincoln, who returned his sword.14

Strategy
The case for Washington
Washington's strategy was to keep the army in being. At the start of 1777 he explained that to fall back from Trenton would destroy every dawn of hope, which had begun to revive among the people, and so he took the risk of standing on the Assunpink and then struck at Princeton. In 1781 he joined the French army and fleet to trap a whole British army, and in his report he paid tribute to the distinguished aid and support of de Grasse and his fleet.15
The case for Cornwallis
Cornwallis looked for a way to end the southern war. His decision to march into Virginia, the Park Service writes, came from the view that the resistance in the Carolinas would only end if Virginia were knocked out of the war. His superior saw it otherwise. Sir Henry Clinton wrote in 1783 that Cornwallis's march into Virginia, made without consulting his commander in chief, forced the British into operations there, though he also blamed the defeat ultimately on the want of a covering fleet in the Chesapeake.16
On the battlefield
The case for Washington
Brumwell, in Encyclopedia Virginia, calls the ten day Trenton and Princeton campaign the high point of Washington's military career, and says that Monmouth, though indecisive, vindicated Steuben's training. He is also blunt about the defeats. Washington, he writes, cannot be rated as an outstanding battlefield commander, at New York he accepted bad advice instead of following his own convictions, and Brandywine was a tactical defeat, though one that barely dented the army's morale. Of Germantown three weeks later Washington himself wrote that the day was rather unfortunate, than injurious.17
The case for Cornwallis
Brandywine was a British victory with Cornwallis's flank march at its centre, as Ross records, and at Camden he defeated Gates. At Guilford Courthouse, in Lord George Germain's words in a letter of June 1781 that Ross prints, he gained a glorious victory.18
Marches and escapes
The case for Washington
Washington's escapes are among the best known moves of the war. He took his army off Long Island across the East River in one night without losing a single life, the Trust records, and two nights after Trenton he left his fires burning on the Assunpink and marched round Cornwallis to Princeton. Brumwell notes that he did so although a cautiously defensive war of posts, always shunning a potentially disastrous battle, ran against his aggressive instincts.19
The case for Cornwallis
Cornwallis was a fast and aggressive pursuer when he was allowed to be, as his eighty mile chase across New Jersey in 1776 showed. His own escape failed when it mattered most. Brumwell judges that at Yorktown, heavily outnumbered and facing a siege in which French gunnery and engineering expertise were decisive, his surrender was inevitable. Yorktown, Brumwell concludes, broke Britain's resolve to retain America.20
Keeping an army
The case for Washington
Washington kept an army in the field for eight years, through defeat after defeat. After Brandywine he was frank with Congress about the loss and closed his letter with the hope that another time we shall compensate for the losses now sustained.21
The case for Cornwallis
Cornwallis held his army together through a long war of marches in the Carolinas, and after Yorktown he tried to protect the loyalists who had served with him. Ross records that Washington let the sloop Bonetta sail to New York unexamined, so that the loyalists most at risk could escape.22
Masters and allies
The case for Washington
Washington answered to Congress for eight years and reported to it after every battle, from Princeton to Yorktown. The Library of Congress records that it commissioned him on 19 June 1775 and that he took command at Cambridge on 3 July. Congress chose him, the guide explains, partly for his military experience and partly because a Virginian at the head of the army might help unite the colonies. When the war was won he gave the command back. On 23 December 1783 he came before Congress at Annapolis to resign his commission, the Maryland State Archives records, and left at once for Mount Vernon.23
The case for Cornwallis
Cornwallis spent most of the war as a subordinate, first under Howe and then under Clinton, and the two quarrelled bitterly. Clinton wrote that Cornwallis had gone into Virginia without his approbation and very contrary to his wishes and intentions, and that had he been left to his own plans the campaign of 1781 would not probably have ended unfortunately. Ross traces the dispute through their letters of 1781.24
The Park Service concludes that Cornwallis did not share in the blame for Yorktown and that his reputation did not suffer. He was paroled immediately after the surrender.25
What came after
The case for Washington
Washington went on to be the first President of the United States, and he died on 14 December 1799, the Park Service records.26
The case for Cornwallis
After Yorktown Cornwallis served as governor general of India and lord lieutenant of Ireland, the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography records. Bew reports Andrew O'Shaughnessy's view that he enjoyed the most successful postwar career of any of the British generals who served in America, and writes that the man who lost America secured India for the British Empire. He died in India on 5 October 1805.27

How historians have judged them
The argument over Yorktown began at once, between the two British generals. Clinton's Narrative of 1783 blamed Cornwallis's march into Virginia and, in the end, the want of a covering fleet in the Chesapeake.28
Henry Johnston's study of the Yorktown campaign, published in 1881, uses the official returns of both sides and shows how far the counts of the surrendered army differ. Dierksheide and Holton give roughly 8,000 British, Loyalist and Hessian prisoners, and add that the nearly 4,000 enslaved people seized by Cornwallis's forces received no protection as prisoners of war.29
Bew, reviewing O'Shaughnessy's The Men Who Lost America, argues that Cornwallis was one of Britain's most important generals and certainly one of the most politically able, though he has no great, iconic victories to his name, and adds that no British historian has ever attempted a comprehensive biography of him. He is careful not to overstate the case: Cornwallis was not, he writes, some sort of undiscovered military or strategic genius.30
Battles on the site
Every battle page on the site that involves either man, with the guides that set them in context.
Washington in command · 1776Battle of Long Island
Washington's army · 1776Fort Washington
Washington in command · 1776Battle of Trenton
Both in command · 1776 to 1777The Ten Crucial Days
Both in the campaign · 1777Battle of Princeton
Both present · 1777Battle of Brandywine
Both present · 1777Battle of Germantown
Both present · 1778Battle of Monmouth
Cornwallis in command · 1780Battle of Camden
Cornwallis's campaign · 1780Battle of Kings Mountain
Cornwallis's campaign · 1781Battle of Cowpens
Cornwallis in command · 1781Battle of Guilford Courthouse
Decided Yorktown · 1781Battle of the Chesapeake
Both in command · 1781Siege of Yorktown
Washington in command · 1776Washington Crossing the Delaware
Washington's first fight · 1754Jumonville Glen
CommanderGeorge Washington
Guide · 1775 to 1783The American Revolutionary War
RankingThe Greatest American Commanders
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide between them.
For Washington
- An army kept in being for eight years, through defeats
- The night escapes from Long Island and the Assunpink
- Princeton, a victory snatched from a trap
- Yorktown, a whole British army taken with French help
- He handed back his command when the war was won
For Cornwallis
- The eighty mile pursuit across New Jersey
- The flank march that won Brandywine
- Camden and Guilford Courthouse in the South
- He often served under superiors who held him back
- A career that recovered in India and Ireland
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Washington lost Long Island and Brandywine but kept his army. Is survival a victory?
- Cornwallis was often a subordinate. How much of 1776 to 1778 is his own credit or blame?
- Does Yorktown measure Washington's skill, the French navy's, or Cornwallis's choice of post?
- Should a general be judged by one war, or by a whole career?
- The figures for Yorktown differ widely. How much does the exact size of the trap change the story?
Cast your vote below and see how other readers have judged them.







