Grant or Lee: what does the evidence say?
Ulysses S. Grant (1822 to 1885) and Robert E. Lee (1807 to 1870) were the leading generals of the Union and the Confederacy. They faced each other for eleven months, from the Wilderness in May 1864 to Appomattox in April 1865, and that campaign ended with Lee's surrender. Historians have not settled it. Freeman's life of Lee is the classic of the tradition sympathetic to the South, while Fuller came to the opposite conclusion. Greene, in Encyclopedia Virginia, concludes that Grant's generalship deserves all of the praise posterity gave it and only a portion of the criticism. This page sets out the evidence for each and leaves the final verdict to you.
Before 1864 they fought in different theatres. Lee won his great victories in Virginia, Grant his in the West, where he took the surrender of a whole Confederate force at Fort Donelson and of Pemberton's army at Vicksburg. In early 1864, the historian Joan Waugh writes, Lincoln named Grant lieutenant general, and he chose to travel with the Army of the Potomac, which George Meade still commanded, with Lee's army as its objective.1
This is not a ranking. Below are the two careers side by side, the campaign in which they actually met, and six questions on which a general can be judged, each with the strongest evidence for Grant and for Lee, their own words and those of the historians who have argued about them for a century and a half. At the end the decision is yours.
Side by side
- Lived
- 27 April 1822 to 23 July 1885
- 19 January 1807 to 12 October 1870
- Origin
- Point Pleasant, Ohio
- Stratford Hall, Virginia, son of the Revolutionary officer Light-Horse Harry Lee
- Trained at
- West Point, 21st in a class of 39
- West Point, class of 1829, second in his class
- Highest command
- General in chief of the Union armies from March 1864
- Army of Northern Virginia from June 1862, general in chief of the Confederate armies from February 1865
- Wars
- The Mexican War, the Civil War
- The Mexican War, the Civil War
- Battles named here
- Fort Donelson, Shiloh, Vicksburg, the Wilderness, Cold Harbor, Petersburg
- Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, Gettysburg, the Wilderness, Cold Harbor, Petersburg
- After the war
- Eighteenth President of the United States, 1869 to 1877
- President of Washington College, Lexington, from 1865
- Death
- Mount McGregor, New York
- Lexington, Virginia
Dates, origins and commands from the Miller Center and Encyclopedia Virginia. No source we read gives a win and loss total for either man, so we give none.2
Where they met: Virginia, May 1864 to April 1865
Before 1864: the same army in Mexico
Their careers first touched in the Mexican War, on the same side. Lee served on the staff of General Winfield Scott from 1847 and fought at Vera Cruz, Cerro Gordo and Chapultepec, Elizabeth Brown Pryor writes in Encyclopedia Virginia. Grant fought in the same war from 1846 to 1848 and was twice cited for bravery, Waugh notes, and he resigned from the army in 1854.3
The plan and the command
Grant's letter to Meade of 9 April 1864, which he printed in his memoirs, set the Army of the Potomac its task inside a larger plan: Sherman was to move against Johnston's army, Banks against Mobile, Butler and Sigel towards Richmond and the Virginia railways, and Meade against Lee. Grant kept Meade in command after Meade offered to step aside, and wrote that he gave all orders for the army's movements to Meade to have them executed. He admitted that Meade's position afterwards proved embarrassing to me if not to him. Meade had seen that coming. On 13 April he wrote to his wife that if the campaign succeeded his share of the credit would be less than if Grant were not present.4

The Wilderness and Spotsylvania, May 1864
The armies met in the tangled woods of the Wilderness on 5 May. The National Park Service gives the forces as 101,895 Union and 61,025 Confederate, and the losses as 18,000 and 10,800. The American Battlefield Trust gives the same strengths but puts the losses at 17,000 and 13,000. Both call the battle indecisive. What changed was the next move: Grant did not retreat as the Union generals before him had done, and on 7 May he marched south towards Spotsylvania Court House.5
At Spotsylvania, from 8 to 21 May, Emory Upton broke briefly into the Confederate line on the 10th with twelve regiments packed into a column, and on the 12th about 20,000 men of Hancock's corps struck the salient known as the Mule Shoe, where the fighting at the Bloody Angle lasted 22 hours. The National Park Service says that attack captured nearly a division of Lee's army. The casualty counts differ again: 18,399 Union and 12,687 Confederate in the Trust's figures, 18,000 and 9,000 in the Park Service's.6
In the middle of it, on 11 May, Grant wrote to Halleck the sentence that became his signature: I purpose to fight it out on this line if it takes all summer.7
North Anna and Cold Harbor, May and June 1864
At the North Anna, from 23 to 26 May, Lee drew his line into an inverted V that kept the two Union wings apart. The National Park Service writes that the battle mattered not so much for what happened but for what did not happen: illness and fatigue kept Lee from striking, and each side lost about 2,000 men. The Trust counts 2,600 Union and 1,600 Confederate losses. Grant moved east around him.8
Cold Harbor followed. At 4.30 in the morning of 3 June three Union corps attacked Lee's entrenchments through darkness and fog. The Trust estimates that 7,000 men were killed or wounded in the first 30 minutes and that Grant called off the attack at 12.30.9
The figures for that morning are disputed. Douglas Southall Freeman, Lee's biographer, wrote that more than 7,000 of Grant's men were hit and that Lee's losses had not exceeded 1,200 to 1,500. The Official Records, quoted in Meade's published letters, give Union losses from 2 to 10 June as 13,153.10
Over the whole Overland Campaign, the Trust counts 55,000 Union and 33,000 Confederate casualties in a month of fighting, while Pryor writes that Lee's army lost some 35,000. On the night of 12 June the Union army left its trenches and marched for the James River and Petersburg.11
Petersburg and Appomattox, June 1864 to April 1865
Petersburg became a siege of 292 days. Even its scale is counted in two ways: the National Park Service speaks of eight offensives and over 70,000 casualties, the Trust of nine offensives and some 42,000 Union and 28,000 Confederate casualties, with Union strength nearly two to one for most of the campaign. It included the disaster of the Crater on 30 July 1864, which Grant called the saddest affair he had witnessed in the war, and Lee's failed attack on Fort Stedman on 25 March 1865. On 2 April the Union Sixth Corps broke through, and Lee abandoned Petersburg and Richmond that night.12
A week later Lee was trapped near Appomattox Court House. On 9 April the two generals met in Wilmer McLean's house, where Lee sat in a caned armchair and Grant signed the terms at a small spool-turned table, both now in the Smithsonian.13
The terms let the officers keep their side arms, horses and baggage and sent every man home on parole. The National Park Service records 28,231 paroles signed and issued before 15 April.14

Strategy: the war as a whole
The case for Grant
Grant planned for the whole Union. His letter of April 1864 coordinated armies from Georgia to Virginia and aimed Meade at Lee's army, not at Richmond, and Waugh calls him the first Union commander to truly take the war to the South. The British general and historian J. F. C. Fuller, who began as an admirer of Lee, called Grant in 1933 the greatest general of his age and one of the greatest strategists of any age.15
The case for Lee
James McPherson argues that Lee was the only Confederate commander whose victories had some potential for winning the war. Lee also knew what held him back. In October 1863 he wrote to the secretary of war that nothing prevented him from continuing in the enemy's front but the destitute condition of his men. Fuller judged the other way: Lee was no grand strategist, he wrote, for he refused to be influenced by policy or to influence it.16
Attack and defence
The case for Grant
At Spotsylvania Grant's army broke into Lee's entrenchments twice, with Upton's column on 10 May and Hancock's mass attack on the Mule Shoe two days later. His critics point to Cold Harbor. Grant wrote in his memoirs that he always regretted that the last assault there was ever made, and set it beside the assault of 22 May 1863 at Vicksburg.17
The case for Lee
In 1864 Lee fought mostly on the defensive, and his biographer Freeman quotes Lee's aide Colonel Venable on Cold Harbor: perhaps the easiest victory ever granted to the Confederate arms by the folly of the Federal commanders. Freeman is frank about the failures on Lee's side too. Of the opening days at Cold Harbor he writes that liaison between Anderson and Hoke was incredibly bad, and Hoke did nothing.18
Manoeuvre
The case for Grant
After every check Grant moved on: after the Wilderness to Spotsylvania, after the North Anna around Lee's flank, and after Cold Harbor, as his letter of 5 June shows, he planned to take the army south of the James and lay siege to Lee rather than make more costly assaults, and in six weeks the Army of the Potomac went from the Rapidan to the gates of Petersburg.19
The case for Lee
Lee met each move with a smaller army, from the inverted V at the North Anna to the trenches of Cold Harbor. Meade saw what that meant. On 19 May he wrote to his wife that Grant had thought it useless to knock their heads against a brick wall, and on 5 June that Grant had had his eyes opened about Lee's army.20
The cost in men
The case for Grant
Grant was called a butcher. Waugh writes that the name came from Democratic newspapers after the heavy losses of 1864. McPherson answers that of all army commanders on both sides, Lee's troops suffered the highest percentage of casualties, yet it was Grant who acquired the label. He sets Cold Harbor, where the Union lost about 7,000 in less than an hour, beside Pickett's Charge at Gettysburg, where the Confederates lost about the same.21
The case for Lee
Lee's side made the opposite argument from the start. His adjutant Walter Taylor wrote that the Army of Northern Virginia had put out of action a number of Grant's men equal to its own entire strength at the start of the campaign, and William Swinton put the Union loss at Cold Harbor at more than thirteen thousand. Both are quoted in the collection of Lee's letters published by his son.22
Command
The case for Grant
Grant held the whole Union command and still kept Meade at the head of the Army of the Potomac. He explained it in his memoirs: it is men who wait to be selected, and not those who seek, from whom we may always expect the most efficient service. The arrangement worked, though not without friction. In June Meade complained to his wife that the papers were giving Grant all the credit for what they called successes.23
The case for Lee
Lee commanded one army and only became general in chief of all the Confederate armies in February 1865, when Jefferson Davis gave him the post, as Pryor records. Fuller adds a criticism of method: he doubted whether, in Grant's place, Lee would have done half as well as Grant.24
The end and after
The case for Grant
At Appomattox Grant wrote terms that let the Confederate soldiers go home. He recalled in his memoirs that he felt like anything rather than rejoicing at the downfall of a foe who had fought so long and valiantly, and suffered so much for a cause which he believed one of the worst for which a people ever fought. As president from 1869 to 1877 he was less fortunate. Greene describes an administration racked by corruption and scandal.25

The case for Lee
Lee's farewell order of 10 April told his men that the army had been compelled to yield to overwhelming numbers and resources, and that he had consented to the result from no distrust of them. He then served as president of Washington College in Lexington from 1865 until his death in 1870, Washington and Lee University records, and after his death the college took his name.26

How historians have judged them
For decades after the war, writers sympathetic to the South set the terms. Lee's general order spoke of overwhelming numbers, and his officers' accounts, like Taylor's, measured the war by Grant's losses. Freeman's multi-volume life of Lee, published in the 1930s, is the classic of that tradition.27
The reaction came from several directions. Fuller wrote in his preface that he had once accepted the view of Lee as one of the greatest generals and came to the opposite conclusion.28
Thomas Connelly's study of 1977 traced how the image of Lee was built after the war, and Alan Nolan's Lee Considered of 1991 argued that Lee's offensive strategy prolonged the war and cost the South men it could not replace. McPherson, reviewing Nolan, called the book a useful corrective but disagreed that the Confederate cause was hopeless before Lincoln's re-election in 1864.29
Greene, in Encyclopedia Virginia, concludes that Grant's generalship deserves all of the praise accorded it by posterity and only a portion of the criticism. Pryor, in the same encyclopedia, sets out both views of Lee: the bold tactician and inspiring leader of his admirers, and the commander whose strategic judgment and losses his critics question.30
Battles on the site
Every battle page on the site that involves either man, with the guides that set them in context.
Both in command · 1864Battle of the Wilderness
Both in command · 1864Battle of Spotsylvania Court House
Both in command · 1864Battle of Cold Harbor
Both in command · 1864 to 1865Siege of Petersburg
Both in command · 1865Appomattox Court House
Same side · 1847Battle of Chapultepec
Grant in command · 1861Battle of Belmont
Grant in command · 1862Battle of Fort Donelson
Grant in command · 1862Battle of Shiloh
Grant in command · 1863Siege of Vicksburg
Lee in command · 1862The Seven Days Battles
Lee in command · 1862Battle of Antietam
Lee in command · 1862Battle of Fredericksburg
Lee in command · 1863Battle of Chancellorsville
Lee in command · 1863Battle of Gettysburg
Grant's strategy · 1864Sherman's March to the Sea
CommanderUlysses S. Grant
CommanderRobert E. Lee
GuideThe Eastern Theater
GuideThe Western Theater
Guide · 1861 to 1865The American Civil War
RankingThe Greatest American Commanders
Your verdict
We do not pick a winner. Here are the two cases at their strongest, and the questions that decide between them.
For Grant
- Fort Donelson, Vicksburg and Chattanooga in the West
- A plan for the whole Union war, with Lee's army as the objective
- He never retreated after a check in 1864
- Lee's army pinned at Petersburg and forced to surrender within a year
- Generous terms at Appomattox
For Lee
- Victories in Virginia that gave the Confederacy its best hope
- A smaller, hungrier army that met every Union move in 1864
- Defensive skill at the North Anna and Cold Harbor
- He held Petersburg for 292 days at odds of nearly two to one
- He took responsibility for defeat, at Gettysburg and at the end
Questions to weigh before you decide:
- Is a general judged by the result of the war he was given, or by what he did with the army he had?
- Do absolute losses or losses as a share of the army tell you more about who spent his men freely?
- Does Cold Harbor outweigh the manoeuvres that took Grant from the Rapidan to Petersburg in six weeks?
- How much credit belongs to Meade and the Army of the Potomac rather than to Grant?
- Should Lee be judged against Grant alone, or against the whole Union strategy he could not answer?
- Which counts more for you: winning battles, or understanding what the war required?
Cast your vote below and see how other readers have judged them.








